Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

RIP faster-than-light neutrinos

By CosmicConservative
No surprise here.... pretty much the outcome I expected.

Faster-Than-Light Neutrino Results May Be Due to Bad Cables | Wired Science | Wired.com.

The sensational result that neutrinos can travel faster than the speed of light may be undone by nothing more than a simple mechanical error. Scientists from the OPERA collaboration at the Gran Sasso National Laboratory in Italy have “identified two issues that could significantly affect the reported result,” wrote OPERA spokesman Antonio Ereditato in an email. The first issue is a faulty connection of the fiber-optic cable bringing the GPS signal to the experiment’s master clock. The experiment’s GPS may also have been providing the wrong timestamps during synchronization between events. “These two issues can modify the neutrino time of flight in opposite directions,” Ereditato wrote. Back in September 2011, OPERA researchers found bunches of neutrinos arriving 60 nanoseconds earlier than should be possible if they were traveling at less-than-light speeds. The neutrinos traveled 450 miles from experiments at CERN near Geneva, Switzerland. The findings seemed to contradict Einstein’s theory of relativity, which states that nothing can move faster than light. Many in the physics community kept a skeptical view of the findings, suggesting that some unknown source of error had perhaps entered the experiment. The collaboration is now looking to perform a new measurement of the neutrino velocity as soon as the Large Hadron Collider begins operation in March.

Comments (11)

Andy
Cosmic, I had ZERO idea what to make of this post, because I'm close to the "imbecile" range. But, another blogger I read posted on it, too. http://depletedcranium.com/neutrinos-travel-faster-than-light-or-maybe-just-loose-cable/ I've been reading this guy's stuff for a long time and really enjoy it (when I can understand it...it's usually down on my level, and I'm sure he tries hard to KISS). Thought I'd drop you a link to his joint, just in case you haven't come across him before.
CosmicConservative
While general relativity can be used under the conditions and physical constants measured in our universe to derive "E=mc2" that doesn't mean it's true everywhere... The speed of light thing is actually more important than that anyway. In effect the speed of light being the physical limit to speed is essentially a requirement of causality as we understand it. If something can move faster than light, it isn't the laws of physics which break down, it's causality itself. Or to put it another way, if there is anything that can move faster than light, according to our current understanding of the universe, then there is no such thing as cause and effect, it's all just some sort of bizarre illusion. Of course metaphysics has been telling us that causality is an illusion for some time. Most religions have a fundamental premise that the universe is the creation of a supreme being who can do whatever He likes whenever He likes, so in a way finding something that breaks the speed of light would be evidence of non-causal indeterminate metaphysical reality. So, yeah, faster than light neutrinos would be a big deal if they were true.
Drax
I don't know, but I think that the first thing I'd do - before I released results which challenged one of the fundaments of our understanding of the universe - would be to check my equipment...
CosmicConservative
In all fairness Drax, the "equipment" in question here is a massive array of thousands of cables that stretch for miles through the stygian depths of huge scientific "instruments" that are quite literally the size of office buildings. Not saying I disagree, but I can absolutely understand how a partially connected optical fiber cable could have slipped past even a pretty diligent inspection. Typically that sort of validation is done automatically, but if the cable in question was partially connected and so was responding with positive signal results, the corruption of a signal by, literally, a few billionths of a second would not be easy to spot. Which is why it took months for them to finally get to it. I'm sure they have been hand inspecting every cable and chip in that massive device for months, and no doubt they are not done yet.
Drax
Okay. I'll buy that in large part. I'm not clear on whether or not the results were "official" or not (i.e., released as part of a paper in which the findings were put forward as accurate), so, if not, then I'll buy the excuse. If they were released (not pending checking out the equipment, but released) then, won't buy the excuse. When we're talking about measuring such things, even I understand that one of a thousand glitches in the equipment could cause the error - and replication of the results on the same equipment doesn't necessarily confirm the results but, instead, confirm the existence of faulty equipment...
CosmicConservative
Apparently so Dadman. My sense of subtlety has been somewhat awol lately. Can you elucidate?
Dadman
Well, I've never been asked to deconstruct an off-the-cuff, TIC comment before but I'm willing to attempt further elucidation if only to provide additional fodder for analysis. There's been a great deal of speculation about the veracity of the Gran Sasso results in my circle of friends and colleagues. Since I work at Intel (for the moment at least) I'm surrounded by very bright people with strong science backgrounds. Most of these people were saying they didn't 'believe' the results and that they 'believed' the speed of light to be an immutable, universal constant. I agreed with them, but that's beside the point. I've been struck/amused by their, and others, use of language to describe their skepticism that is usually reserved for matters of faith - words like 'belief', 'true/truth', even 'faith', etc. When I said 'I believe E=mc2 is true' I was merely poking fun at this faith-based language to describe their confidence that the speed of light cannot be exceeded. I admit my comment was way too obscure (since you are not aware of the conversations I've been having with other people about this issue), and probably lame... :)
CosmicConservative
Well, once you said it was tongue in cheek I sort of suspected that was where you were going. I've said before that unless you are a total intellectual arnarchist, you "believe" in something. Descartes plumbed the depths of this and came up with "I think, therefore I am." I am just not one who thinks that all "beliefs" are equally plausible and supportable. But I know whatcha mean... I work mostly now in a job where I have very few technical people working directly with me. I miss that actually.