Movie Review: "The Avengers"
By CosmicConservativeFor a decade or so from the late 60s into the 70s I was a pretty avid comic book buyer and reader. I typically preferred Marvel comics to DC comics for a variety of reasons. My favorite Marvel comics were Spiderman, Dr. Strange, Warlock, Fantastic Four, X-Men and every now and then some Thor or maybe even a Captain America thrown in. On rare occasions I might purchase an "Avengers" comic. From the DC side of the equation I mostly liked Batman and the pre-Jack Kirby Superman. Somewhere in there was the really amazing and fantastic run of "Green Arrow" comics.
But I never really cared for the "supergroup" comics from either Marvel or DC. The motley collection of superheroes always struck me as implausible and contrived. Superman fighting alongside Aquaman just made no sense and stretched my willing suspension of disbelief far beyond the breaking point. I couldn't help but imagine the super villains lining up to attack and one of them saying something like :
"Oh no! We've been caught! You guys take the dude in blue and red tights who is invulnerable, can fly faster than light, can crush coal into diamond and whose eyes shoot laser beams. I'll handle this dude over here who can talk to fish!"
The idea of Thor, the lightning-bolt-hurling, mountain-crushing, God of Thunder fighting alongside Hawkeye, the guy who shoots a bow really, really good, just doesn't really work.
So I really didn't have high expectations for the movie going in.
But Joss Wheedon.
Am I right?
I mean if anyone can make this work, it's gotta be Joss...
And he actually really did.
Let's be honest, the plot of these superhero stories is no more plausible today than they were when I rolled my eyes as a twelve year old kid, so you can't really analyze this sort of movie from any reasonable literary perspective. The scientific pseudobabble is so predictable and contrived that I'd honestly just prefer they stopped trying. Nobody really cares about the supposed technical rationale behind the acquisition of powers or the warped cosmology that allow Thor, Iron Man and the Hulk to slug it out as more or less equals while Captain America, the Black Widow and Hawkeye stand around looking all tough even though everyone knows if the Hulk sneezes on one of them, they'll just be a stain on a nearby wall...
So the only real question for a movie like this is "how much fun was it?"
Well, it was a lot of fun. There were plenty of things I could point out that made no sense, but what's the point?
Here are the things I liked:
1. The movie had a sense of humor about itself. There was just the right hint of self-awareness, a sort of winking at the audience that allowed the watcher to realize the characters were in on the joke.
2. The CGI was amazingly well done in most cases. The fusion of live action and CGI was nearly flawless.
3. Some of the acting was surprisingly well done. Robert Downey Jr always rises to the occasion, but the toughest acting challenge in my mind had to be Thor. But Chris Hemsworth not only pulls it off, he injects the role with remarkable vulnerability and even some wisdom. His role in this movie faithfully carries forward the transformation from impetuous blood-thirsty warrior-king in the first "Thor" movie to the rightful heir to Odin's throne. He plays Thor straight, not campy nor overly serious. It's a surprisingly nuanced performance for such a seemingly one-dimensional role.
4. The humor. There are moments that I think only Joss Whedon could have conceived and brought to screen. I won't reveal any of them because they are some of the best moments in the movie. But they are reminiscent of some of the best moments from "Firefly" or "Buffy".
There were some things I didn't like too:
1. Some of the acting. Mark Ruffalo strikes me as badly miscast as Bruce Banner. He also doesn't seem to be as attuned as the rest of the cast to Whedon's vision for the movie. He just doesn't work for me. Also, as much as I enjoy watching Scarlett Johanssen in leather tights... well, she's not really convincing as Black Widow either.
2. The whole S.H.I.E.L.D supersecret government entity thing with all the behind the scenes political machinations... I'm not watching movies like this to wonder if my government is the good guy or the bad guy. There's plenty of movies like that out there. Let S.H.I.E.L.D. be what it is supposed to be and focus the story on the action and the Avengers. Quit wasting my time with shadowy super-secret Tri-lateral commission skullduggery.
3. Complete disregard for plot holes so glaring that you just have to either say "OK, I'll just ignore that" or else spend most of the movie saying "what the hell?" I chose the former.
4. No Jane Foster (Natalie Portman). I mean come on! Thor is supposed to be madly in love with her!
Anyway, it was a fun movie, the Cosmic clan greatly enjoyed it. Cosmic says, check it out.
Comments (7)