Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Yet another Tebow post...

By CosmicConservative
So last night I couldn't help myself. I spent about two hours while listening to the MNF game on the radio perusing all the ESPN, Sports Illustrated, Fox News and other sports "news" sites to see what the latest take on Tim Tebow is. This is actually relatively new to me. I've never cared to read through all the opinions of a bunch of has-been or never-was football players about a player. Normally I just see the headline stories and I sort of assume that those stories reflect the overall opinion of the sports talking heads about a guy. And usually I think that's right. Certainly the NFL analysts have been pretty consistent in their analysis of Jay Cutler (he's the perennial "almost superstar" who never quite gets over the hump) or Tony Romo (he's an erratic conundrum who sometimes seems like he could outplay Brady or Manning, but then lays the most monstrous eggs imaginable at the worst possible times) or Aaron Rodgers (he's going to make Green Bay completely forget about a guy named Brett Fa.... uh.. what's his name?)... So I wanted to see if that was true of Tebow. And it is. The headline stories are all about how Tebow is winning in spite of his awful QB skills. In general the only positive Tebow sports stories are the fluff human interest pieces. All the "hard analysis" stories, even those that are seemingly pro-Tebow, still say that Tebow can't throw, can't operate out of the pocket, won't be a long-term QB and can't take a team deep into the playoffs. Not a single story I've read predicts Tebow will be successful, or even a starting QB next year. The blogs are the worst. The venom dripping from the comments about Tebow is palpable. The guy is HATED with a passion that I don't think I've ever seen. He's hated so much that the hate bleeds over to anyone who supports Tebow. Besides Tebow the most vilified sports figure on the blogs seems to be Skip Bayless, who has been a vocal Tebow supporter on some ESPN talking head shows. If anything the hate for Skip is even MORE than the hate for Tebow. It's really sort of stunning. Every now and then you'll see someone grudgingly give Tebow some credit, but for the most part, no matter what Tebow does, the narrative seems firmly established. He can't throw. He is too slow. His mechanics are unfixable. His accuracy will never improve. He has nothing to do with Denver winning games (the credit is given mostly to Von Miller). If anyone attempts to defend Tebow the sneering condescension heaped upon them is like an avalanche of vitriol. Only an idiot would suggest that Tebow can play in the NFL. Just to say "give the kid a chance" turns you into a "Teblow fan" or worse. So I've taken another look at the rest of Denver's schedule and compared that to the Oakland Raiders schedule. It's almost impossible to believe, but on paper I would say that Denver actually has a slightly better chance to win the division than the Raiders do. Of course the Broncos could lay an egg in every remaining game, but realistically I think the Broncos have a shot to win two or three games, while realistically I think the same is true of the Raiders, and the Broncos have most of the tie-breaker edges over the Raiders. In most scenarios Denver actually wins the tie-breaker. And if Denver wins the division, then they get at least one playoff game at home. And right now I think it looks like if that happens, they would play Cincinnatti in the first round. Could Denver beat Cincinnatti? I believe they actually could. Which would mean that Tebow might actually win a playoff game this year. And if he does, I can't imagine what that level of cognitive dissonance will do to the Tebow-hating population, but more importantly... what does that do to Elway? Can Elway possibly bench Tebow if Tebow takes a 1-4 team and wins an actual playoff game? I don't see how. I think the Denver fan base would turn on Elway in a huge way. Right now I think it mostly hinges on this Sunday. I think Denver HAS to beat Chicago to actually have a chance to win the division. The Raiders still have Green Bay to play, and I doubt they can win that game (but of course... "any given Sunday" caveats apply). Denver has New England. Can Denver beat New England? I dunno...

Comments (15)

CosmicConservative
Looking at the current NFL QB stats for the season is quite interesting. Comparing Tim Tebow to Kyle Orton, both had almost exactly the same number of passing attempts (Tebow has one more attempt). Orton, of course, has a higher percentage of completion by about ten percent. However, Tebow has almost 100 yards more in passing yards, so his yards per attempt is actually HIGHER than Orton's was. Plus Tebow has two more touchdowns and seven fewer interceptions. In the end, in spite of Tebow's lower percentage completion rate, he actually rates higher than than Orton for QB rating. By a good chunk. In fact, if Tebow's attempts were enough to qualify, he would be listed as the #10 QB by QB rating on the QB rating page. #10. That's higher than Jay Cutler, Phillip Rivers, Mark Sanchez, and 20 other NFL QBs. Interesting, no?
JSullins
Even though a careful analysis of the numbers tends to yield a good picture of Tebow, I think they miss the point about the man. He is humble and hard-working, and inspires his fellow teammates. I think that leads them all to be better players, and everything I have heard from interviews of teammates about attitudes on the field and in the locker room tell me that Tebow's mere presence and leadership have as much to do with Denver's resurgence as completed passes and read options.
CosmicConservative
J- Of course that's true. But it doesn't challenge the Tebow narrative. The Tebow critic will say "intangibles schmandibles... the guy can't throw." What I'm trying to show is that focusing on a single statistic (completion percentage) completely ignores the fact that even for a passer there are more important statistics than completion percentage. In every QB rating system I know of completion percentage is factored in at a lesser value than touchdowns, turnovers and yards per attempt. And by those numbers ACCORDING TO THE NFL'S OWN STATISTICS PAGE, Tim Tebow is the tenth best QB in the league. Better than supposed "elite" QBs like Jay Cutler or Phillip Rivers. And as I've pointed out, that ignores the fact that he's added another 500 yards and three touchdowns running the ball. If you look at total yardage from scrimmage and total touchdowns, Tebow's numbers are quite comparable with some of the best QBs in the game. People like Tony Romo or Ben Roethlesberger. I admit it, I have been a little slow to climb on the Tebow bandwagon. His wobbly throws and tendency to duck-hop the ball to open receivers caused me quite a bit of concern. But I simply can't deny the facts of the results. The guy scores touchdowns and doesn't turn the ball over. And that's really the bottom line for a QB. If he doesn't get a shot as a starting QB next year, I will be seriously fed up with the NFL in general. ESPECIALLY when I see QBs like Mark Sanchez or Blaine Gabbert or KYLE FRICKIN' ORTON getting a shot when their results are demonstrably inferior to Tebow, but they have a pretty throwing motion. Bleh!
JSullins
Personally I think there is no way he won't start next year, barring a total collapse in performance. I think the fact that he was given the start at all is due to fan pressure, and that's going to be even more now than it was when it helped get him the spot this season. Elway would end up being torched in effigy if he doesn't start next year, and I think he knows it.
CosmicConservative
Mebbe so... mebbe so... I guess we'll see. But if Elway knows that and is still publicly refusing to commit to Tebow, then I can't fathom his purpose. By not committing to Tebow he is creating a perception that the Broncos don't like Tebow, and that sort of thing can poison a locker room. I suspect Tebow is one of the very, very few individuals whose performance will not falter just because his boss's boss seems to dislike him, but Tebow's not the only person in that locker room. Eventually Elway's apparent doubt will creep into other members of the team, most likely starting with coaches (who first have to impress Elway) and then down to players (who take their lead from coaches).
Andy
All I can say is that this has REALLY been fun to watch. I can't remember what group of talkers I watched for a few minutes last night on ESPN. What I heard was, "Well, the coaching is starting to pay off. Tebow is taking well to instruction, and is correcting, JUST LIKE WE THOUGHT HE WOULD!" I just chuckled. I know what these guys have put Timbow through. I've said it before, and I'll say it again. The guy is a winner. He wins ball games. Three seasons from now every nay-said piece of electronic upload to the 'net will have been scrubbed, in hopes that people will forget how all these experts stomped on the cat. The guy is a winner.
Drax
Skip Bayless has been on the Tebow train since before the draft. He has a good track record on evaluating QB's before they're drafted. (A lot of the Bayless hate is generic...he's an epic bomb thrower...) Some of the "hate" from pundits and players comes from the way things went down. He was announced as the starter. Then demoted as a result of his performance in practice. Then demoted again. (And, if the rumors are true, he was internally listed behind someone on the practice squad.) Then, when Orton was benched, Tebow was leap-frogged over Quinn - who, by the statements of management (Fox/Elway) was a BETTER QB than Tebow. Thus, Tebow was GIVEN a starting job which rightfully belonged to someone else - simply due to FAN PRESSURE, i.e., a "popularity contest," rather than the job (hard to find, eh? Only 32 in the world) going to the person who had EARNED it. Put the style of play into the mix. Then put his abysmal performance (in passing - not percentage but throwing the ball into the stands, etc.). Then top it off with winning and "Tebow Time" becoming the mantra. Finally add the "Thank Jesus" every time he opens his mouth... well, there's plenty of fuel for the fire. I love the kid. I have always thought that anyone who thought that he couldn't play an NFL QB was a drooling idiot. IT'S FOOTBALL. It's, by its nature, one team, led by one man, IMPOSING ITS WILL on the other team. Of course the defense has been a big part of the winning. How could it be otherwise? But, where was that defense under Orton and 1-4? Or, for that matter, ALL LAST SEASON? Tebow's a baller. He will put every iota of his being in every play. Some of his teammates (enough so far) will buy into him. The result is predictable. Oh, yeah. I predicted it....
CosmicConservative
Well, if they beat the Bears, they will have ensured a non-losing season anyway. Just based on the current status, they really ought to be able to hang with the Bears, and if they hang with them, they can beat them. Green Bay is practically a lock to beat the Raiders, so this time next week the "smart" money is probably betting on Denver to be alone in first place. But then comes next weekend. Denver has New England, but Oakland has Detroit. Those are pretty comparable games, I would be greatly surprised if either team is favored. But, if Denver loses and Oakland wins, I believe Denver loses one tie-breaker they have over Oakland (conference record would then be tied I think). Then the next week you have Denver at Buffalo and Oakland at KC. I think Oakland has the edge there, but both of those should be winnable games. So it may well come to the final game of the season with Denver needing help to either win outright or take a tie-breaker. I think if they both win, because Denver would have beaten KC twice, Denver might end up with the tie-breaker of common opponents... I'm so confused... It would be so much nicer if Denver would just win out...
Drax
Denver vs. New England is about the same as Oakland vs. Detroit? Uh. Denver will be at least a 10 point dog to New England. Oakland will likely be within 4 points over Detroit. Oakland/Detroit is close to a coin-flip right now (with Oakland a slight favorite. New England is a heavy, prohibitive favorite over Denver. I agree that, without Cutler and Forte, Chicago is ripe for being beat by, well anyone who can put up points against their still formidable defense. On the other hand, if Oakland can get its act together, Palmer can score with Rodgers and Oakland has a better defense than Green Bay. I wouldn't be surprised if Oakland wins that game. It is an essentially meaningless game for Green Bay and an extremely important one for Oakland. Be an interesting weekend for sure!
CosmicConservative
I don't think the Oakland game is meaningless for Green Bay. They still have not locked up home field throughout the playoffs, and I suspect Rodgers sees an undefeated season as the best way to put a stake through the heart of any lingering sentiment that GB fans might have for Favre over Rodgers. So I'm expecting GB to be prepared and to play hard. I guess you are right though that Detroit's shine has faded while the Pats have been surging, so I do think Oakland will be much less of an underdog than Denver will be against New England. Still neither NE nor Detroit are the Packers, so in that sense the games are somewhat comparable. For Denver vs Chicago I think the key will have to be how well the Deenver D plays I don't see the Broncos scoring many points, but perhaps the D can help out with aanother pick six... Actually, that game may come down to special teams...
Foobarista
A bit of irony is that they said the same stuff - at least about mechanics - about Joe Montana early in his career: he's slow, isn't tall enough, doesn't zip the ball, etc. If Montana had been visibly religious, things may have been equally nasty. The good thing about sports is the scoreboard rules.
CosmicConservative
Foo, the scoreboard is a major factor for sure, but whenever I think that ability trumps everything else, I remember Doug Flutie, who did nothing but lead the Buffalo Bills to a division championship and a playoff spot only to be benched with no explanation in favor of a "more conventional" QB who promptly lost the first playoff game, and Flutie never started another game for the Bills. All Flutie did at every level of football, including the USFL and the CFL, was win, win, win. But he NEVER got a real chance to be an NFL QB because he was "too short" and had "bad mechanics."
CosmicConservative
Besides winning three Grey Cup trophies in the Canadian Football league, none other than John Madden once described Doug Flutie as "inch for inch the greatest QB of his generation". But that wasn't enough to get him a steady job as a starting NFL QB.
Drax
Yeah. Whenever I compare Tebow to anyone else who didn't get a fair shake and was completely misjudged in his ability to play his position, I think of Flutie. When I think of successful QB's with bad mechanics, I think of Randall Cunningham who had the looping throw of Tebow along with a good fraction of his running ability. He didn't get a shot for quite a while either. Funny how BLACK QB's with crappy mechanics (and piss-poor completion percentages) but good feet seem to be hailed as great athletes and are given the opportunity to start (run them off - Kordell, McNair, McNabb, Vick, that Aarron guy that started for New Orleans for a while, among others....) All of them were mediocre throwing QB's (although all with stronger arms than Tebow) but could make plays with their feet or extend plays with their elusiveness (and/or strength). But, it's cool to be a black QB who can run...not so much white. (Just as it's cool for a black player to be religious (remember the "Minister of Defense?") but not so much a white one.
CosmicConservative
On the Denver Broncos team itself, Brian Dawkins is probably a more vocal proponent of his faith than Tim Tebow. Yet nobody cared when Dawkins started each interview with "I want to thank my lord and savior" and it was never a locker room concern when Dawkins led a prayer circle.... Not sure of Dawkins' race though... I personally don't think it's Tebow's profession of faith that gets him in trouble and makes him so hated. I think it's his deliberate efforts to fight abortion since his mother was advised to abort him, and decided not to. THAT's the real reason Tebow is hated by the Left.