Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

butter, bacon and cheese omelette...

By CosmicConservative
Yeah, that's what I had for lunch today. Two egg omelette, made with milk whipped in instead of water. Cooked in bacon fat and butter. Two strips of bacon! A hefty dollop of cheese! Have I gone crazy? Maybe. I read an article on weight control that the Cosmic Wife referred to me. It is by a weight loss researcher who has a revolutionary and controversial theory. He says that most diet programs make people fat. The statistics do seem to back him up. The vast majority of diets fail. He is particularly contemptuous of calorie counting diets. You know, the dieting that I've been doing. His theory is that the most commonly recommended way to lose weight is just about the worst way to try to lose weight imaginable. And it is absolutely the worst way to try to keep weight off. The typical diet regimen is based on eating fewer calories, avoiding fat like the plague and exercising more. The theory is essentially based on thermodynamics. Take in fewer calories and increase your energy burn rate, and you will force the body to burn reserves. Why doesn't it work? Not because of thermodynamics, but because of biochemistry. The typical diet program wreaks havoc on the typical body's insulin production. Starving the body of fat causes the body to want to make fat, so it reacts by changing the cellular chemistry so that fat cells get more efficient at storing fat. This causes your energy level to drop like a rock, and causes your body to burn carbohydrates at a higher rate, resulting in an energy deficit that is manifested by increased hunger and craving for fatty foods. In essence, according to him, if you wanted to do the most you could possibly do to make yourself hungry, the typical diet is what you would do. His recommendation? Eat enough fat to keep your biochemistry stable, and enough protien and fat to keep your body from going into energy starvation. In other words, eat that cheesy, buttery pizza. Or in my case that cheesy omelette. If you do, he says, you won't be hungry. Just learn to eat enough to satisfy your actual hunger and then stop. So this morning I had my typical breakfast bar, but added to it a strip of beef jerky with 45 calories, half of which were fat calories. Then I had the buttery, cheesy omelette for lunch. And you know what? I have not been craving food all day. I ate lunch 7 hours ago and I'm still not feeling that sort of hunger I've been feeling for weeks. Will this work? I'll keep you posted.

Comments (13)

Andy
Cosmic, from personal experience, the "no fat" diets really do fail in the long run. Most people put it all back on eventually. I've maintained my weight since I had the big loss at just shy of 30, without worrying about fat intake. Fat is good for us in many ways, and appetite suppression is one (at least in my case). But, I don't crave fat, or fatty foods. At least not often. And when I get a hankering for cheesecake, or ice cream, I just indulge (moderately), and then go back to my normal routine. Everyone is different, though. What works for me doesn't work for others. I think we've each got to experiment (sometimes over many months or years) to figure out our particular "perfect" diet.
CosmicConservative
Yes, I did visit my doctor yesterday. He did recommend staying on the Lexapro since I'm not having major side effects and it does seem to have some positive impact. Still, he said it's not having the overall effect he was hoping for. My blood pressure was down in the normal range. The doctor seemed pleased by my weight loss. He suggested shooting for 170 since I'm already down close to 180 and still losing weight without problems. He wants me to come back in six weeks to evaluate if I need to stay on blood pressure medicine or can stop taking it, or reduce it significantly. On the diet thing Andy, I think one reason I've been doing pretty well on this diet is that I've been snacking on nuts. Nuts have pretty high fat and protien content, and other than cauliflower, carrots, broccoli and radishes, they've been my primary snack food. We ran out of nuts a few days ago and due to heavy snow we didn't go to the store for a few days, and I could really tell a difference in my hunger and craving for something fatty. So we refilled the nut canister yesterday. I am at one of those psychological barriers again, pushing down to the 180 range, trying to break through and see that 7 come up on the scale.... Hopefully just a few more days... Wish me luck.
Dadman
My immediate reaction to this post, before seeing the comments, was that the nuts you've been eating would have provided all the fat you need - the poly-unsaturated kind - and that eating cheese and bacon loaded with saturated fats to mitigate hunger should not be necessary. I'd stick with the nuts. I hear macadamia nuts are excellent for snacking...
CosmicConservative
I think the nuts have been working well, and I did get some more nuts so I've been nibbling on them again. I am adding a piece of beef jerky to my breakfast every morning though. That has definitely made a difference in my craving of snacks before lunch. And it's only 45 calories anyway, so not a huge impact. (One cookie is about 90 calories.) I have been unable to get out and walk at lunch lately. Too cold or snowy. I'm hoping things warm up a bit so I can resume my daily walks.
Yup
ummmm I wouldn't do the pizza much. not due to the sauce, cheese or the toppings - but the crust. Simple Sugars are one of the best things you can eliminate from any diet. Nuts and good fats are great. Heck the Atkins diet and South Beach you're encouraged to eat a lot. They just differ on the implimentation.
Drax
Heh. My advice to all dieters has always been: "1) Find one thing which you habitually eat or drink which is fattening (cheese, soda, ice cream - whatever) and stop eating or drinking that thing. 2) When you are eating your meals, once you are no longer hungry, stop eating." If you do these two things, the weight will fall off steadily.
CosmicConservative
Heh... well, I think I will go back to my old counting calories diet... I lost about half as much this week as previous weeks...
Drax
But, you're around 180? At your height, that's quite acceptable, isn't it?
CosmicConservative
Yeah, 181 this morning, meaning I only lost a pound or two since last week. That's by far the worst week so far from a losing weight perspective. But I still have too much flab around my belly. I don't have any desire to be all "buff" but I am tired of flab around my belly. I'm going to try to get rid of as much as I can. So long as I can still grab a double handful of it, I'm not going to be satisfied.
Drax
The pace of weight loss should slow down to an absolute crawl as you approach your "ideal weight," (and I think you have already hit it) - else you're not losing weight, you're starving yourself.
Drax
See... While I can't completely disagree with the reasoning behind the reason why diets don't work as you posted, I almost do. My theory of why dieting doesn't work is because it's dieting -- not a change in eating HABITS. What should be done is to alter eating HABITS, but (as I noted above) to do so marginally - combined with the HABIT of stopping eating once you're no longer hungry rather than when you're "full" (read "stuffed" or "overeaten" or "gorged yourself" or whatever). This is a healthy way to lose weight gradually. Most importantly, the "dieter" won't constantly feel DEPRIVED and HUNGRY, so that, once the weight has come off, they say, "okay, I can eat differently (read "badly") again." And, predictably, the weight gradually comes back. Rinse and repeat. Instead, if you just do as I suggest and change your eating HABITS, then, your weight will gradually fall off (as it gradually fell on) and, most importantly, your eating HABITS will change so that, when you reach your "ideal weight" you will never have felt "deprived" or think that "now you can start eating normally" again - because YOU ARE. Just my two cents.
esox67
Ham and eggs in the morning on a regular basis and pistascio's for snacks have kept me at about the same weight for many years. It is all about what you eat and your habits. While probably considered overweight, I am at least very stable, and I work out and get aerobic exercise on a regular basis also.