Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Whither now, Harry Potter cast?

By CosmicConservative
For the past decade the whole world has basically watched the principal cast members of the "Harry Potter" movies grow up. Now they are all grown up and they have, I believe, finished all of their acting even though the final movie still has months of final editing and production work. There is no doubt that all of the primary cast members have to be set for life after the unprecedented success of a set of seven blockbuster movies (no doubt soon to be eight). The question is whether any of them will become successful long-term dramatic actors/actresses. Here's my guess, fwiw: Daniel Radcliffe will either eventually drift away from acting or will become a character actor. I like him, but I don't think he will be successful as a leading man. He will be weighed down by the Harry Potter type-casting more than any other cast member, which is unfortunate but not uncommon for a child actor in such a prominent role. Rupert Grint may blossom into a strong supporting actor, in fact I wouldn't be surprised to see him take on some villainous roles in the future. He's got a very plastic face with a very impressive scowl. But again, I don't see him being a leading man type. Emma Watson will almost certainly become an A-List leading lady type. She seems able to handle both strong dramatic scenes and light humor. I could easily see her as a romantic comedy lead, but also I see her doing a Jodi Foster sort of turn as she gets older. I suspect she'll have the most successful long-term career of any of the main young actors. Most of the adult cast members were already very successful, so I don't see the Harry Potter films doing much but making them a lot of money. I do see some other actors who have some real promise. Matthew Lewis, who played Neville Longbottom, looked like the real deal to me. I wouldn't be surprised to see him in some big hit movies in the future. I have a soft spot for Evanna Lynch, who played Luna Lovegood, just because I thought she was brilliantly understated and quirky. I hope she doesn't get typecast. I can't figure out Bonnie Wright, who played Ginny Weasley. She had some rather difficult scenes and carried them off well, but I frankly never thought she and Daniel Radcliffe had any real chemistry as two young lovers. Plus she's got a sort of strange face that isn't unpleasant, but it's just odd enough not to really have leading lady quality. Now, she's still young and might grow out of that, but compared to Emma Watson, Bonnie just doesn't have the same wattage. Tom Felton, as Draco Malfoy, started off good, but as his character got darker and more conflicted, he just came across as petulant and morose. In the book Draco was an interesting foil for Harry, and in the first couple of movies that relationship sort of worked, but as the movies went on, Draco just sort of faded into the background. I don't think that will do much to propel Mr. Felton to mega-stardom. I would not be surprised to see Imelda Staunton (Dolores Umbridge) make a good living as a strong supporting actress. That was a tough role to pull off, and I thought she managed to convey the concept pretty well. It will be interesting to see what happens to these folks as the Harry Potter decade fades into the collective memory of our various cultures.

War in the ranks!

By CosmicConservative
The chiefs of the Army, Marines and Air Force warned Friday that implementing a repeal of the policy banning gays from serving openly in the military would be more difficult than a Pentagon study has suggested, challenging the assessments of other top military officials in the administration. via Military Chiefs Cast Doubt on Repealing 'Don't Ask, Don't Tell' - FoxNews.com.
Well, now this is getting more interesting... Looks like opposition within the military is growing. Those Joint Chiefs meetings must be a little strained right now...

Where is the outrage?

By CosmicConservative

The US is increasingly using drones for air strikes in Pakistan's border area, with the CIA controlling the unmanned aircraft from the US. Drone attacks against insurgent targets form a key part of US President Barack Obama's anti-terror strategy, and are estimated to have killed over 500 people in 2010 alone. The approach has been criticized by some human rights experts as violating international law, given that Pakistan is not a war zone.

"Fire and Brimstone"

"Such attacks are happening outside the law," says Neskovic. "International law does not provide any legal basis for the killing of suspected terrorists outside of a combat situation. … No intelligence service has the license to kill."

According to Neskovic, if other countries adopted such a strategy, the entire world would become a war zone, with "American drones over the Brandenburg Gate (in Berlin) and North Korean drones over Washington."

Neskovic reserves his strongest criticism for the American president, who he sees as being ultimately responsible for the drone attacks. "Barack Obama is not God, able to freely decide about life and death," he says. "Nevertheless he behaves like an Old Testament God who kills people as he sees fit with fire and brimstone."

via 'Obama Is not God': US Drone Attack Raises Uncomfortable Questions for Germany - SPIEGEL ONLINE - News - International.

(Emphasis and italics are mine.) Neskovic is absolutely right here. Barack Obama, the man who viciously attacked George W. Bush for his "illegal war" has vastly increased the use of drones to kill suspected terrorists precisely because he would rather kill them without proof of guilt than capture them, interrogate them and potentially be stuck with holding them captive. It's easier for Obama to just give the order to allow drone attacks. After all, the NY Times gets her panties all in a wad when the US interrogates a prisoner, but apparently doesn't mind just blowing them into a fine red mist without any warning.

NASA plays the media...

By CosmicConservative
A NASA press release announcing "an astrobiology finding" -- something that will impact the search for extraterrestrial life -- has sent shockwaves through the blogosphere. The press release simply announces an event, set for Thursday at 2 p.m. EST, to discuss an astrobiology discovery "that will impact the search for evidence of extraterrestrial life." via FoxNews.com - Rumor Roundup: Has NASA Discovered Alien Life?.
Gotta give NASA credit for this from a PR perspective. The announcement a few days ago that there would be a press conference to reveal something new about the search for extraterrestrial life has really stirred up the blogosphere. I guess I can't really call myself "CosmicConservative" without weighing in on this before tomorrow's press conference. My guess is that the quote above is the key to the whole thing. They believe they have discovered something that impacts the potential discovery of extraterrestrial life. That's what they say. So, what could that be? Well, there are a couple of likely candidates based on other space news stories I've seen lately, and based on the areas of expertise of the scientists giving the press conference. First, and most likely, is that they believe they have discovered a different "marker" which could be detected at a great distance to indicate the likely presence of life. Right now the most well-known "marker" for life is atmospheric oxygen. Since oxygen is one of the most reactive elements around, it tends to get bound up in chemical compounds very rapidly. Thus it is thought that atmospheric oxygen (not ozone, that's a different thing) would be an almost certain indicator of living processes. Methane is another potential marker, as is any evidence of chlorophyll. Exobiologists spend a lot of time looking for tiny bits of evidence of those markers. But those are well known markers. But oxygen based life may not be the only form of life, particularly at temperatures where water is not likely to exist (water is generally thought to be necessary for life, and is also, not coincidentally, considered an excellent source of oxygen if life is present). The problem is that water based life requires a very narrow range of temperatures (called the "Goldilocks zone" in exobiology). So it may be that NASA scientists have come up with a strong theory of, for example, life based on a methane/ethane cycle that operates similar to the water cycle on earth. If so, perhaps their models predict a chemical presence similar to oxygen that would be a good marker for methane/ethane sea-based life. This would potentially greatly increase the number of candidate planets for life since most of the planets we discover are either too close or too far away from their sun for liquid water. Of course there could be any number of other chemical bases for life, so perhaps they have postulated one that would fit with an early Mars environment. Who knows? But I suspect it is something like that. I doubt they have discovered any proof of life outside of earth, something like that would have leaked by now I'm certain. But discovering a non-water based possible means to support life could probably be kept under wraps. The other possibility, much less likely imho, is that they have discovered one or more of the more common markers on one of the newly discovered planets that are close to or in the Goldilocks zone. That would be huge for us since that would imply a potential colonizable world. But again, that would probably be big enough that it would have leaked by now. We'll see. I am curious.

Yet another "I told you so"

By CosmicConservative
The United States Interior Department on Wednesday backtracked on a plan to open up the eastern Gulf of Mexico and parts of the Atlantic seaboard to new offshore drilling leases – a decision sparked by the Gulf oil spill this summer and the failure to strike a political deal with Republicans on global-warming legislation. via Obama backtracks on plan to open more Gulf waters to offshore drilling - CSMonitor.com.
When Obama announced his "plan" to allow more drilling I applauded it originally, but then in my first comment I pointed out that it was likely just a cynical ploy to move his poll numbers and that he'd eventually use his regulatory power to shut down more drilling. Which is exactly what happened. It really is pretty much true that you can tell Obama is lying because his lips move.

Don't Ask, Don't Tell final DoD report

By CosmicConservative
As regular readers of this site should know, I'm not much of a "social conservative." I'm mostly a fiscal, foreign policy and constitutional conservative. So the issue of gays in the military is not one that I'm terribly overwrought about. I'm sure many social conservatives will assert that the just released final Department of Defense report on the potential repeal of "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" is some sort of politically correct fabrication prepared at the command of President Obama, but, as with most things, until I see some evidence of such malfeasance I will assume that the authors of the report are decent, honest, ethical folks dealing with a difficult question the best way they can. The report itself is long and covers a lot of different areas, including breaking down attitudes according to branch of service and even into units of command within the branches of service. Not surprisingly the Marines seem to be the branch with the most concerns about repealing the policy. But even within the Marines there is only a minority voicing concern over the repeal. Here is the money quote:
Based on all we saw and heard, our assessment is that, when coupled with the prompt implementation of the recommendations we offer below, the risk of repeal of Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell to overall military effectiveness is low. We conclude that, while a repeal of Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell will likely, in the short term, bring about some limited and isolated disruption to unit cohesion and retention, we do not believe this disruption will be widespread or long-lasting, and can be adequately addressed by the recommendations we offer below. Longer term, with a continued and sustained commitment to core values of leadership, professionalism,and respect for all, we are convinced that the U.S. military can adjust and accommodate this change, just as it has others in history.
Now, just a bit of blogging business here, the above quote was actually lifted from the Volokh Conspiracy because I couldn't copy out of the .pdf file itself for some reason. Other than just wanting to see Obama twist in the wind on this policy for purely partisan reasons, I really don't have any major problem with repeal of the DADT policy, and in the wake of this report I believe that if Republicans stonewall on this issue they will lose a lot of the independent and moderate voters who defected to them in the last election. This should probably be done quickly and Republicans should stay focused on what the American people just elected them to do, which is to control spending, control taxes and stop the rampant stampede towards socialism that Obama has embarked upon.

Dark Jupiter in Oort cloud?

By CosmicConservative
A century of comet data suggests a dark, Jupiter-sized object is lurking at the solar system’s outer edge and hurling chunks of ice and dust toward Earth. “We’ve accumulated 10 years’ more data, double the comets we viewed to test this hypothesis,” said planetary scientist John Matese of the University of Louisiana. “Only now should we be able to falsify or verify that you could have a Jupiter-mass object out there.” via Dark Jupiter May Haunt Edge of Solar System | Wired Science | Wired.com.
I remember back in 1999 when the whole "Nemesis" hypothesis was proposed. I didn't have a blog then, but I did review the data and discuss the hypothesis with knowledgeable folks, including one astrophysicist. At that time the hypothesis was that a brown dwarf lurked in the outer solar system with a 30 million year orbit which grazed the Oort cloud and sent showers of comets to the inner solar system. I never did think the overall astronomical and geological data supported that contention. The geologic data in particular showed tantalizing periodicity, but the margin of error was too large for me to believe that something as precise as the orbit of two stars could result in that much variation in the actual species extinction events or other evidence of extra-planetary bombardment. Plus it was soon realized that some of the extinction events were due to the then new concept of super volcanoes. But there was still the nagging truth that there were some reliable shorter term patterns in the data. At that time Pluto was still a "planet" and there was much speculation of larger "Pluto-like objects" in the Kuiper belt. The problem with that though was that the Kuiper belt wasn't the source of many of the comets implicated in the periodicity, those seemed to come from the Oort cloud. This new look at the data, with double the number of comets examined, seems to re-validate the idea of an Oort cloud origin, and with more powerful computer simulations they have concluded that there is a body interacting with the Oort cloud that is about one and a half times the mass of Jupiter. There is a problem with that though, at least with my limited understanding of the current planetary formation models. Planets that large simply don't form that far out from the sun. That implies that a planet of that size orbiting within or beyond the Oort cloud must have migrated to that position from some other location. Perhaps it is even a captured planet. I'm sure there will be more to come. I find the hypothesis of a large object out beyond the Oort cloud to be more likely than a brown dwarf mostly because a  brown dwarf does radiate in the low infra-red and I think we'd have found a closely orbiting brown dwarf by now if it were that close and within the plane of the solar system's disk. Since we haven't, and since a body about the size of Jupiter would not radiate nearly as much, I find this to be a plausible hypothesis. And, in planetary science, if there's one, that means there can be more than one... Perhaps there's a dozen or so massive gas giants silently and invisibly orbiting the remote outer reaches of the sun's gravitational well. Who knows?

Audi A4 heater problem...

By CosmicConservative
So, on our recent Thanksgiving trip, our 2003 Audi A4 Quattro turbo 1.8L heater just stopped blowing hot air. It still blows air, and it will blow warm air for maybe five seconds when you first turn it on, but then it blows cold air after that. Was real nice on our 8.5 hour drive in 20 degree temperatures.... So I just called the Audi dealer and he said the fix would range from $160 if it's a mere problem with "recalibrating the stepper motors" to $1700 if we have to "replace the heater core." Anyone wanna guess what the likely problem is going to turn out to be? The other options are "replace the auxiliary water pump" for about $1200 or "replace the blow doors" also for about $1200 (because both of those require taking the dashboard entirely off the car. Brilliant engineers those Germans...) What I love is that all of these sound more like problems that I'd expect to run into on the starship Enterprise than just blowing hot air into my car from the engine compartment. Where is Scotty when you need him? "Scotty, I need more heat!" "I'm doin' all I can Captain!" "Well, do more!"

Guitar blues...

By CosmicConservative
Why do I still suck at playing guitar? I can play tons of chords. I can finger notes clearly. I can handle many songs in the songbooks I have, but only in terms of playing the chords. I got no rhythm. I got no soul. I got no spark. I got no jones. Put a guitar in my hand and I can do scales, chords and even blues progressions until my fingers bleed. But I can't make MUSIC. What the hell's wrong with me?