Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

NFL week 11 ruminations...

By CosmicConservative
I think this weekend did more to crystallize the likely playoff status of several teams than any previous weekend. At least I hope so. This weekend was a particularly promising weekend for the two teams I watch most closely, the Broncos and Cowboys. I'm sure a whole lot of 'Boys fans and haters will both point to the 'Skins game and Dallas almost losing it as continued proof of the Cowboys' troubles. That's pretty much dead wrong in my book. This was a game that the Cowboys of the past decade lose in a blowout. I was expecting Dallas to lose, frankly, and the only reason they won it is because they played hard for over seventy minutes. Romo had a stellar day against a highly motivated and talented defense. If I would point to anything that concerned me in this game from the Cowboys, it would have to be their lackluster special teams play. They can't cover kicks like that and expect to win playoff games. Looking at the Broncos remaining schedule, I'm optimistic that they'll reach the six win plateau I predicted when Tebow was made the starter. In fact based on where they are now and who they have left to play, I'd be disappointed if they didn't win a few more games. Here are their remaining opponents: Sun, Nov 27 @San Diego Sun, Dec 4 @Minnesota Sun, Dec 11 Chicago Sun, Dec 18 New England Sat, Dec 24 @Buffalo Sun, Jan 1 Kansas City When Tebow first took over these games all looked very daunting. Since then Kansas City, San Diego and Buffalo have all fallen on hard times. If those three teams play the way the have been playing recently, Denver should have a chance to win any of those games. Minnesota was already a winnable game. Which leaves New England and Chicago. New England remains as daunting as ever, but with the news that Jay Cutler is likely out for the season, Chicago might actually move into the winnable column as well. So with five of their remaining six games in the "potentially winnable" column, it would be pretty bad for them to lose them all. Winning one of them would be a disappointment. Winning two would probably be about what I would expect, winning three would be a major sign that the team is moving forward with Tebow. I was actually looking forward to the Chicago game just to see if the Broncos could harass and pressure Cutler into throwing a game away like he used to do for the Broncos so frequently. Anyway, I still think that 6-10 would have to be seen as a major improvement over the past few years, and anything better than 6-10 should be an indication that things are truly moving in a positive direction here in Denver. Of course expectations are higher for Dallas, as they should be. I consider all of Dallas' remaining games as winnable, and going 3-3 would be a disappointment. They really should win four more games, and one of those at least should be against the Giants. that would give them a 10-6 record for the year and a real shot at the division title. Which may be critical since it may require winning the division to get into the playoffs. I do think Dallas is a dangerous team. I think they have the talent both on the field and in the coaching box, to win against any team in the league. But they are still not consistent enough for me to be very optimistic about their chances to go far into the post season. As much as I think Romo is one of the top five QBs in the game, he does have too much tendency to channel Brett Favre (whom he idolizes) and that has cost the Cowboys quite a few big games over the last five years. Until he learns to control his worst Favre-tastic tendencies, I don't think the 'Boys will win a Super Bowl. But if he plays within himself and takes what the other team gives, I think the 'Boys could go all the way.

Comments (6)

Drax
Elway made it clear today that he doesn't think that Tebow is the long-term answer for the Broncos. I don't care if he makes it to the playoffs, wins the division, or even makes it deep into the playoffs - ELWAY DOESN'T WANT HIM. And, they'll keep calling plays in such a fashion to give him the LEAST chance to win while allowing them to SAY that they are changing their offense to accommodate his strengths. (In other words, they'll throw in some "option" plays but not a "spread read" type of offense throughout the whole game. Gives them plausible deniability.) I'm still with 8-8, but with the possibility of 9-7. I think every game is winnable. KC doesn't have it's QB. Chicago doesn't either. Minnesota doesn't have its running back. New England can't stop ANYTHING. San Diego can't run and Rivers is a turnover machine. I wouldn't be surprised if they go 4-2 the rest of the way. And, if so, it'll be in SPITE of the front office and coaching staff. And, if so, he will STILL either be traded or sit on the bench next year.
CosmicConservative
Elway might very well be playing with fire here if that's true. Tebow is rapidly becoming the most popular sports figure in Denver. If he takes this team to a 9-7 record, which would quite possibly make the playoffs, and then Elway benches him or trades him? I don't think Elway has any clue what that would do to his long-held "most popular sports figure in Denver" status. I think the city might well turn on him. One thing to consider is that Denver owner Pat Bowlen has supposedly said very positive things about Tebow, including a comment sometime last week saying that he sees Tebow being in Denver "a long time."
Drax
When Orton was benched, according to the depth chart, Tebow was #3 and shouldn't have taken Orton's place. (According to rumors, he was actually number FOUR on the charts...) This means that Tebow replaced Orton over the objections and judgment of the coaching staff (and, almost certainly, Elway). This could have ONLY been due to Bowlen telling them to start Tebow. Bowlen signed off on and signed the check for Tebow's high draft status. His insistence on starting Tebow over the objection of his "football guys" could not have sat well with them. And, that's why I've been saying for weeks that Fox and Elway are the two most disappointed people in Denver every time Denver wins and why I'm convinced that the play calling has been crafted to give Tebow the least chance at winning while, at the same time, giving the "football guys" plausible deniability.)
CosmicConservative
I'm not sure how Tebow could have been #4. So far as I know Denver only had three QBs on the roster. For him to be #4 would mean that either a non-QB was listed higher than Tebow, or else that a practice team QB was listed higher than Tebow. I haven't heard anything about that. And yes, it was well known that Brady Quinn had "beaten out" Tebow in training camp, but the rumor was also that it was very, very close between the two, and that Orton was far and away above either of them. Or at least that's what I recall. I have mixed feelings about Tebow, frankly. I like the guy, and I love what he brings to the table in the "intangibles" department. And I know that in our debates I have almost always been the one championing "intangibles" over "statistics" (which was my big problem with Cutler as you may recall, I always agreed that his physical skills were off the charts positive, but I also felt his intangibles were off the chart negative). But in spite of all that, I simply can't ignore the fact that Tebow continues to miss wide open receivers less than 20 yards away from him with minimal pressure. In fact he seems to throw better when he is under pressure. As good as Tebow has been in crunch time, if he could make HALF of those throws before crunch time, there probably wouldn't BE a crunch time. I struggle with understanding why a guy who has been a football quarterback for twenty years can be so off the mark on such simple, fundamental throws. I can see how that would frustrate Elway. Now, as far as Fox is concerned, I think he's totally in Tebow's camp now. The whole tone and tenor of his interviews about Tebow has changed dramatically since the KC game. He has even apologized for some of the comments he made about Tebow and has basically said that Tebow is his guy and he will ride him as far as Tebow can take him. And I believe him. I think he sees Tebow as a rare, raw QB talent who can fit very well with the fundamental type of football that Fox likes to play, which is just plain fundamental football which focuses on defense, ball control, not making mistakes and not making penalties. I think Fox sees that type of football as being the sort of approach that keeps teams in games late, and he sees Tebow as the sort of QB who can win games he is in late. That's why I think he has turned around on Tebow. Elway simply sees the QB position as fundamentally being about throwing the ball downfield. And he doesn't see Tebow as a QB who can do that. Right, wrong or indifferent Elway doesn't believe you can win Superbowls unless your QB can throw for 300 yards and three touchdowns reliably, REGARDLESS of what he does with his feet. I think Elway sees the 4-1 record Tebow has put up as a fluke, and Elway doesn't like the idea of every game coming down to a final drive with the game on the line. He wants to sit comfortably and watch his team build a three touchdown lead and THEN run the ball down the opposing team's throats. Bowlen, I think, sees the game in terms of wins and losses, with a hefty dose of fan appreciation and people moving through the turnstiles. Bowlen sees Tebow doing all of that. It's really an interesting convergence of multiple perspectives of what the game is all about. My personal opinion is that of the three (Elway, Fox and Bowlen) it is Bowlen who has it right. Winning games and moving people through the turnstiles is, in fact, what it is all about.
Drax
From Elway's perspective, the "long-term" prospects of Denver must revolve around a traditional quarterback, someone who can throw with accuracy from the pocket. That is entirely understandable. If Tebow is "only" a running QB, then, to have long-term success, the whole offensive team must be changed. They must draft a full-back. Tight ends. Heavy on defense. Then, what if Tebow either goes down or STILL doesn't succeed. The whole team has wasted YEARS in the "long-term" and will have to retool not only its offensive scheme, but its offensive personnel. I just think he's wrong. There's a reason Tebow is missing passes that he made in college and that's because, for the most part, he is in his FIFTH WEEK of playing with this squad with this offensive scheme. He doesn't know how to read his guys yet. Doesn't know how fast they are (or are not). Can't read their body language. When he makes some of the throws, they aren't where he expects them to be. A whole HOST of reasons why he isn't very good - most of them the SAME reasons that just about EVERY rookie (and he's still a rookie) QB struggles with accuracy for the first couple of years. Some comparisons: Peyton Manning was 56% his first year, had a 71 QBR, set the record for most interceptions for QB's, and won only 3 games. Michael Vick: Rookie season (8 games). 44% completion. 62.7 QBR. 2 TD/3 Int (only ran for 1 more). Eli Manning: Rookie season (7 games). 48% completion. 55% QBR. 6/9 TD/Int. Tim Tebow: Rookie year (3 games, conventional style offensive scheme): 50% completion. 82% QBR. 5/3 TD/Int ratio (and ran for 6 more). Next 5 games (2 conventional scheme, 3 "option" style). 44% completion. 78 QBR. 7/1 TD/Int (ran for 3 more). Overall: (8 games - 5 traditional/3 "option") 47% completion. 80 QBR. 12/4 TD/Int. (Ran for 9 more). By ANY metric, at this stage in his career, he is FAR superior to Eli and Vick. By any RATIONAL metric, he is better than Peyton was. (Close in completion % and better in QBR with a FAR SUPERIOR TD/Int ratio, and, uh...WINS.) You know, already, how he compares to Elway. If he's given time to work his way into the offense, he'll get better. He was almost 70% completion in college. He can throw the ball accurately enough to win in the NFL. Michael Irvin (who is coming around) said something on target the other day. Paraphrase: "Pundits need to check themselves. What have we been saying and hearing forever? To win in the NFL, you have to run the ball, stop the run, and not turn the ball over. THAT'S WHAT TEBOW'S DOING." Yeah. That's EXACTLY what Tebow's doing. And, it wins in the NFL - just as predicted by EVERY PUNDIT - except when it's Tebow doing it.
CosmicConservative
I've been giving a whole lot of thought to the argument that all of the QBs you mention doing worse than Tebow doesn't matter. And I think I am finally getting the concept down... The argument isn't about how Elway, Peyton, Vick or others did at the start of their careers. Especially in the case of Peyton and Elway, it's about the "experts" being proven right in the long term. That argument suggests that in spite of Elway, Aikman, Peyton and others horrible starts, the experts were right to continue to promote them as candidates for "elite" status. This same argument could be made for Cutler probably. Following that argument, but looking at the reverse, it means that what Tebow is doing now is no more relevant to the long-term picture than what Elway did then. The "experts" are still "experts" and that means that you can discount Tebow's success because the experts were right about Elway, Peyton and Aikman. I would find that argument much more compelling if those same "experts" hadn't been so thoroughly wrong about Steve Young, Kurt Warner, Tom Brady, JaMarcus Russell, Ryan Leaf, Heath Shuler, etc. etc. etc... Besides that's a totally circular argument. "Tebow will fail because we experts say he will fail, and since we are experts, it is proven that he will fail." Still, I can't help but think that the best way for Tebow to counter all the arguments against him would be for him to complete 70% of his passes in the upcoming game against San Diego. I don't care if that means he is 7 out of 10 or 14 out of 20. If he can manage to pull that off, the most often cited complaint about his ability will be dealt a serious, serious blow. Tebow has to be aware of that. He has to be. And at some point, while winning THIS GAME is clearly a very high priority, he has to realize that he won't continue to get chances to win THIS GAME unless he wins over John Elway. So in one sense he would make a better case for a stronger Denver Broncos and his own future as a starting QB if he LOST against San Diego, but did so by going 24 for 34 for 320 yards, with no interceptions and a couple of touchdowns. Of course if he did that and they WON, that would be even more compelling...