Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

NPR gets the analogy bass-ackwards

By CosmicConservative
Here NPR's Geoff Nunberg decides that the "word of 2010" was "no." This apparently is a yearly stunt that he promotes on NPR. After the required snarking on why he didn't choose Sarah Palin's "refudiate" he went on to explain how the Republicans came to use "no" to define their opposition to the Obama administrations attempts to lurch this nation into bankruptcy. As he points out, it was first the Democrats and Obama who tried to brand the Republicans as the party of "no." But that effort backfired as he describes  below.
What was different this time is that after some early defensiveness, a lot of Republicans embraced the label and even ratcheted it up a notch. "We're not just the party of no," Rush Limbaugh said, "We're the party of hell, no!" — and Republican leaders quickly adopted the line. That extra word shifted the meaning of the phrase — it no longer suggested just opposition to particular bills and programs but unapologetic and resolute defiance.

That stance clearly resonated with a lot of voters. "No" has a great power to bring people together, precisely because it doesn't have to be pinned down. A child has a much harder time mastering "yes," which is always the response to a specific prospect — "Do you need to go potty?" Whereas the child's first "no" comes earlier, as a pure eruption of willful refusal. And the word retains that capacity, even as we learn to intone it to convey despair, anger, defiance, fear, astonishment, disappointment or resignation.

That's what makes these choruses of negativity so hard to read, whether they're coming from unhappy voters or tired preschoolers in full shutdown. Everybody is sounding the same plaintive note, but it isn't as if there's any single juice flavor that will make them all happy again.

via Knowing Geoff Nunberg's 2010 Word Of The Year : NPR.
Get it? We're children. And we're whining because we can't have the juice flavor we want. This has all the typical NPR subtlety of a flying asian carp hitting you in the face while zooming down the Ohio River. But the truth is that he's got this whole thing totally backwards. Yes there are children involved, but the children are the elitist Leftist nanny-state collectivists who want everything, want it now, and don't want to hear that mommy and daddy don't have the money to pay for it. The ones saying "no" here are the PARENTS who are doing their job by telling the whining, narcissistic, reality-impaired brats "NO!" when the brat just won't shut up about how unfair it is to not get what he/she wants.

Comments (10)

Reggie Wooster
the bad part is I'm forced to pay part of this douche's salary. NPR...radio for the second rate...where else do you find radio "personalities" with speech impediments or accents so heavy they are barely understandable
CosmicConservative
Sigh... I can't believe nobody commented on my brilliant flying asian carp analogy. Sometimes I wonder why I try to be so clever... ;-)
Andy
Okay, I picked that one up on the first read-through, and did think it was pretty sharp. I guess when you get used to brilliance you just kinda expect it. ;)
Dadman
I thought it was funny. Had you said in my presence you would have seen me chuckle...
Tom DeGisi
> I can’t believe nobody commented on my brilliant flying asian carp analogy I don't get the joke. =>.>= Can it be explained? Yours, Tom
CosmicConservative
Flying asian carp are a fish species that has invaded much of the lower Mississippi river drainage system. NPR has run some stories on how they are displacing native fish. The fish themselves, which can easily get over 10 pounds have the alarming habit of leaping several feet into the air when disturbed. Boat motors disturb them. As a result they leap out of the water in front of speeding boats. Many boaters have been struck by asian carp projectiles as they zoom at high speed on the river. So this analogy that the oh-so-clever author used is about as subtle as getting hit in the face with a ten pound fish traveling at 45 mph..