Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Eli again...

By CosmicConservative
Gotta give the dude credit. He delivered the goods. Brady can make the argument that his receivers let him down, but he didn't look sharp after taking that sack.

Comments (11)

Drax
Amazing that, in the Superbowl (again) Billacheat was unable to perform his amazing ability to make his post half-time "adjustments" for which he is so famous - even after Spygate. The Giants made the plays when needed. The Patriots didn't. In reality, Brady played well enough to win. Had his receivers caught catchable balls, the Patriots would have won. They didn't, so he lost. Just another example - again - of why it is the most insipid of all comparisons to count the number or rings on a QB's hand when making the determination as to where they stand on the ladder of historical greatness. Brady could have done everything exactly as he did and won or lost - the number of rings contingent on the play of others. (Eli too - great throw but, without the catch - he's watching Brady put on another ring.)
CosmicConservative
I have mixed feelings about it. I am still a big Brady fan, although I have to admit his star has gotten a little tarnished in the last few years when he has seemed to be rattled on occasion in big games. I have an opinion of Eli very much like my opinion of John Elway. The guy came into the league with a chip on his shoulder and a seriously bad reputation for the "intangibles" at the QB position. But over time I have had to grudgingly give the guy credit for being one of the most unflappable players I've ever seen in any sport at any position. Playing QB in New York is a brutal job description. There probably isn't a press anywhere that is more critical and outside of Philadelphia, a fan base that is more fickle. Yet the guy just keeps his head down and plays the game. You could make a strong case that Eli was the true MVP of the league this year. For half of the season he was pretty much all the Giants had.
Drax
I look at Eli and see what I've always seen (except for the first couple of years while he was learning to play in the NFL) - a high risk/reward player - much like Favre or Romo. He is willing to make the throws into coverage and hope (trust - pray) that his receivers can make the play or, at least, prevent the interception. This year, the reward paid off more than the risk - especially in critical situations. I don't see that he played any differently this year than any other - just that many balls which, in the past, might have been interceptions resulted in big gains in critical situations. No one. Not a single person. Ever. Could make the throw that he made last night more than 1/2 the time. The difference between his making that throw and not was his receiver slowing down at the right time, jumping at the right time, essentially everything which could go wrong NOT going wrong. More than 1/2 the time he makes that throw it gets intercepted or dropped. But, he'll throw it EVERY time in that situation. Many (perhaps most) QB's would not even try that throw. That's why he's wearing that ring and why he wore the last one. And, it's why he'll likely wear another one and go to the Hall. (Eric Mangeni just now is saying that Eli shouldn't have thrown that ball to begin with...Heh.)
CosmicConservative
Well, if that had been a 3rd and 10 throw I might agree with you, but it was a second and seven or something like that I think. It was a high reward play, but for a QB who throws as much as Eli does, I don't think it was that high risk. He put it out in front of the defenders in a place it would either be dropped or caught, not intercepted. As opposed to Brady who threw several balls in the second half that were underthrown or behind receivers and could have been intercepted (one was). I think Brady was hurt and couldn't put full zing on the ball. The one that got intercepted was just a bad throw, the guy was wide open and behind the coverage, and Brady simply couldn't outthrow the linebacker. That's not good in the NFL. I think even Tebow would have put that ball over the linebacker's head.
Drax
Eli threw a couple which could have been (should have been) interceptions. Brady's one interception could have just as easily been either knocked down by his tight end or, if he had stopped earlier or jumped earlier, caught over the head of his smaller defender. So much of what an elite QB does is dependent on how what his receivers do. (Oh, you think that it's a better percentage throw to make on 3rd and long than 2nd down? It was just BARELY doeable on 2nd down when it is less expected than 3rd and long. Both teams were denying the long ball all game. Eli took the shot when it was there and, if he didn't with less than 3 minutes to go, might not be there again.) All I'm saying is what I've always said: A quarterback should be judged on what HE does - not on what his team does. I look at the game last night and see two quarterbacks who played well enough to win and the one who won was the one who had his teammates make tough plays in critical situations while the losing quarterback had his teammates fail to do so.
CosmicConservative
I'm saying that making that throw on second down leaves third down to recover if the ball is dropped or caught out of bounds. If thrown properly that ball shouldn't be intercepted, and Eli threw it properly. Making that same throw on third down means that you have to punt if it's dropped or caught out of bounds, and punting in that situation pretty much loses the game. That's what I meant about it being high reward, but not so high risk.
Drax
Ah. If it isn't the highest risk, then it isn't "high risk?" So, if he makes it on 3rd down, it isn't as "high risk" as if he had thrown it on 4th down (they were in 4 down territory to be sure...)?
CosmicConservative
Yes, I would say that play is higher risk on fourth down than on third down. I'm not entirely sure they were in four down territory right then. Maybe. They still had almost four minutes and I think they had at least two timeouts left. I've seen teams punt the ball and win in that situation many times. They would have only had to hold the Patriots on one series and still kick a field goal to win.
Drax
Heh. Give the ball to Brady where he would have had to only get a single 1st down and the game is over...and it might not be 4 down territory. We could argue this all day. I don't think there's any argument that, taken by itself (not considering down/distance, score and time left) the throw itself was a high risk/high reward pass. You can argue that if you wish. I think that the throw speaks for itself. But, when it comes to whether it is a "higher" risk to throw in THAT situation on 2nd down than on 3rd (or even 4th) down - there are alternative ways to think about it. On 2nd down, you have more options. You have an additional down to get a 1st down, and, at that stage of the game, you must either get a 1st down or a touchdown. Thus, taking that throw into that window with that coverage - was extremely risky when you consider the alternatives he had. On 3rd down, he would have HAD to get either a first down or a touchdown. This makes the throw harder and the consequences greater if the throw is missed - and more likely that it would be missed due to softer coverage short and harder coverage long. But, on 3rd down, he HAS to go 10 yards or better. He doesn't have a choice. If, on the other hand, he had NOT thrown that long throw (and missed in this mind game) and taken a less risky route, his options on 3rd down are greatly increased. THIS is what Manning risked with that throw. So, the argument can be made that it is an inherently MORE risky throw to make such an attempt on 2nd down than on 3rd - especially in that situation where, if he missed, he MUST perform on the next play or the game is likely over - and THAT throw on 3rd down would have been more difficult than it was on 2nd. Regardless. He would have attempted it on 2nd, 3rd, and 4th downs. He's a "gunslinger" in that respect and always has been (as his interceptions testify...)
CosmicConservative
Heh... I would say you're overthinking this. It's riskier as the consequences increase, and they increase down by down simply by virtue of having fewer downs to recover from the failed attempt. I'm not sure I would put Eli in the same category as Favre. I think Eli is more calculating than Favre was. And it hurts badly to say this, but I think he is more accurate in critical situations than Romo is.
Drax
People are almost always "prisoners of the moment." The Giants were 7-7. One of the main reasons they were 7-7 was Eli's poor play in many games. In fact, in only 2 of those 7 losses did he throw more touchdowns than interceptions (and against the best teams - New Orleans and Green Bay). He played like he has always played. Just like he played in the Superbowl where there were at least two "gunslinger" passes which should have been intercepted and a couple which were made to be great passes (and they were) because not only did the receivers make great catches, but the defenders DIDN'T. High risk/high reward. Calculated, to be sure. Drew Brees is much the same. In fact, that is the current model of a successful QB in the NFL. And, when the copycat league goes with two 7' tall tight ends going across the middle against 6' tall DB's, we'll see even MORE of the balls thrown into tight windows where the receiver is tasked with either making the play or preventing an interception. (In between those "great throws," there will be a healthy smattering of zero yardage "passes" where the TE/RB/FB/WR/whomever is given the ball and asked to make something happen. Like the Superbowl, we'll be seeing more and more games where there isn't more than one or two passes of more than 20 yards until desperation time at the end of the game.)