Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Science Reporting parody

By CosmicConservative

In this paragraph I will state the main claim that the research makes, making appropriate use of "scare quotes" to ensure that it's clear that I have no opinion about this research whatsoever.

In this paragraph I will briefly (because no paragraph should be more than one line) state which existing scientific ideas this new research "challenges".

If the research is about a potential cure, or a solution to a problem, this paragraph will describe how it will raise hopes for a group of sufferers or victims.

via This is a news website article about a scientific finding | Martin Robbins | Science | guardian.co.uk.

Hat tip to jsullins for the link. I frequently comment on how egregiously stupid a science article in the news is, so of course I enjoy this parody, but in all honesty, I think the author of this piece gives science reporters far too much credit. My personal opinion of science reporters is that by and large they are the "reporters" who aspired to the Society or Entertainment page but were too vapid and ignorant to write readable commentary on the number of veins visible in Madonna's creepy forearms. And so they are sent by their editors to cover the one area that nobody in the "newsroom" has the slightest idea of what is going on anyway, and which nobody has any hope of editing for accuracy or relevance since the highest hard science class that anyone in most journalism environments has ever attempted is second year high school algebra, a course they brag incessantly about almost failing and how difficult they find it to balance their checkbooks. As far as I can tell, nothing is more damaging to a professional journalism career than any indication that your brain has the capacity for rational, logical thought. (Which, of course, also explains why 95% of them are hardcore liberal Democrats as well.) The idea that most science "reporters" put this much thought into the reporting they do on a science subject is flat out laughable.

Comments (3)

Science Reporting – ROFLMAO «
[...] (ht Cosmic Conservative who notes: The idea that most science “reporters” put this much thought into the reporting they do on a science subject is flat out laughable. [...]
ASEI
I recall reading a science article written for the New York times sometime last century, lambasting Robert Goddard for his foolish notions that you might be able to put something in orbit. Every student of science "knew" that gravity would inevitably pull everything to the ground, and it would be mad to tolerate his continued experiments out in the desert. (Nevermind the doodles in Isaac Newton's notebooks, more or less establishing the concept of orbits in the 1600's!) The science was so bad it was pathetic, and it was delivered as serious reporting in one of America's main newspapers of the time. One observation of (was it Michael Crichton) is that when science reporters report on something you know about, and you can scarecly contain yourself because it is such a ridiculously misunderstood hash, you should probably take that as a warning about the accuracy of anything else that appears in the paper.
CosmicConservative
Heh... good point. No doubt the reporting on Madonna's arm vein count is as ridiculously wrong as their reporting on nuclear weapons...