Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The twelve planets?

By CosmicConservative
A newly proposed system for designating planets would up the known list of planets from 9 to 12. Basically the new system says anything larger than 800 km in diameter, spherical in shape and in orbit around the sun would be a planet. That would include Pluto, and the asteroid Ceres. It would not include earth's moon, Titan or Europa, all larger than Pluto and Ceres, because they are not in orbit around the sun, but are in orbit around another planet. I think the second part of this definition is too arbitrary. If you want to use physical properties to determine if something is a planet, then stick to the properties themselves. If Pluto is a planet, then our moon is a planet and we are part of a binary planetary system. Sticking the arbitrary rule about "if it is in orbit around another planet" in there is just a way to keep calling the moon a "moon." If we didn't have such a moon around earth, I'm sure such an arbitrary rule would not have been proposed, much less accepted. Let's say, for example, that Ceres is captured by Jupiter's gravity and begins orbiting Jupiter. Does it now become a moon after having been a planet? Doesn't make sense. Of course using my rules, we'd have about 20 planets. OK with me.

Comments (1)

CosmicConservative » Earth’s moon could become a planet
[...] This is a good example of why I think the current moon/planet designation proposal is plain stupid. They set it up specifically to allow the moon to still be called a moon, but the definition they chose so they could do that (that the center of gravity of the earth-moon system is within the radius of one of the bodies, in this case, the earth) is not permanent, and one day it will no longer be true. So with the proposed plan an object could be a moon on Monday, and a planet on Tuesday. [...]