Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Religion of Peace? by Jamie Glazov

By CosmicConservative
Here's an interview everyone should read.
FrontPage magazine.com :: Religion of Peace? by Jamie Glazov It was only in the West that religious power developed in parallel with secular power but distinct from it thanks largely to the doctrinal distinction in Christianity between giving 'to Caesar what is Caesar's and to God's what is God's.' While religious and secular power have certainly commingled at times in the West, it is fully possible for the two to coexist separately. But in Islam, there has never been a distinction between religion and political power; the two are inseparably united. An Islamic society is invariably a theocracy ruled by Sharia (Islamic) law, which is understood as God's prescribed legal code for all mankind, based on the commandments of the Koran and the precedents set by Muhammad.
One of the most compelling quotes from the story is this:
The facile way in which politicians, commentators, and academics dismiss Islam as a 'religion of peace' indicated to us that there was more that needed to be said on the topic. The Muslim terrorists claim to be doing the will of Allah, while Western leaders insist that Islam is peaceful. The obvious question was: who is right? There is no a priori justification to assume that peaceful Muslims represent authentic Islam while violent Muslims do not.
The premise here is one I've heard from other sources and goes something like this: "If Islamic fundamentalists go about routinely telling the world that their religion demands that all other religions be subservient, and all humanity should be held to sharia law, why do we simply assume that they are misrepresenting their religion? Don't they know their own religion better than we do?" The quick and common answer from "reasonable moderates" to this sort of claim is "well, isn't that more or less exactly how the Catholic Church imposed its own will on Europe for centuries? How is it any different with Islam? Sure there are radical elements, but this radical fundamentalist boil in Islam will be lanced soon enough and we'll all be able to sit at the table together." I'm one of those who can see both sides of this argument. I know many Muslim individuals and I have to say that in general I have been very impressed with them, both in terms of their personal integrity and their general ability to get along with other cultures. Since my own direct experience with Muslims has been almost universally positive, I tend towards the "this is the Islamic version of the Spanish Inquisition" side of the argument and I too think it will pass when certain economic and cultural conditions are rectified by the inexorable march of history. But as I said, I can see both sides. What do you think?

Comments (19)

mtnlurker
I just wonder if the rest of the world will survive until this passes.
Drax
Unless and until there are no states which are Islamic theocracies, it will not pass. Since the West is unwilling to do what is necessary to dethrone the Crazy Islamic Dictators, it is unlikely that these theocracies will fade into memory. It's going to get worse before it gets even worse.
CosmicConservative
I dunno.... There are some extraordinarily powerful cultural forces at play on this planet right now. Islamic fundamentalism is definitely one of them. But it's not the only one, and I doubt that it is the dominant one. I would say that the dominant one continues to be technological advancement. Others are the continued march of democracy and the continued dominance of the free market. See, the thing is, as much as I am concerned about the Islamist movement and its obvious potential for personal danger, I see that the three our four dominant cultural forces in play are not only more powerful than Islamic fundamentalism, they are in direct opposition to it. In fact, that's what I think is driving the Islamist movement. It is a base recognition of the threat that today's cultural evolution has on religious fundamentalism of all stripes. I felt this way already before reading Kurzweil's book, but after reading it I am more convinced than ever that the current wave of Islamist fundamentalist terrorism is a last, desperate attempt of theocratic authorities to impose their will on a world that every day finds it harder to believe in religious fundamentalism. So in the long run I remain completely optimistic that reason will triumph over superstition. But the short run, as you say, is going to be ugly.
Dadman
But can reason triumph over apocalyptic fanaticism (armed with nuclear weapons) and the seemingly waning resolve of Western civilization to stand up against it. When I consider what is happening in an historical context it is clear that strong societies - societies like ours - eventually lose their way and become weak making them susceptible to tyrannical forces. I fear that Western societies may indeed be in decline with Islam eagerly waiting in the wings to assume the mantle of world domination. In such a world I'm not confident free market, technological or secular forces can save us. I hope I'm wrong, but I'm concerned about The Dark Ages Part Deux ushered in by fanatical Islam and Western democracies unwilling to fight. Perhaps I should read Kurzweil's book for a little dose of optimism...
CosmicConservative
I'm not sure I'd call "The Singularity is Near" and "optimistic" book. In fact in many ways it is far more frightening than the prospect of fanatical Islam ruling the earth. At least with a world full of fanatical Islamists, it's a world full of biological human beings. Kurzweil's vision has human beings becoming more or less obsolete in this century. One of the reasons I'm not terribly concerned about Muslim extremists taking over the world is because I'm actually more concerned about a world where our culture is so alien as to be unrecognizable. And I think the latter is actually more likely to happen than the former. The story of Pandora's box is uncannily wise. Technology is what came out of that box, and I don't think it's going back in. And the extrapolation of what technology will do to human beings is quite alarming in many ways. As I said, I think it is in part a reaction to that realization that has sparked a lot of the religious fundamentalism in the world today. Quite frankly I don't think Religion itself will survive the singularity, if it happens even remotely as Kurzweil (and other futurists) envision it. When you have become a god, what do you worship?
Drax
I don't know about therre ever being an "end to religion." Or, more precisely, an end to a "belief in a Supreme Being who takes an active hand in human affairs." We can talk about the rise of a belief in supernatural forces (however the "Godhead" is named) in distant and forgotten memory all day, but I'll, at the end of that day, still believe that the rise of such beliefs originated in a fundamental fear...whether of the unknown...of death...or whatever...but born of fear. This fear, while significantly mitigated in an advanced society (and certainly more advanced in a future society) fear will continue to exist, and, alongside that fear, the NEED to believe that there is someone/something "out there" who is looking out for us.
CosmicConservative
Drax: I'm not sure about that. Perhaps you are right. I have had a book idea in my head on this subject for a couple of years now, but can't make myself put it on paper....
qwerty182764
"The story of Pandora’s box is uncannily wise." I don't know. I don't hold much truck with Greeks and their hubris aversion. I don't think knowledge takes anything away from life in and of itself, and I think in the long run and on average, most people/people-ish-things/robots will use what they have to attempt to better their lives.
qwerty182764
Do you suppose that our curiosity in any point in our history has lead to things which are entirely bad for the people investigating? Did some sort of punishment befall us for figuring out what the earth was, how the solar system worked, how life goes together? No. In each case, our understanding and technology have been a near unadultered boon. Who gains from us not knowing things? Certainly not us.
Dadman
My faith is not a product of fear or wishful thinking. I simply cannot accept a universe that is nothing more than a capricious accident. It makes no sense. Okay, maybe that is wishful thinking, but if I employ Occam's Razor it is simply, in my way of thinking, easier to accept a universe imbued with some kind of overarching purpose, driven by free agency, than it is to accept a universe that literally has no purpose other than what we dream up. I don't mean to provoke a deep metaphysical argument about the meaning of life, the universe and everything else; I'm simply reacting to the notion that faith is nothing more than a reaction to fear, or somehow synonymous to superstition and irrationality.
CosmicConservative
qwerty: I will play devil's advocate and take the Leftist moonbat position and say "You don't think knowledge has hurt us? Are you crazy!" Let me give you a top five list: 1. Global Warming 2. Nuclear bombs 3. Pollution 4. Habitat destruction 5. Overpopulation Now, that's just with what we are capable of doing with our own limited 2 kilogram brains. Once we get artificial intelligence perfected and link our neurons up with near-infinite processing power and memory, what havoc will we wreak? Nanobots are going to turn the entire biosphere of the earth into gray goo. Even if they don't, human beings themselves will cease to exist except as zoo or museum exhibits. I suppose some will find this to be "progress" but most of us humans who can't afford to purchase new nanotech bodies to become immortal will instead simply die off in poverty and squalor as the artificial intelligences compete with the artificially augmented "humans" who may very well have decided to adopt the lifestyle of a cetacean for some reason. That's the "pandora's box" I'm talking about.
CosmicConservative
Dadman: Is it conceivable that at some point in the future what the human race has become (merged with artificial intelligences and reshaped into whatever form they find pleasing) will no longer find the universe to be a frightening and irrational, and instead consider themselves to have mastered this universe? And if they do in fact reach that stage, what role does religion play in such a culture? Let's say that a thousand years from now (and many think that is too large by a factor of 50 or so) "human" beings are no longer biologically constrained at all, can shape matter into whatever thing they want by sheer willpower, can live forever simply by uploading themselves to a digital universe where they can reform a physical body whenever they want to, and they have a thousand times the information processing capacity of today's human brain... In such a universe, what does religion provide? A sense of purpose? Is that all?
Dadman
Forgive me if I am a little skeptical that such a world will ever exist, or that fundamental human nature will be drastically altered by technology..in spite of Mr. Kurzweil's best arguments.
CosmicConservative
I guess it's not Kurzweil that I'm thinking of, Kurzweil actually doesn't suggest that religion will go away. In fact his previous book was titled "The Age of Spiritual Machines" so he seems to think that any intelligence will "divine" a purpose in the universe. I'm just not so sure he's right about that. But this is getting far afield now. I should just get off my lazy behind and write that book.
qwerty182764
"Now, that’s just with what we are capable of doing with our own limited 2 kilogram brains. Once we get artificial intelligence perfected and link our neurons up with near-infinite processing power and memory, what havoc will we wreak? Nanobots are going to turn the entire biosphere of the earth into gray goo. Even if they don’t, human beings themselves will cease to exist except as zoo or museum exhibits. I suppose some will find this to be “progress” but most of us humans who can’t afford to purchase new nanotech bodies to become immortal will instead simply die off in poverty and squalor as the artificial intelligences compete with the artificially augmented “humans” who may very well have decided to adopt the lifestyle of a cetacean for some reason." About that poverty and squalor... The west has left the medieval third world behind these past 300-500 years, developing exponentially by almost every measure. The third world is now as it always has been. It seems like poverty and squalor to us because we've become so incredibly wealthy in comparison, but before the enlightenment, [i]everyone[/i] lived in similar poverty and squalor. Where we interact with each other economically, a sort of "dual economy" has formed. In the countryside, the calandar still reads 600AD. In the cities though, it is possible to get the much decried sweatshop jobs which pay 2-5 times what they could get toiling in a field. The "evil" multi-nationals pay even better than that. It is slowly bringing modernisation to their nations as it did with ours during our own industrial revolution, as capital and wealth builds up to the point where they can afford safer working conditions, better processes, to bargain for even better wages, ect. In any event, my long winded point was that some group being able to attain radical advantage over us normal humans doesn't neccissarily have to make things any worse for us. I don't see why we need to end up any less wealthy because of it than we are now - we still have the same abilities to produce wealth that we always have had. Super-intelligences may have the ability to do far more than that, and so will probably end up a lot richer than us. But if we don't become dangerous to any more powerful association of AIs, if we can keep our envy in check, and as long as all our associations with AIs/genetically engineered humans remain voluntary, then there is no reason why we shouldn't benifit from it.
qwerty182764
If we find ourselves the new "medieval" barbarians in some future world, we have several ways we can react. The way I'd favor is reacting like India, rather than, say, Afghanistan.
qwerty182764
1. Global Warming Paraphrasing some Russian: "Now we can all spend less on hats!" 2. Nuclear bombs How else do you expect us to hollow out that 10 mile wide habitat on the moon? Or move asteroids. Surely you don't advocate wasting the hydrogen to move a decent sized asteroid? 3. Pollution Examined the tradeoff between industry and pre-industry, found to be massively in industry's favor. 4. Habitat destruction 5. Overpopulation Notice that the nations which are technologically advanced and industrialized are the only nations capable of dealing with their population. Population happens anyway. The older methods of dealing with overpopulation were to start a war with someone and get rid of the surplus youth, or simply not take them on as serfs and let them starve to death. In the modern west, we can actually feed them, actually support arbitrary (by today's standards) numbers of people, and end up richer, not poorer for it.
goldenman
It is interesting to read all the blogs about the "meaning of life". For many, many years I, too, searched for the meaning of life. One day I was leafing through Webster's Dictionary and LO!
Drax
Dadman: My assertion was that belief in the supernatural began with a fundamental fear. What "religion" has evolved into over those thousands of years, depending on which religion is embraced, has moved from that fundament in their main teachings while still retaining the element of fear...simply not so prominent as it was while huddling in a cave while the thunder played. This fear, especially in an advanced society, is minimal. We understand so much more, so, there is less to be fearful of. The "unknown" is retreating almost faster than we can follow. However, death, that final unknown, along with "what comes after" will likely be forever unknown, thus, the fear of death (and what comes after) is now, and will continue to be, a great impetus for people to believe in the supernatural, especially a benevolent Godhead which promises rewards after life, and, in most cases, punishment when failing to adhere to the Godhead's proscribed way of life. It is an old canard: "There are no athiests in a foxhole." It is in those moments of fear and dread that even the most hardened athiest may find himself calling upon the supernatural, the Godhead, to protect him or to forgive him for his unbelief. The conversion may be momentary...but it is, in the end, that what created the Godhead in the first place. What we have done with the Godhead in the rational light of day, in the safety of our Libraries, is another question entirely. I'm talking about the creation of it in the first place. Now, if the entire world became technologically advanced and pushed back the boundaries of fear, reduced the suffering of the masses so that they don't rely on promises of a better life after life or fear the punishment of a life ill-spent...then, maybe, only rational religions would survive. I ain't holding my breath.