Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The Rehabilitation of the Wicked Witch

By Dadman
So, my wife, son and I went to see one of Broadway's recent sensations - Wicked - the other day in Tempe, Arizona. In case you've just stumbled onto Earth from another planet, Wicked is a musical stage show featuring as principal characters the Wicked Witch of the West and Glinda the Good Witch immortalized in the cinematic classic the Wizard of Oz. It's essentially a parallel story of the two famous witches full of great musical numbers and witty repartee. I liked it... But on another level I was annoyed. Wicked is rife with popular liberal themes. For example, Glinda is initially portrayed not as a purely good character (as she was in the Wizard of Oz , but as a self-serving, shallow, manipulative (and blonde) alpha chick intent on making Elphaba (the Wicked Witch) suffer. Elphaba, on the other hand, had the misfortune of being born green and subsequently driven to wickedness more by circumstance than any conscious choice of her own. It is all so painfully familiar. How often do we hear liberals tell us that the odious behavior of serial killers is somehow mitigated by the tragic circumstances of their childhood, or that the poor are the victims of oppression rather than their own poor choices? And now we hear them tell us that blood-thirsty Islamofascist murderers are only responding to the evil foreign policies of the West when they decapitate people on the internet. In the liberal mind all the bad actors on the planet are just misunderstood victims rather than individuals empowered with the free agency to make good or bad choices. Their wickedness is derived from external forces, not from within. Or worse, that wickedness is somehow good, and good is somehow evil. Wicked, I'm sorry to say, reeked of this brand of moral relativism. I certainly had no trouble sniffing it out. At the very least it was a strong subtext of the main storyline and this, as I've said, was annoying...and predictable I suppose. The graphic above clearly implies that Glinda may not be as good as we think she is. I concede I may be too cynical, or too politically sensitive, for my own good. I've learned that too much cynicism has a way of sucking the fun out of things. And I admit I let it tarnish my enjoyment of Wicked to some extent. Shame on me I guess...

Comments (1)

CosmicConservative
I think National Review already did a review of "Wicked" that makes a similar argument, so you're in good company. The whole "moral relativism" theme is clearly a major effort here. But this is how liberals display their "tolerance" and "sensitivity." Anyone can sympathize with Dorothy when the evil old witch is trying to kill her and her "little dog, too." That's sooo lame and booooring. It takes a real sophisticated and subtle person to sympathize with someone like the Wicked Witch of the West. Or that's what they believe anyway. So this is all about demonstrating liberal credentials by demonstrating a "more tolerant than thou" attitude that is just as offensive to me as the "holier than thou" attitude exhibited on the far religious Right. Of course, much like Brokeback Mountain, I find these things to be about as sophisticated and subtle as a bludgeon attack, but then again, I'm a certified rube already, so my opinion doesn't mean much. But I would probably enjoy the play, I loved "Into The Woods", for example.