Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Peyton Manning to be released by Colts

By CosmicConservative
From ESPN:
Peyton Manning's 14-year career with the Indianapolis Colts is coming to an end after owner Jim Irsay informed the four-time NFL MVP on Monday night that the team will release him, according to team sources. Irsay and Manning traveled together Tuesday night from South Florida on Irsay's private jet and will conduct a joint news conference at noon ET on Wednesday, which sources said will be to announce the quarterback's departure. The pair was spotted together in Irsay's car after arriving in Indianapolis. Irsay began to address the media before Manning, while smiling, "We'll see ya'll tomorrow. We're gonna talk tomorrow." When asked if they were both happy, Manning said: "We're good, we're good. We're gonna talk tomorrow. We're gonna do it the right way tomorrow." Manning then repeated the same "We'll do it tomorrow" response when asked to describe how tough his pending release was for him. The decision to pass on the $28 million bonus owed to Manning and not to pick up the four remaining years on his contract means Manning will become a free agent.
I would not at all be surprised to see the Broncos make a serious effort to bring Manning to Denver.

Comments (17)

Drax
Denver might try. Can't see Manning going there, though. Denver is a defense/run first offense. That's what Fox is all about. But, it has a crappy offensive line. It has a mediocre defense. It has no receivers or tight ends of any significance. It is a bad fit for Manning. Miami, on the other hand, looks good. Wouldn't be surprised to see him go to either Seattle or Arizona either.
Dadman
I've offered to show him around town if he comes to Arizona. He's not returning my calls, though, so I don't think he's coming...
Drax
Manning is actually going to Denver in person, so, he's interested. He'll make his choice by next Tuesday, he says.
CosmicConservative
I think I predicted this during the middle of Tebow-mania
CosmicConservative
According to Chris Mortensen and Adam Schefter, Denver is still the likeliest place Manning will end up. I think Arizona is more attractive to Manning with the natural turf, but closed stadium. I doubt Manning really wants to play in a Denver snowstorm. But, I know he an Elway are buds, and he supposedly has a good relationship with John Fox too. All this does is show how much Tim Tebow can trust John "Tim Tebow will be our starter going into training camp" Elway. As miserable a "promise" as that was, it's clear that Elway never intended to even honor that gnawed down bone he tossed at Tebow after getting the first post-season win in a decade. Great guy that Elway. A real gem among men.
CosmicConservative
So, it now appears that Manning won't make a decision until the end of the week. This means Elway can't pursue the top line free agents since he clearly feels that a Manning signing would bring a different set of free agency priorities than continuing on with Tebow. The end result means a weakened Broncos team regardless of Manning's decision. This whole thing is looking more bone-headed every minute. In the end Denver is likely to end up with a potentially has-been potentially injury-prone superstar with no targets to throw at and the most porous offensive line in the game. It's enough to almost make me root for them to get Manning.
Drax
Tennessee is apparently under examination as well. Frankly, even if Manning goes to Denver, is healthy and Denver gets all the free agents he wants - I don't think that Denver is much better, record wise, than they were last season. Every team in the division will be better. And, I really don't believe that getting Manning upgrades the position all that much - even with the addition of the free agents. Jeremy Linn. That's why. Jeremy Lin and Carmello Anthony. Tebow was Linn, Linn was Tebow. Each of them took a bunch of sub-par role players and made them believe that they could play with the big boys. Eric Decker played like a number one wide receiver. Willis McGahee pounded the rock like he was 25 and had never been injured. Even the defense stepped up and played way above their heads. The same thing happened with the Knicks when Linn took over as point quard (the QB of basketball). They went on an 8 game winning streak, bring the Knicks up to a .500 record. Then they added the superstar Amare Stoudemire and the team didn't do quite as well. Then the true superstar, Carmello Anthony - perhaps the best pure scorer in the game - to the roster, and the team fell apart. They're something like 2-8 since he has come back. It's the same thing with Manning. Denver isn't as good as its record of last year would indicate. They were just as good as their record in the first 5 games of the season and all the previous season would indicate (perhaps worse since they got rid of their best offensive weapon before Tebow took over). If they get Manning and every free agent they want, I'd be surprised if Denver went better than 9-7.
Drax
Apparently, Houston is in the mix as well. If Houston is a possibility, then Manning would be an absolute idiot to go anywhere else. They were a pass away from the Super Bowl last season with a crappy QB.
CosmicConservative
I can understand why Adam Schefter might be a Denver homer (he is from Wyoming and is a frequent guest on Denver sports talk shows, and has expressed a bias towards Denver teams) but Chris Mortensen was still calling Denver the lead city as late as yesterday... But I don't see it. I don't understand why Manning would want to come to Denver. I understand why Denver (Elway and Fox anyway) would want Manning, but it makes no sense to me that Manning would take Denver over several of his options. Denver would have to totally rebuild their offense (not because of Tebow, the Denver offense sucked before Tebow took over), redefine their offensive philosophy (something Fox has never shown any indication of doing at any level) and scour the bottom of the free agency barrel to try to get some level of talent to play with Manning. Surely Manning and his agent see that? If Denver does hold off of pulling the trigger on free agents pending Manning's decision, I think 2012 is going to be an ugly season, regardless of who ends up at QB. Denver is full of serious holes in talent. And their best draft pick last year never played half as well after breaking his thumb.
Drax
Speaking of free agency... This is the second time 31 teams passed over Randy Moss and one team got the most talented wide receiver in the history in the game (who still runs a 4.3 40 yard dash) - for a song. Gee. Alex Smith sure is a bust, isn't he? (I expect him to throw around 35 TD's this season and for San Fran to go to the Superbowl.)
CosmicConservative
Heh... You put a lot on Randy Moss.... I have mixed feelings about Moss. He is undeniably a great talent. But his record in disrupting locker rooms and destroying team chemistry is well known. I guess we'll see if his 4.3 speed is something he can maintain with his aging legs over a full football game, much less a football season...
Drax
I've heard the exact opposite about Randy Moss, from a variety of former teammates (at least two of them today as the signing was discussed). He's supposed to be a great team mate - and a great leader - most of the time. Yeah. I put a lot on Moss. Ask Culpepper who went to the waiver wire after Moss left. Ask Brady who became Marino for a year. But, if your team is disfunctional (like Oakland) he loses heart. He became disgusted when he wasn't resigned after being a model NFL citizen in New England and never got his heart back into the game. With San Francisco and Harbaugh, he'll make Alex Smith look like an elite QB. I predict 3500 - 4500 yards for Smith, 35 TD's and 10 Int or so. 13-3 at worst and Superbowl bound. (Oh, and Houston's owner says that he's not interested in Manning - happy with their QB. Looking like Denver or Arizona, and I'm with you - really can't see what Manning's attraction to Denver is. There is NOTHING about that team (including where they play) which would make that an attractive team to a QB who only wants to win a Super Bowl in the next 2-3 years. Call me befuddled.)
Drax
Arizona is apparently out of the running. Miama too. He worked out for the '49ers. Yep. If he doesn't take that job, he's a total moron. (Especially after signing Moss (and working out Manningham and Brandon Lloyd). Seriously. A top tier defense. A top tier running game. A top tier offensive line. A top tier special teams. And, with Moss, a top-tier receiving corps. Kinda hoped he would go to Denver and Tebow to Jacksonville...but simply can't believe that he would take a lower-tier offensive line, bottom of the barrel receiving corps, a lower tier (without Tebow) running game, and a middle of the road defense over anyone still under consideration, and SF is heads and tails above all of them.
CosmicConservative
I concur with all of that Drax. In fact, I think this is going to be a major story in Denver when Manning signs with San Fran and Denver is left trying to scrape the bottom of the barrel for free agents. In spite of all the "experts" saying "there is no way Denver fans could be unhappy about Elway wanting to get Manning" the talk show lines have been burning up with people who have been unhappy about Elway wanting to get Manning. I think the last eight months have done serious harm to Elway's image in Denver. And I think it's going to get worse before it gets better as more and more people realize that Elway truly is the main opposition to Tebow getting a fair shake on the team.
Drax
I can understand Fox and Elway deciding that Tebow shouldn't be the starting QB as a result of Tebow's performance in practice prior to last season. I can also understand Fox and Elway concluding that running any system in which they believe that Tebow might be more competent isn't a system which is viable in the NFL, or, if viable couldn't be successful for many and valid reasons - not the least of which is the difficulty of keeping a running QB who is bruising rather than elusive on the field and healthy. I get all that. I can't blame them for that. I believe them to be wrong on all counts, but I fully understand their reasoning. But, they gave him the starting job. Jumped him over at least one other QB who, the day before, was 2nd on the depth charts. That showed that they were weak and would subordinate their football judgment to fan pressure. If they believed he was inferior to Quinn, they should have started Quinn. By their own lights, the decision to start an inferior QB was incompetence, at best. But, once they started him, they should have made a game plan which gave the TEAM the best chance to succeed. Instead, they intentionally implemented a game plan - one which they followed the entire year - which was designed to HIGHLIGHT the deficiencies in both the offensive scheme which they believed was the only one Tebow could run as well as Tebow's incompetence as well. Run on 1st. Run on 2nd. Either throw long on 3rd or run on 3rd. A completely predictable offense which should not have worked. And, frankly, it didn't work. Just as Fox and Elway wanted, Tebow couldn't move the ball. Then, in the final minutes - behind and knowing that the TEAM would be lost to them if they didn't at least give the ILLUSION that they were actually trying to win, Fox loosened the reins on Tebow in the last quarter. And, he won. When he could. Fox and Elway even tried this in the playoffs. Running it on 3rd down over and over. Forcing the few passes when they were 3rd and long. But, Tebow made those throws. And, even with this playbook designed to LOSE, he tied the game. Faced with the prospect that they might actually WIN a playoff game, either Fox called a pass on 1st down or TEBOW called a pass on 1st down and caught Pittsburgh off balance. Then, the game against New England. I couldn't watch it after just a while. Run. Run. Run on 3rd and 20 and down 20 points. Run some more. There are too many in Denver who see through what Fox and Elway were trying to do. Like me, most of the fans can understand Tebow not winning the starting job in the first place, but will not forgive the way that the two of them tried to destroy Tebow just to prove to the fans that he couldn't play in the NFL. I still want Manning to go to Denver and Tebow to Jacksonville. The owner said that he would trade for him and start him. I doubt that, with Manning, Denver could win more than 9 games. 10 at the outside. He's good, but he doesn't have anything to work with and "his" system would be a complete departure from what they have been doing even before Tebow got there.
Drax
Denver it is. I believe that, unless the Raiders completely fall on their faces, that Denver won't even make the playoffs next year.
CosmicConservative
As I said, I predicted this back when it became clear that Indianapolis would draft Andrew Luck. I wish Tim Tebow success. If the Broncos don't get at least to the AFC championship game (one game further than Tebow took them last year) then I think fans will revolt.