Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

On Tolerance and bigotry

By CosmicConservative
The news today that the terror plot to blow up several airplanes over the Atlantic Ocean was tipped off by a member of the British Muslim community has given rise to several posts, including posts at Dean's World, which are trumpeting the fact that a Muslim provided help in foiling this plot as evidence that those who point out that worldwide terrorism is virtually the exclusive venue of Muslim extremists are being unfair to Muslims. This seems to me to be a remarkable stretch of circumstances to fit an idealized world view. I am absolutely fine with giving credit to the British Muslim for having tipped authorities off, but that does not in any way mitigate the fact that the terror plot was devised, planned and was about to be executed by 24 Muslim extremists. On the one hand I don't want to call people who jump to such conclusions "Muslim apologists" but on the other hand, I don't want to get labeled as a "bigot." How do we recognize both realities and use the bare facts to help plan to avoid future terrorist attacks? There is clearly a risk of alienating fence-sitting Muslims by harping on the Islamic connection in terrorism, but ignoring the reality of the profile of the jihadist seems at least as dangerous, if not more so. I lean towards profiling and recognizing that there is an obvious and profound connection between Islam and terrorism so that we can effectively deal with the situation. Where do you stand?

Comments (2)

Drax
Only a person utterly bereft of sense doesn't recognize that those who plan and execute these murderous plots are almost entirely muslim. By the same token, anyone who thinks that all muslims desire to kill anyone who thinks differently is likewise bereft of sense. The problem is that the recognition of the first truth causes the knee-jerk PC crowd to impute acceptance of the second, thus, if you recognize that it is fanatic muslims who commit these acts, you MUST believe that all muslims are fanatic muslims. I would have thought that elementary school teachings of sets and subsets would have solved this conundrum.
Spence
I think the fact that an individual from the British Muslim community helped to prevent these attacks is excellent news. Muslim communities inside western countries may be the best-equipped individuals in our societies to spot these villains. With that said, I don’t think this individual did anything that most Christians, Jews, Hindus, Agnostics, Atheist, Taoist, Buddhist, or Pagans wouldn’t have done had they learned of the plot. Hopefully, most people in our society, regardless of their spiritual beliefs, recognize our responsibilities to protect each other. I believe this responsibility extends to protecting Muslims in our communities from backlash. Certainly another useful tool in this war is profiling. The consequences are simply to high not to leverage this method. Giving scrutiny to middle eastern males between the ages of 16 and 40 would, at a minimum, make it harder for the fanatic poltroons to murder our citizens (even if the New York Times leaks that we are employing this tactic).