Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

More on Miers

By CosmicConservative
My earlier post did not have any depth to it, so I'll try to add some actual analysis to the situation. I was originally willing to let Harriet Miers prove her case in her Hearings. I changed my mind after looking at the few public writings and speeches she had made. I had called for pretty much exactly what ended up happening so I feel pretty good about the situation. Miers is off the table, Bush has saved face and the need to nominate a solid Janice Rogers Brown type to SCOTUS is now clearly in front of the Bush inner circle. I am sure my short list of candidates matches most other conservatives but topping that list are Janice Rogers Brown, Michael Luttig and Michael McConnell. This is a really good site with a rundown on the possible nominees. The hope now is that this withdrawal by Miers will re-invigorate the conservative base. But that will only happen if Bush appoints the right person now, if he pulls another Miers on us, the base will likely be ten times as angry as they were over Miers. Right now, with all the other issues besetting this administration, it would be better for Bush to regain the support of his base even if he loses a tough confirmation hearing. Sometimes the battle is worth the effort even if you lose. This is one of those times.

Comments (2)

Mr Bob
I actually think Bush WAS trying to reach to the Evangelical base on this nomination. He nominated a friend, he knew was a believing Christian, but he totally underestimated the fact that even though we like Bush, we don't trust LAWYERS! There has to be a proven track record and even then we hold our breath.
CosmicConservative
I agree that Bush was trying to sneak an evangelical onto the bench and thought that the lack of a paper trail would let her get by. I don't think the ones who opposed Miers were the "radical right" so loved by the mainstream media. I think the main opposition was from principled conservatives who felt that you had to earn a SCOTUS slot and that there were many who had paid their dues (Rogers Brown, Luttig, McConnell, etc.) and that in spite of an ugly confirmation process, he would win. One of the main reasons I opposed Miers is because we need superstars, we can't win the battle of ideas with merely "good" players. I have nothing against Miers, I am sure she is smarter and more successful than I am. But we need a court packed with minds like Scalia, Thomas, Rehnquest and Roberts. That's what I am hoping for and if we get it, I am sure that the left will lose their greatest source of power in this country.