Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Science & Technology

Dark Jupiter in Oort cloud?

By CosmicConservative
A century of comet data suggests a dark, Jupiter-sized object is lurking at the solar system’s outer edge and hurling chunks of ice and dust toward Earth. “We’ve accumulated 10 years’ more data, double the comets we viewed to test this hypothesis,” said planetary scientist John Matese of the University of Louisiana. “Only now should we be able to falsify or verify that you could have a Jupiter-mass object out there.” via Dark Jupiter May Haunt Edge of Solar System | Wired Science | Wired.com.
I remember back in 1999 when the whole "Nemesis" hypothesis was proposed. I didn't have a blog then, but I did review the data and discuss the hypothesis with knowledgeable folks, including one astrophysicist. At that time the hypothesis was that a brown dwarf lurked in the outer solar system with a 30 million year orbit which grazed the Oort cloud and sent showers of comets to the inner solar system. I never did think the overall astronomical and geological data supported that contention. The geologic data in particular showed tantalizing periodicity, but the margin of error was too large for me to believe that something as precise as the orbit of two stars could result in that much variation in the actual species extinction events or other evidence of extra-planetary bombardment. Plus it was soon realized that some of the extinction events were due to the then new concept of super volcanoes. But there was still the nagging truth that there were some reliable shorter term patterns in the data. At that time Pluto was still a "planet" and there was much speculation of larger "Pluto-like objects" in the Kuiper belt. The problem with that though was that the Kuiper belt wasn't the source of many of the comets implicated in the periodicity, those seemed to come from the Oort cloud. This new look at the data, with double the number of comets examined, seems to re-validate the idea of an Oort cloud origin, and with more powerful computer simulations they have concluded that there is a body interacting with the Oort cloud that is about one and a half times the mass of Jupiter. There is a problem with that though, at least with my limited understanding of the current planetary formation models. Planets that large simply don't form that far out from the sun. That implies that a planet of that size orbiting within or beyond the Oort cloud must have migrated to that position from some other location. Perhaps it is even a captured planet. I'm sure there will be more to come. I find the hypothesis of a large object out beyond the Oort cloud to be more likely than a brown dwarf mostly because a  brown dwarf does radiate in the low infra-red and I think we'd have found a closely orbiting brown dwarf by now if it were that close and within the plane of the solar system's disk. Since we haven't, and since a body about the size of Jupiter would not radiate nearly as much, I find this to be a plausible hypothesis. And, in planetary science, if there's one, that means there can be more than one... Perhaps there's a dozen or so massive gas giants silently and invisibly orbiting the remote outer reaches of the sun's gravitational well. Who knows?

Empirical proof of Google search bias

By CosmicConservative
"Technology consultant Benjamin Edelman has developed a methodology for determining the existence of a hard-coded bias in Google's search engine which places Google's services at the top of the results page. Searching for a stock ticker places Google Finance at the top along with a price chart, but adding a comma to the end of the query removes the Google link completely. Other variations, such as 'a sore throat' instead of 'sore throat,' removes Google Health from its top position. Queries in other categories provide links to not only Google services but also their preferred partners. via Slashdot Technology Story | Hard-Coded Bias In Google Search Results?.
Remember when I pointed out that Google had an obvious bias in search results for google based blogs over independent blogs like, well, like CosmicConservative, based on my own analysis of blog search results? This guy proves it. Google is evil. And they lie.

I told them so...

By CosmicConservative
So, I don't have a link since I heard this story on the radio coming home from work yesterday... Ten years ago I worked for a major Yellow Pages directory publisher. My job at the time was as a software development project manager. I had been hired as part of an overall "resystemization effort" starting back in 1994. Prior to that effort the company produced Yellow Pages directories the same way they had for generations. They literally used entirely manual paper-based processes that had not changed since the early Jurassic period. In the six years between 1994 and 2000 my software development teams designed and coded completely new automated systems which accelerated productivity so much that it was really immeasurable. Customer Service representatives replaced literally dozens and dozens of reference books, manual tallying clipboards and request submission forms with Macintosh computers which not only allowed that to be done on computer, but which also tied into large back-end database systems so that representatives in Minneapolis could work on tasks that had been initiated by representatives in Phoenix (and vice versa of course... with lots of other cities, large and small, thrown in). It was, at the time, the single most successful software system deployed in the company since the ancient mainframe based Ad processing system (which didn't actually process any ads, but which did automate some of the layout tasks of the directories). Once we had completed the resystemization of Customer Service, my team developed an online file repository system which allowed documents to be created on the computer and stored in a massive document management system, giving artists and salespeople from all over the 14 state region the ability to store and retrieve a variety of documents which were critical to the process of creating the directories. Just before 2000 we developed a comprehensive online workflow system which directed the process of ad creation, allowing graphic artists to log into the system and work on ads from a priority-based queue with all the documents automatically being saved back to the back-end document management system. This was by far the largest and most productivity enhancing project the company had seen, perhaps ever. The business sponsor of the project (really a program, it had several individual projects as part of it) calculated the savings to the company from the system to be over $5,000,000 a year. The entire system cost us just under $2,000,000 to develop. Over the ten year life of the system it saved the company nearly $50,000,000 dollars. Not a bad days work. Then, of course, we had to deal with the looming Y2K calamity. Since our systems had been designed from the start to deal with four digit dates, our part of the Y2K "remediation" effort really amounted to locating random brain-farts from developers who didn't follow the design standards and locating any vendor-provided software with Y2K issues. I don't recall exactly what we had to do to keep our systems up over the year switch to 2000, but I do remember it was very trivial compared to the work other software teams had to do. So all of this is to lead up to the following observation. By the year 2000 my teams had demonstrated themselves to be, in my humble opinion, by far the most successful, forward-thinking and innovative software development teams in the entire company. We had won two major awards, including the most prestigious award the company offered at the time. So when my lead architect and I went to talk one day with the IT senior vice president, we wanted to warn her about the upcoming internet revolution which would, in our opinion, pretty much make paper directories obsolete. We were quite literally laughed out of her office. We specifically warned her that paper-based phone directories were a declining market and that within a decade the majority of people in our market area would be using the (then still new) internet to do their phone number lookups and business supplies and services searches. Not only were we laughed out of her office, but that began a career decline for me personally that I never was able to figure out. I went from being the "golden boy" PM to being left out of critical meetings and being passed over for promotions. Well, yesterday I heard on the radio that several major yellow pages providers have petitioned state governments in their areas to no longer be required to publish and distribute paper directories because, and I quote, "the majority of our customers no longer use paper directories to look up phone numbers and business supplies or services." I resigned from that job several years ago and have never looked back. But I have to admit to having some schadenfreude on the subject, and I caught myself smiling and muttering "I told you so, you idiots" under my breath...

Why the UN has no credibility

By CosmicConservative
A U.N. biodiversity conference aims to address a simple problem: "We are destroying life on Earth," said the head of the U.N. Environment Program. The world cannot afford to allow nature's riches to disappear, the United Nations said on Monday at the start of a major meeting to combat losses in animal and plant species that underpin livelihoods and economies. The U.N. cited the worst extinction rate since the dinosaurs vanished 65 million years ago, saying it's a crisis that needs to be addressed by governments, businesses and communities. via FoxNews.com - 'We Are Destroying Life on Earth,' UN Conference Claims.
This sort of breathless, Chicken-Little hyperbole is why nobody pays any attention to these asshats. If these anti-human, anti-corporate, anti-free-market crybabies wanted to have people actually take their warnings seriously, they'd present them in terms that don't make people blast soda out their nose when they hear it. Yes, we need to continue to find ways to live more in harmony with our planet. The truth is that in the western world, we are doing BETTER now than we were fifty years ago. And getting better all the time. One reason these asshats are ignored by normal, decent people, is that we're tired of being told that everything is a horrible crisis when we've lived through the obvious improvements of the past 50 years. The air is cleaner in most major cities today than it was in 1970. The environment is cleaner in most of the USA now than it was in 1970. Forested land in the USA has grown by a huge margin since 1970. If these bozos could get their heads out of their rectums long enough to give some actual thought to things, they might realize that they might get more cooperation from most people if they stop yelling at, accusing and lecturing everyone all the time and spend some time pointing out the progress that has actually been made. But of course that wouldn't generate the headlines that the "we're killing poor Mother Earth!" garbage gets. Shut up.

Google Sky to add amateur astrophotos

By CosmicConservative

Alan Boyle writes: Google and the Slooh virtual-telescope company have announced a deal to integrate tens of thousands of pictures captured by Slooh's members automatically into Google Earth's astronomical database. The arrangement could bring scientific crowdsourcing to a whole new level.

Millions of Internet users have already been participating in space-themed projects such as SETI @ Home, Galaxy Zoo and Moon Zoo, but those projects mostly involve sifting through data collected by the professionals. The collaboration announced today immediately puts images of more than 35,000 celestial objects into a Google Sky layer within the free Google Earth standalone program. New Slooh pictures will be added as soon as they're taken.

via Cosmic Log - Sharing the Google Sky.

Very cool.

How the Electric Car Lobby spins the data

By CosmicConservative

So this weekend I did some catching up on the state of electric car technology due to all the hoopla over the Chevy Volt. In doing so I noticed a few assumptions about electric cars that are blatantly untrue in some cases and are cynical spinning of the facts in others.

The first thing that leaped out at me was the near universal comparison of electric cars to gas cars which get 25mpg. On the surface this appears to be reasonable because that's about the average gas mileage of a new car these days. But that presupposes that people buying an electric car would have purchased a gas car of that mileage when every study done shows that electric car buyers disproportionately purchase higher mpg cars. In other words, the Chevy Volt competes directly with the Mini Cooper and the Toyota Prius, not the Ford F100 pickup truck. To be more realistic, the mpg value electric should be compared to is more like 35mpg than 25 mpg. Using those more realistic numbers the supposed CO2 advantage pretty much disappears entirely.

The next assumption is that the cost of electricity won't rise when the demand caused by electric cars hits the grid. In fact the comparisons typically use laughable government goals which somehow defy the laws of physics in projecting energy costs declining to about 20% of current values. To call these projections "optimistic" is a serious understatement.

The next assumption is that electric cars will pull their power according to the overall energy production distribution that exists today. That means for countries like Canada or France which have a high % of power generated from nuclear or hydro, the CO2 output is much less than in a country like the USA which uses coal and natural gas for the bulk of energy demand. What this sort of analysis overlooks is that electric car recharging is a net new power request and even in countries like France and Canada, additional demand is usually met with coal or natural gas. Especially in America where hydro and nuclear have been stalled indefinitely by the wacko environmentalist lobby. In other words all of that additional demand is likely to be met by burning more coal and natural gas.

Finally, none of the analyses I saw factored in the cost and environmental impact of the battery pack production, yet all of them factored in the cost of refining and transporting gasoline. Even with all these assumptions electric cars are barely beating gas cars on CO2 and energy costs. If the comparisons were honest the outlook for electric would be quite a bit less rosy. And that's not even looking at how much work has to be done on the grid infrastructure to support a couple million cars sucking up electricity like sponges all night long...

Robot cars are here now

By CosmicConservative
Anyone driving the twists of Highway 1 between San Francisco and Los Angeles recently may have glimpsed a Toyota Prius with a curious funnel-like cylinder on the roof. Harder to notice was that the person at the wheel was not actually driving. via Google Cars Drive Themselves, In Traffic - CNBC.
Five more years before you can load the family in the mini-van and punch in your destination and let your car do the driving? Heh... of course the car just has to be a Lefty approved Prius.... I have really begun to hate that car. My Yaris is at least as green, if not greener, and it cost less than half as much.

Science Reporting parody

By CosmicConservative

In this paragraph I will state the main claim that the research makes, making appropriate use of "scare quotes" to ensure that it's clear that I have no opinion about this research whatsoever.

In this paragraph I will briefly (because no paragraph should be more than one line) state which existing scientific ideas this new research "challenges".

If the research is about a potential cure, or a solution to a problem, this paragraph will describe how it will raise hopes for a group of sufferers or victims.

via This is a news website article about a scientific finding | Martin Robbins | Science | guardian.co.uk.

Hat tip to jsullins for the link. I frequently comment on how egregiously stupid a science article in the news is, so of course I enjoy this parody, but in all honesty, I think the author of this piece gives science reporters far too much credit. My personal opinion of science reporters is that by and large they are the "reporters" who aspired to the Society or Entertainment page but were too vapid and ignorant to write readable commentary on the number of veins visible in Madonna's creepy forearms. And so they are sent by their editors to cover the one area that nobody in the "newsroom" has the slightest idea of what is going on anyway, and which nobody has any hope of editing for accuracy or relevance since the highest hard science class that anyone in most journalism environments has ever attempted is second year high school algebra, a course they brag incessantly about almost failing and how difficult they find it to balance their checkbooks. As far as I can tell, nothing is more damaging to a professional journalism career than any indication that your brain has the capacity for rational, logical thought. (Which, of course, also explains why 95% of them are hardcore liberal Democrats as well.) The idea that most science "reporters" put this much thought into the reporting they do on a science subject is flat out laughable.