Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The moon colony

By CosmicConservative
Hmm.... Seems I should comment on the plan proposed by President Bush to establish a permanent inhabited base on the moon. Well, if it were 35 years ago, I'd have assumed that we would already have a permanent moon base (and Mars base) by now since it only took us ten years to get TO the moon the first time. Now that we've completely gutted the space program and thrown pretty much every useful thing it ever did away on two boondoggles (the technically ill-advised Space Shuttle and the politically ill-advised International Space Station), I guess I have to applaud anything that will lead NASA back to what I consider the fundamental issue of space exploitation in the first place. What is that fundamental issue? I hear you asking... Heavy-lift capability to high-earth orbit. The more we have of that, the better. Because when it all comes down to the bottom line, getting as much equipment out of earth's gravity well as we possibly can is quite simply the best thing we can do. Now, would I rather see money invested in a space elevator, or a sky-hook arrangement to augment the heavy lift capability of our rockets? Sure I would. But that doesn't seem to be in the works at the moment (with some notable private exceptions like LiftPort), so if it means rebuilding the Saturn V or creating something like the Saturn V, then I'm all for it. Not because we end up with a moon base, but because we end up with the capability to throw a whole lot of really heavy stuff into high-earth orbit where we can then easily move some of it to the asteroid belt, a raw material gold mine any rational species would be drooling over by now. That's right, drooling over. It will be when the human race begins exploiting the asteroid belt's nearly unimaginable raw materials that things like expeditions to other star systems will seem like a perfectly logical thing to do. I used to think that the size and location of the earth's moon, the incredible wealth of raw materials in the asteroid belt and the huge gas-giant planets of Jupiter and Saturn to provide gravity assisted boosts to spacecraft on their way out of the solar system was too providential to be an accident. And I still wonder about that.... But even if it was designed to make our progression into space as easy and obvious as possible... well, you can lead a horse to water, but you can't make it drink. This horse needs to start drinking.

Comments (7)

Brian
This horse needs to start drinking. Like Heinlein, I'm convinced the species will leave this planet. I am not convinced that the ones that do will speak English or carry Western values with them. The only problem with having the government own the means to get off the planet is that government is subject to flights o' fancy and whim. Have a bad war and loose an election? Bang - turn your big giant rockets into lawn ornaments. Because THAT fixed all of our problems in the 70s all-righty ... I'm not saying 'don't go to the moon' but I am saying that a rational approach would be to have the means of getting around in many and diverse hands, not a single organization.
Brian
I just re-read that. I am of course biased in favor of a free-enterprise approach, both by disposition and my employer.
CosmicConservative
Brian: That's why I made it a point to single out LiftPort as an example of private enterprise which might save us all... But, from government perspective, IF they are going to pursue any space objectives, I want them to at least be pursuing ones that have some hope of turning into high-orbit, heavy lift capability. Who knows, maybe they'll turn around this time and sell it to the private sector when they give up on it.
Brian
Who knows, maybe they’ll turn around this time and sell it to the private sector when they give up on it. Oh, you kidder. Private enterprise (probably) won't be able to run it and make a profit. At least not if the example of Saturn V and Shuttle are any guide. 20,000 people to get a bird in the air does not make for a nice balance sheet.
CosmicConservative
When the moon shots were canceled a lot of private industries did benefit, but not from space exploration. For example: NASA had purchased a large amount of rare (then) glass called fluorite, which is used in camera lenses and other optical devices because of its remarkably low color disperson properties. When the Apollo program was cancelled, a guy named Roland Christen managed to buy all that glass for a song. He now owns one of the most profitable telescope making companies on earth, called "Astro-Physics". I own one of the rarer models of telescopes that Astro-Physics made, a beautiful little gem called the 92mm f7 Stowaway. So even if the entire process isn't profitable, perhaps some private firm could take over the heavy-launch capability and forget the rest of the moon base boondoggle.... Of course that's something of a stretch compared to making telescopes, but who knows...?
qwerty182764
Heavy lift is definitely key. You don't put people or bases into space by making them "smaller, faster, or cheaper". At best, you can do that with a space-probe designed to do one very limited thing. A mining rig? Forget it. Even more important: If all we are ever going to do with space is look at it, then sending up mass-minimized, clean-room checked, fragile little toothpicks of spaceprobes makes sense. But why are we looking? It seems to me that if space is ever going to be useful to mankind, we need to put men up there to live and work.
qwerty182764
As for "resources" though, space (any given body, not in total) is actually somewhat poorer than Earth. We could probably get away with much more permissive strip-mining of the moon than Earth, but the moon doesn't contain a lot of heavy elements or hydrogen volatiles. Living there is going to be a challenge.