Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

On food and eating..

By CosmicConservative
I know that there are entire pHD theses written on the subject of why people get fat. I know that there are extenuating circumstances ranging from low body metabolism to thyroid issues to diabetes, etc. But for me I've always just accepted that I was fat because I ate too much of the wrong kinds of food and exercised too little. Of course that realization never did a whole lot of good to my overall self-image and confidence in my own will power, but that's still what I accepted. Now with this diabetes diagnosis I've had to really bear down and exert the will power I do have to stick to a rather strict diet. So far today I've had a breakfast bar (100 calories) and a half-bowl of chili (estimated to be 400 calories). Tonight I'll have leftover chicken fetuccinni alfredo. I've certainly been eating tasty, tasty food since embarking on this diet. So this has caused me to wonder about why I was eating the way I used to eat. (By the way, I am playing a bit of a psychological game with myself by always referring to my previous eating habits in the past sense. I want my brain to fully come to terms with the idea that I no longer eat that way.) Why did I eat such huge portions when I sat down to eat? The meal I purchased at Red Lobster this past weekend would normally not have satisfied my appetite and I'd have eaten several of their biscuits as well as probably grabbing some shrimp from my daughter's plate since she usually doesn't finish them. But eventually I would finish eating. At that point I no longer had any immediate gratification of biting, chewing and swallowing. Taste is a fleeting sensation anyway, it only happens during the short period that you have food in your mouth. Twenty minutes after you eat, that's all gone anyway. And since you can increase the tasty time by more thoroughly chewing your food, taste isn't really totally dependent on food quantity anyway. It's more about anticipating, savoring and remembering than it is about how much you eat. So why did I eat so much? What signal is there that told my brain that I was FINALLY satisfied with shoveling huge hunks of foodstuffs into my maw? It wasn't the "sense of being full" that people talk about. Yes, I admit it, I frequently continued to eat after my "full sensor" had already gone off. Why? What made me take that "one more bite" when I had already eaten plenty? Was it just that food was on the table? Is it a visual and olfactory stimulus thing? I'm wondering about this because I think if I can figure it out, I can completely reset my food expectations. In terms of taste, what's the difference between 15 minutes of eating and 20 minutes of eating? Half an hour later it's all a memory anyway. In terms of nutrition, I clearly was scarfing down far more than I nutritionally needed to eat. Logic tells me that so long as I am getting enough food to sustain myself, it really should not matter whether I eat a half bowl of chili instead of a full bowl of chili. The only sensory difference in the long run is how long it took to eat the meal. Once the meal is done, it's done, whether it was a half bowl or a full bowl. At the (literal) end of the day, whether I ate an extra helping of turkey at dinner is a miniscule difference in actual sensory life experience. I think the key to sticking to a healthier diet, losing weight and getting my blood sugar under control, really totally boils down to one thing: Learning to recalibrate my appetite. That's all. Learning to be satisfied with a suitably sized meal is the whole key. I have to wonder how much of my over-eating was actually some sort of sensory compensation for what I perceived as a lack of stimulation in other areas of my life. If so, then changing my lifestyle to one that provides adequate stimulation from non-food sources should make it easy to stick to my diet. This whole thing is making me really take a hard look at what my priorities in life were/are. Apparently quantity of food was a pretty high priority. That's sort of embarrassing, really. I've always viewed myself more as an appreciator of quality than of quantity. Perhaps one of the ways to change my outlook is to truly focus on quality of food for stimulation instead of quantity. Hmm... food for thought....

Comments (10)

Dadman
I went through this back in 1997 when I lost close to 40 pounds in about 4 months. You may recall how incredibly svelte I was at our 20th high school reunion. ;) Anyway, the secret to my success then was very similar to what you've described - I completely redefined my approach to eating and food and did so successfully for about 5 years. Then I lost focus and began to slip back into bad eating habits. Can't really say why, it just happened - slowly but surely - and by 2002 I had gained about 20 of the 40 pounds back. A couple of years after that I had gained nearly all of it back and now my weight hovers between 195 and 205. You, of course, know backsliding is common, particularly for those who don't have the propspect of Type 2 diabetes staring them in the face. So, I believe you'll be more successful at maintaining the changes than I was because something serious is on the line. In that sense, I think it's fair to say your recent diagnosis may just be a huge blessing in disguise. Of course, those of us who continue to be 'fat' and eat poorly are just living on borrowed time. It's really just a matter of time before our chickens come home to roost and when they do will we eat them, deep-fried, or stir-fry them with a side of assorted steamed veggies?
Terri
I am appreciating your struggle with the new diet and wish you luck. Personally, changing the amounts of my eating is my new "thing" this year. While not being hugely overweight, I constantly work at it. And the work comes from not being good at limiting the food intake. I figure if I can learn how to eat right amounts, then I can enter old age with a more relaxed attitude and less stress. January 4 and I am still feeling deprived, though not hungry. I don't know why I overeat, must be compensating for something. Maybe it is lack of stimulation from a sit down job at the computer......hmmmm. Anyway, thanks for sharing your own fight!
Andy
Good piece, and good comment, Dadman. With me, I think it was the "clean your plate" mindset. As long as there was still food available, I was gonna gorge until it was gone. When I got serious about losing weight, Pam helped me by only cooking enough. And, I'd take my lunch to work, and only take what was in the diet for the day. There were certainly a lot of things going on in my life at the time emotionally, spiritually, family issues, etc. that had to be worked through along with my weight problem. But, in a way it was just as simple as removing the temptation, and not cheating. I still despise going to an all you can eat buffet. I'll pick any other option when going out to dinner, unless someone else insists. The reason I hate it is that I KNOW I'm going to stuff myself like a pig, going back time after time...and I'm going to feel miserable afterward. But, I still do it. If it's there, I'm going to eat it. That's why I still call myself a fat guy. Even though it's been over 20 years, I KNOW that I would blow back up if I gave myself a chance.
CosmicConservative
Heh, I'm pretty well immunized against all you can eat buffets simply by watching what the kids whose parents turn them loose with no supervision do to the food. I'd rather do anything but go to an all you can eat buffet, but not because I'm tempted to eat too much. Quite the opposite. I call them "food trough pig wallow restaurants". Drives the Cosmic Wife crazy, her family loves them.
Drax
Good job on the diet! I would offer my advice on keeping your weight down or taking unwanted weight off, but NO ONE wants to hear such advice from someone who has never had to wrestle with his weight. So...Keep it up!
CosmicConservative
As the Cosmic wife would say, I've never had to "wrestle" with my weight either. On the rare occasions I took it upon myself to lose weight, I've always been able to lose weight. The problem is that I haven't stuck to it for long periods of time. After initially getting off soda and fried foods a decade ago, and losing 25 pounds without really even trying, I just gravitated back to poor eating habits. Some people truly do "wrestle" with losing weight. It's a real struggle for them. And they are constantly trying to lose weight. The fact that I can change my diet and lose six pounds in two weeks is a source of some frustration for the Cosmic Wife. When she tries the same thing, she does not have the same results and her energy level declines drastically. My energy level seems to stay pretty constant no matter what or how much I eat.
Andy
Yeah, Pam gets pretty frustrated with the fact that I dropped it like a rock, and seem to be eternally skinny, while she struggles to lose it. She has lost about 25 pounds in the last year, though. It's tougher for women...especially for short women with a lot of fat people in their genetic make-up. She has worked VERY HARD at it, so I can understand her frustration. But, 25 lost the right way is better than losing 50 that will come back.
CosmicConservative
The whole point of this diet is to improve my health, not to lose weight, but I have to admit that I am starting to look forward to the prospect of getting rid of my "paunch." I've always been embarrassed by the fact that my belly precedes me into a room by a few seconds, and that I could reach down and grab a handful of goopy fat any time I felt like it. My dad used to call it "Dunlop's disease" as in "I Dunlopped over my belt." It will be good when I can no longer fold my belly over my belt buckle. I'm looking forward to it.
davera
I think you're on the right track with recalibrating your appetite and eating. Personally, I have been extremely fortunate to somehow have a self-calibration circuit for my appetite. When I have been on a months long workout regimen, I eat more and gain a few pounds of muscle weight, when I inevitably backslide and become more sedentary, my appetite ramps down and my weight drops back a few pounds along with the muscle shrinkage. This has been a repeating cycle for the last 30 years. I don't know how this happened and cannot claim to any great willpower with it ... so just lucky in metabolism.
CosmicConservative
Well Dave, as I see it there are those who have won one or more of life's lotteries in their lives, be it keeping their hair, maintaining their weight, having their health, etc... And then, of course, there's me. Someone has to balance out the bell curve...