Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

New QB rating system in use by ESPN

By CosmicConservative
The Total Quarterback Rating is a statistical measure that incorporates the contexts and details of throws and what they mean for wins. It's built from the team level down to the quarterback, where we understand first what each play means to the team, then give credit to the quarterback for what happened on a play based on what he contributed. via NFL -- Tom Brady led NFL in QBR for 2010 season - ESPN.
This is interesting. ESPN has essentially ditched the old "Passer Rating" system of rating QBs and replaced it with a new "Total Quarterback Rating" which is based entirely on how much the quarterback contributes to his team's chances of winning games. In the old system a short-passing Joe Montana style QB was heavily favored over a long-throwing risk-taking style Dan Marino style QB, which has long been a major critique of the Passer Rating system. Anyone who's read this blog any length of time has seen the frequent discussions between Drax and me over who the better QBs in the league are. I've always said that I judged QBs based not on their arm and stats, but on their ability to WIN GAMES. For that reason I have always ranked Tom Brady as the best QB in the game, and I've hammered on other QBs like Brett Favre or Jay Cutler because they may make incredible plays from time to time, but that is at the cost of making incredibly bone-headed plays all too frequently. At first glance this new system of ranking would seem to hurt Brady since he is more of a Joe Montana style QB and the Patriots rely heavily on a high-percentage precision passing game. But it turns out that Tom Brady tops this list too. Significantly ahead of Peyton Manning, who is #2. And where do the QBs I routinely criticize fall on this new system of ranking QBs? Brett Favre came in ranked at #32 of 33 rated QBs. Jay Cutler came in at #25. Where do the QBs I routinely call the top QBs come in? Tom Brady, as noted, is #1. Aaron Rodgers is #4. Ben Roethlesberger is #10. Tony Romo is #11 (and that was in a shortened season where he played injured) In fact the only surprises in the list for me were how well Eli Manning ranked (#7) and how poorly Kyle Orton ranked (#21). I guess I have to re-think my opinion of Eli and Kyle... But in the main, I think this new system is probably much better than the old one.

Comments (3)

Drax
Hmmm...gotta look. I'm not judging Favre on a single (bad) season. Any more than I would Brady on a single (great) season with Moss. (Strange how the two highest scoring teams in history had Moss on them and how widely divergent the same QB's with the same teams were without Moss...) Ima look at this new system.
Boyd
Tangentially related, I moved back to Texas earlier this year, so I'm looking forward to being able to watch all the Cowboys games this year. I think Garrett's changes will help Romo shine. At least, that's what my homer instincts tell me.
Drax
Boyd: A more clear statement of my continuing assertion that the system makes the QB could not be made. Matt Cassel nods in your general direction.