Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

World of Warcraft boosts senior brains...

By CosmicConservative
Doesn't surprise me at all. The game actually requires some thought to play.
Playing a popular online game may improve some older adults' abilities to focus their attention, a new study suggests. Those who spent two weeks playing "World of Warcraft" — a game in which players take on the role of a character, and role-play with others in fighting monsters and completing quests — improved more on tests of attention and of spatial abilities than those who didn't play the game, the results showed. "It is a cognitively challenging game, in a socially interactive environment that presents users with novel situations,” said study researcher Anne McLaughlin, an assistant professor of psychology at North Carolina State University. Read more:

Comments (19)

Boyd
I'm sure that Blizzard's approach to the differences in armor for male and female characters, illustrated by the graphic you chose for this post, has nothing to do with this.
CosmicConservative
Ah, yes, nothing like a good old chainmail bikini...
CosmicConservative
By the way, the graphic is the same one from the news story, I didn't go seek out a titillating photo for its obvious sex appeal.. they did. Well, then I did seek out the Red Sonja illustration.... But hey...
Dadman
I know you think I think WoW is silly, but the results of this study don't surprise me at all. I actually believe designing role-playing games with interfaces and themes that might be more appealing to seniors is a compelling business opportunity...
CosmicConservative
I know several "seniors" who play WoW (and I'm getting awful close to "senior" status myself). They all find the current design to be quite satisfactory. There are some new MMORPGs with far more realistic graphics, but so far Blizzard has shown no desire to go that direction, even though the vast majority of their user base could easily run more complex graphics today. And I really can't blame them, the WoW look is sort of jarring when you first encounter it, but over time your eye and mind adjust to the stylized races and unique scenery. I haven't played WoW for more than a few minutes in almost a year. I don't "miss it" but I did have a lot of fun playing that game. I wish now that I had spent the $150 or so on a computer generated sculpture of Rhlyssa when I had the chance. She was pretty friggin' awesome.
Dadman
Is it really surprising that 'seniors' who are already using WoW find the current design satisfactory? What would be interesting to know is how many seniors don't play WoW or other MMORPGs because they find the interface/context off-putting in some way. This is Business 101; there might be a great opportunity to grow the use MMORPGs in the senior market if their brain health benefits are highlighted and, perhaps, if some consideration were given to the nature of the games themselves. I would guess someone is already working on it...
Drax
From this near-senior's perspective, I can say that I find the graphics and toonish feel to the game very off-putting. Makes my eyes cross and my head hurt.
CosmicConservative
Drax, my initial impression of the game, even coming from other early MMORPGs was that WoW's cartoonish look was offputting. Especially after playing Everquest II on what was then a state of the art graphics computer. EQ II graphics were amazing for the time, and are still quite impressive. WoW was like a leap back in time. But the play was far superior and as I said, it didn't take long to adjust. Eventually I even grew to appreciate some of the clever design things WoW provided. It grows on you. And Dadman, WoW is still the MMORPG that attracts the most users of any age group, not just us old gamer geezers...
Boyd
One of the reasons I didn't take up WoW until it had been out for a year and a half was precisely due to the graphics (and it's been a few years since AARP first sent me an invitation letter). I'd had Warcraft 3 and was underwhelmed with its graphics even then, and I knew that WoW was based on the same graphics engine. I'd been playing Half-Life (and its offspring) for several years, too, so WoW's graphics were really a downgrade. But a friend who'd been playing WoW from the very beginning finally convinced me to give it a try. Now he's been gone from the game for a couple of years, and I'm still hanging in there.
Dadman
I'm not arguing the merits of WoW, I'm just suggesting the MMORPGs market could be expanded. Brain health in the age of Alzheimers is becoming increasingly more important to an aging U.S. population...
CosmicConservative
Let's see, Red Sonja is probably a level 20 barbarian... Barbarians get AC boosts for not wearing armor I believe. She's probably got a base dexterity of around 26, with a likely +8 on top of that due to magic items. There are a few feats that provide AC boost that she should have, and some barbarian archetypes gain further AC boosts. I'd guess she's got at least a +5 Ring of Protection and a +5 Amulet of Natural Armor (those are both pretty basic items) so even if she has taken the "no armor" route, she's at least AC 38 or so (which isn't that great for an epic level character). So let's assume her chain mail bikini there is treated as full chain mail armor. Fully enchanted, even losing the no armor bonuses for barbarians, that would probably push her AC into the 40s. Which is probably good enough since Red is likely a two-handed whirling dervish of destruction with massive hit points who uber-rages to boost her damage taking limits even further, so AC is probably less important to her than dealing and taking damage...
CosmicConservative
Dadman, I'm not defending WoW, just pointing out that there doesn't seem to be a significant demographic difference in MMORPG preference. Since WoW took over the MMORPG market from Everquest about a decade ago, there really hasn't been a serious challenge to its market dominance. The market for grittier, more realistic graphics seems to trend more towards military first person shooters like "Halo" which run on game consoles instead of PCs. There are some truly incredibly realistic game engines out there now that make WoW's graphics look ancient by comparison, but they still aren't really putting a dent in WoW's dominance. Not yet anyway. My own experience with EQ and WoW was pretty common based on conversations I had with my guildmates in WoW. I enjoyed playing the original EverQuest, even though the graphics were primitive even by WoW standards. But the game play was pretty engaging, and it was the only real MMORPG around at the time I started playing. About the time that WoW came out Sony (who owned Everquest) apparently decided that Blizzard was a serious threat, and so they came out with Everquest II, which used an entirely new game engine, including a new graphics engine. Sony began pushing EQI players hard to move to EQII. They were very aggressive about it, and their constant nagging of EQI players to move to the more expensive version of the game, with new characters started from scratch, new game mechanics, a totally different graphics feel, and a far more draconian skill leveling system... well all that did was make EQI users look hard at WoW, and the vast majority of them fled EQ and opened WoW accounts. EQ never recovered and is now a "free to play" game... WoW does have some really good game dynamics. When my EQI guild fell apart I just quit playing for a long time, probably four years or so. When I finally decided to get back into it, everyone I knew who gamed played WoW so I played WoW. It took a little adjustment to get used to the graphics, but the game play was much superior to EQ II and even had some advantages over EQ I. Once I got used to the graphics, they never bothered me again.
Dadman
Okay...I think you're missing my point. It's simply this: There's a huge population of older folks out there who don't play MMORPGs now (and never have) but might in the future if you 1) touted the benefits such games have on brain health (reference title of your post) and, 2) offered a variety of game design options in addition to WoW. WoW, presently, seems to be the only game in town and I'm guessing most 'seniors' aren't attracted to it. So, I'm merely suggesting there's a business opportunity/market out there that doesn't seem to be fully exploited.
CosmicConservative
OK, perhaps there is a market niche that isn't currently filled by any of the existing MMORPGs on the market, and that niche would appeal to seniors. I sort of doubt it since there are a ton of such games ranging from first person shooters to fantasy D&D clones to "reality show" versions such as "Second Life". I think the bigger chore in getting seniors to play such games is simply to make them aware of their existence and get them more likely to use computers in the first place. The last study I saw on computer use among senior citizens showed a steady increase in the possession and use of computers, but most seniors still used them only for email, light web surfing and social media. Most simply didn't see them as gaming platforms at all, and those who did game on them overwhelmingly gamed in Facebook.
Dadman
That's where marketing comes into play. Tell them they can boost their brain health by playing WoW, or different game designs that might have greater appeal to an older demographic, and business might rise dramatically. It's already happening actually. Success is still TBD because it can be hard to teach an old dog new tricks... ;)
CosmicConservative
Just taking this in a bit different direction, when I hit my mid-forties I decided to deliberately continue to pursue new and interesting hobbies or activities specifically to keep my mind active. I still think tabletop role playing games are one of the most effective ways to keep your brain active and engaged. I intend to play them until I can't roll the dice anymore...
Losty02
As a 74 yr old male who has played wow since it came out, I find the game a real pleasure to play. The "toon" look has never bothered me as it is based on fantasy after all. Finding the right guild has always been my major problem. If I reveal my age, they think I cant play well enough to be included in dungeon runs or raids and patronize me with help I don't need. I now have 3 bank guilds (2 ally and 1 horde)that I play daily. I welcome other seniors to join me as this is a great time to start new characters.