Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

On Liberalism and Reality

By CosmicConservative
I am going to paste in most of a comment I had on another post because I think the subject matter deserves its own thread. So here is what I said in the thread on the 24 Muslim terrorists just arrested in Britain after Dadman had suggested that anti-profilers (meaning most liberals) had a death wish:
I think its denial. They truly don’t believe they are personally in danger yet. Go to Daily KOS and read the comments on these arrests. There are as many comments implying that this whole thing is a put-up job by Karl Rove as there are discussing the possible implications of an actual attack. Many of the Left are truly unhinged. I mean truly and deeply caught in a world-view that is absolutely at odds with physical reality. In another post I described the difference between Left and Right as the difference between “mooning for utopia” and “dealing with reality.” I think that’s actually profoundly true. I talk with a lot of Lefties, and many of them simply cannot accept that reality does not conform to their ideals. When I tell them that captitalism works because it recognizes that people will do what is in their best interest, almost to a person the response is “That’s the problem! People shouldn’t be so selfish!” As if they themselves do not pursue their own self interest with every bit as much (and sometimes much more) vigor as I do. It is a deeply entrenched blindness that is so deeply ingrained in their worldview, that it allows someone like Al Gore, who owns three houses and consumes resources at orders of magnitude above me, to lecture me about conservation. There is truly a complete inability to confront reality. They prefer the utopian world and simply wish the real world away. Including the reality that millions of rabid, insane fascist theocrats want to kill them in horrible painful ways. They just don’t believe it.
A few additional comments: This is not to say that conservatives don't also have their own blindspots and their own problems with reality. I most frequently run into conservative dogma in the religious realm, where the great evolution vs. creationism debates rage, so I try to recognize the blind spots on both sides. But I do believe that the denial of reality is strongest with liberals who simply cannot understand that the world that they think they want to live in would have to be populated by something other than human beings, including the exclusion of themselves. Human beings simply don't act the way that they so desperately need to believe that they do. "Imagine no possessions..." is one example. Lennon got it right when he said "I wonder if you can..." It's pretty clear that he and Yoko certainly couldn't imagine living without John's name listed first on all the Beatles songs that he and McCartney wrote, even if McCartney wrote them. They are so unable to imagine living without possessions that they have repeatedly taken Paul McCartney to court to retain that possession. And John and Yoko are liberal saints. It's all well and good to sing about such things, and pat yourself on the back for being able to "imagine" them, but when push comes to shove, all the liberals I know are just as good at grabbing that brass ring as any conservative I've seen. And yet they still claim to believe that their ideology is workable. It is a profound blindness that is the equal of any religious dogma I've ever encountered. And it leads to the monumental hypocrisy of an Al Gore, Barbra Streisand or Robert Redford lecturing us mere mortals on how to conserve energy while they jet around the world in private jets, keep multiple mansions to live in and generally consume more material goods and services than a hundred of the "mere mortals" they are so sincerely lecturing every day. They can do it because they simply cannot even see their own hypocrisy. They are immune to it because they are "fighting the good fight" and therefore their own excesses are excused because they are working to save the world, one mere mortal at a time. And that makes them feel sooo good. Again, my personal belief is that the main difference between liberal and conservative is that liberals are mooning for utopia and conservatives are trying to deal with reality. At least I think that's true of us rational conservatives.

Comments (9)

Dadman
A wise individual once said that the basis of his conservatism was the fact that human nature has no history. It makes a lot sense if you think about it. Liberals are constantly striving to implement their utopian vision - Thomas Sowell calls it the vision of the anointed - by leveraging the power of government to essentially force others to live in accordance with their idealistic values. But their efforts are doomed to failure because human nature and utopia are simply not compatible regardless of how badly liberals want it to be so. As a species we are not evolving into more enlightened creatures with a greater capacity to live the kind of enlightened existence liberals dream about. Human nature remains constant and it's its less desirable qualities will continue to disappoint our sensitive liberal friends. That's the reality liberals just can't seem to grasp. In practical terms this means that we will always need a strong military to preserve the liberties we cherish. War is sometimes necessary. There is evil in the world and it will not slink away if you talk nicely to it. It proactively seeks our destruction. Political and economic systems must recognize the selfish aspects of human nature to thrive. That’s why capitalism and our federal republic work. As people, we tend to reap what we so. Life is not fair. Etcetera... Liberals need to deal with it...
Drax
While I agree that HumanKind is not "evolving" as liberals would wish, I do not believe that HumanKind is not CAPABLE of changing its collective thinking (as opposed to actual evolution) so that it more closely approximates "utopia" than it does the Sudan. Just think about the changes in Western thinking over the past couple of hundred years. As a general rule, we have accepted that slavery is wrong; that women are our equals; that no race is superior to another; that religions other than our own are worthwhile (even if incorrect in their interpretation of the supernatural), etc. What is wrong with the liberals isn't that they want utopia, hell, I want it too. What is wrong is that they want it NOW and that they fail to understand that other civilizations are not so far along with their thinking as are some of the Western Civilizations. It took us many thousands of years to arrive at the foregoing conclusions, and will take hundreds of years (assuming that we all survive) for these other civilizations to come to the same conclusions that we have--if ever they do.
Dadman
Yes, I would like to live in a utopia too, but I know it's not going to happen. My argument is not that human beings are not capable of enlightened behavior or positive change. Western civilization has made great strides in the areas you mention. Heck, the Constitution of the United States is a miracle in the annals of human history, but I would argue that our enlightened system of government is successful (so far) because it recognizes the foibles and dangers of human nature. Hence, our separate branches of government with multiple layers of checks and balances. History is punctuated with positive manifestations of human nature. The Renaissance and the emergence of federalism and democracy are prime examples. However, it is fairly clear that advancements in human thinking and human institutions are achieved in spite of our fundamental nature. And that's my key point. Human nature is constant and we need to be consistently and deliberately vigilant against it's darker aspects. For every step humanity takes forward it seems, without fail, it takes a step back. Nazism and present day Islamofascism are two great examples of ugly steps backwards. A thousand years from now, I believe, the struggle will continue...because human nature indeed has no history.
Drax
I'm not as convinced as to the "nature" side of the "nuture/nature" argument as you seem to be, as I believe that it is our thoughts, not our nature, which decides our behavior, and thoughts can be changed while our nature is malleable. The less "nuture" there is, the more we are, individually and as a society, likely to succumb to our "natures." By the same token, when the "nuture" is like that which is visited upon the children in most Muslim states, where hatred of all "not us" is taught from the earliest age, their "natures" are fundamentally altered -- but not because they are evil, but because they are TAUGHT to do evil and believe it to be "good." Take the same children, raise them in America, and I would submit that very, very few of them would be willing to strap bombs on themselves and walk into a restaurant for the glory of Allah.
Dadman
The successes and failures of humanity are an ebb and flow. The United States is a relatively unique success story in the history of the world and while I agree with you that children raised in the United States guided by the ideals enshrined in our Constitution are not very likely to strap bombs to themselves and murder innocents in the name of Allah, don't be too surprised if that happens someday. That scenario was unthinkable in England until last summer until some British citizens blew up their fellow citizens on buses and trains. Again, my point is that human nature does not change and we must be keenly cognizant of that fact. Liberal don't seem to be. They seem to think with the right mix of legislation, activist courts and political correctness that our fundamental human nature can somehow be surpressed. The reality is the American experiment could fail. Tyranny and totalitarianism could flourish once again. The Dark Ages part deux could emerge. Islamofascism could grow in influence and perhaps even succeed in destroying our way of life. Who knows what the future holds? I just know that we can't pretend like the dark side of our natures has somehow been rehabilitated or modified and hope to survive. This philosophy goes a long way in explaining why I consider myself a rational conservative and political realist.
qwerty182764
The fact that liberals desire a better world is not quite the problem. The problem is that the world that they do desire won't work (in some cases, it's incompatibility with human nature, in many others it is lack of even internal consistency), won't happen, and wouldn't be "better" in any case. I desire a better world. I have seen the amazing progress that the western world has made since the bronze ages, and I hope that we will continue to grow and improve, getting indefinitely better. But I also understand, emprically and to some extent theoretically, why socialism, communism, and any other form of elite control will never yield an improvement over what we've acheived so far. If every attempt to suppress mankinds "selfish" (in the sense that liberals imagine capitalist businessmen to be selfish, ie they desire to produce good things for themselves) nature results in something worse than if it was allowed expression, then in what sense can mankinds "selfish" nature be said to be undesirable? The "greed" of an industrialist (desiring something, and then acting to produce it), is of a far different nature than the greed of a barbarian king (desiring something that someone else has, and then acting to take it). Production is not the same as predation, regardless of the fact that liberals can't seem to parse the two.
CosmicConservative
Production is not the same as predation, regardless of the fact that liberals can’t seem to parse the two.
Well said qwerty
qwerty182764
"I’m not as convinced as to the “nature” side of the “nuture/nature” argument as you seem to be, as I believe that it is our thoughts, not our nature, which decides our behavior, and thoughts can be changed while our nature is malleable." I agree. Humans may have the same natures, but it does appear to be culture that influences our behavior to the largest extent. Look at the differences between the Israelis and the Palistinians, for an example of how different the end behavior of human beings can be. Progress from our tribal past would be impossible if human behavior were impossible to modify through culture.
Dadman
Human behavior can be modified...human nature cannot. So I believe we are in agreement that liberals tend to pine for an untenable utopian world that is often at odds with human nature itself while conservative philosophy seeks to leverage the realities human predisposition. My greatest hope is that our governments, communities, laws, institutions, etc. will continue to nudge humanity toward even greater levels of enlightenment than we know today. I believe that is possible. But we are going to have overcome some of human nature's darker tendencies along the way...