You are supposed to put a "censor" black box across your page or something like that.
CosmicConservative
I had a long conversation about SOPA with the Cosmic Daughter last night. As with most things there are two sides to the issue. The bill itself, as well as the PIPA bill in the Senate, is a travesty of federal government overreach, but the House has already pulled their bill and is rewriting it. How will that turn out? I don't know. But the threat to the livelihood of purveyors of intellectual content posed by the rampant copying and distribution of that content is a very real threat. It is already forcing the music industry to fundamentally transform. Hollywood is just starting to see the impact. Even traditional publishing is at risk.
These are real industries with real jobs who donate real money to real politicians.
The issue is not going away. And it shouldn't. Our culture needs a radical transformation of our approach to intellectual property. The old approach is simply not workable in today's world, and will be less workable in the future.
Andy
I've been trying to decide whether I'm for it, or agin' it.
As a RULE, I despise Congerrss passing them.
I know that the intellectual property landscape has changed because of the 'net. But, it also changed when cassette recorders became widely available, too. Lord...don't know how many copies of CCR I dubbed...not proud of it, mind you.
But, the internet has exponentially increased such "theft." I understand that.
I've read a few pieces (on both sides), and my Libertarian self wins out on this one. But, just barely. At this point, I'm leaning toward less regulation, not more.
It's a tough call. I understand the entertainment industry, and their concerns. But, they are operating in an environment that they should well understand. Spend some of the bazillions you've made to develop technology to protect your stuff.
That would create jobs. And, take decisions away from ignorant/bought and paid for Legislators, and Judges.
Some will argue that such technology can't be developed. I would have a few years back. But, I'm astounded daily with advances in tech. And then there are always the courts, where individual cases can be taken up. I just don't like broad legislation that is open to broad interpretation.
CosmicConservative
Andy, one of my problems with modern life is how people try to take complex issues and demonize those on the other side. But that's just how the game is played today.
Obama is showing some rare political savvy on this issue by not telegraphing his intent yet. If this thing gets to his desk he is going to seriously piss off at least one major constituency that could haunt him in the general election. His best hope is that Congress can't pass anything before November.
I'm sorta like you Andy, my libertarian side is winning out on this too.
People rarely return to first principles. They always seem to start with the status quo and argue from that. If you go back to first principles and investigate the very concept of intellectual property, you can take a lot of the emotion and antipathy out of this debate (and others).
The purpose of our current legal concepts around intellectual property was to deliberately encourage creativity and entrepreneurism. The end result has been to create global megaliths who manage massive portfolios of content. This has tended to stifle, not promote, creativity. Take it from a guy who wants to be a writer and whose daughter wants to be a writer or singer. The current mechanisms for pursuing that goal are so daunting that experts have estimated that less than five percent of potential authors have even submitted a book or book proposal to a publisher. Of that five percent publishers themselves will tell you that less than one percent of submissions are ever picked up by an agent, editor or publisher. Many of those that do get picked up are published and distributed widely. It's a system designed to enrich the publishers of books, not to facilitate the career goals of writers. The same is true of singers and movie stars. If anyone thinks that Madonna is ten times the singer as the best singer on their own block, they are nuts. The difference between an amateur and a professional singer is mostly marketing, and marketing is mostly at the whim of the megalithic corporations.
So taking this back to first principles, I have come to the conclusion that the best approach to content is the approach that promotes the easy and direct publication of content from creators to consumers, with as little Hollywood, Madison Avenue, Random House or Virgin Records as possible in between. Producers will more easily sell their product and consumers will have far greater choice.
Of course those artists are not going to become fabulously wealthy though. They'll just be able to make a living.
Like me.
So put me down as opposing SOPA and PIPA on the basic grounds that I don't like the system in place today, and SOPA and PIPA are entirely about protecting and maintaining the status quo.
Andy
Yeah...what YOU said. I was actually going to go there with the "artist/producer selling directly to the consumer" deal as the optimum.
But, I got distracted by a one-year-old, so I cut my thoughts short before fully typed. Sigh.
With all the BAD things about the 'net, and all the horrible things people use it for, it IS where the world is going/is. I'd hate to see aspects of it shut down before full maturity. And, again, I don't trust DC (or Baton Rouge, or any legislative body) to make thoughtful, forward-looking decisions. It's all about "today & the next election" with the great bulk of pols.
Interesting thought about ObozO pissing off his crowd if this ever passes...interesting.
Comments (5)