Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Dark Jupiter in Oort cloud?

By CosmicConservative
A century of comet data suggests a dark, Jupiter-sized object is lurking at the solar system’s outer edge and hurling chunks of ice and dust toward Earth. “We’ve accumulated 10 years’ more data, double the comets we viewed to test this hypothesis,” said planetary scientist John Matese of the University of Louisiana. “Only now should we be able to falsify or verify that you could have a Jupiter-mass object out there.” via Dark Jupiter May Haunt Edge of Solar System | Wired Science | Wired.com.
I remember back in 1999 when the whole "Nemesis" hypothesis was proposed. I didn't have a blog then, but I did review the data and discuss the hypothesis with knowledgeable folks, including one astrophysicist. At that time the hypothesis was that a brown dwarf lurked in the outer solar system with a 30 million year orbit which grazed the Oort cloud and sent showers of comets to the inner solar system. I never did think the overall astronomical and geological data supported that contention. The geologic data in particular showed tantalizing periodicity, but the margin of error was too large for me to believe that something as precise as the orbit of two stars could result in that much variation in the actual species extinction events or other evidence of extra-planetary bombardment. Plus it was soon realized that some of the extinction events were due to the then new concept of super volcanoes. But there was still the nagging truth that there were some reliable shorter term patterns in the data. At that time Pluto was still a "planet" and there was much speculation of larger "Pluto-like objects" in the Kuiper belt. The problem with that though was that the Kuiper belt wasn't the source of many of the comets implicated in the periodicity, those seemed to come from the Oort cloud. This new look at the data, with double the number of comets examined, seems to re-validate the idea of an Oort cloud origin, and with more powerful computer simulations they have concluded that there is a body interacting with the Oort cloud that is about one and a half times the mass of Jupiter. There is a problem with that though, at least with my limited understanding of the current planetary formation models. Planets that large simply don't form that far out from the sun. That implies that a planet of that size orbiting within or beyond the Oort cloud must have migrated to that position from some other location. Perhaps it is even a captured planet. I'm sure there will be more to come. I find the hypothesis of a large object out beyond the Oort cloud to be more likely than a brown dwarf mostly because a  brown dwarf does radiate in the low infra-red and I think we'd have found a closely orbiting brown dwarf by now if it were that close and within the plane of the solar system's disk. Since we haven't, and since a body about the size of Jupiter would not radiate nearly as much, I find this to be a plausible hypothesis. And, in planetary science, if there's one, that means there can be more than one... Perhaps there's a dozen or so massive gas giants silently and invisibly orbiting the remote outer reaches of the sun's gravitational well. Who knows?

Comments (2)