Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

On "Spirituality"

By CosmicConservative
On my previous post a comment was made about my view of "spirituality" which essentially expressed surprise that I would even bring up "spirituality" since in general I seem not to "believe" in such things. That's unfortunate since my view of spiritual things is, in my perhaps self-centered view, complex and subtle. But first I must approach the whole concept of "belief." This is a very critical thing to understand about me, especially since so many people toss around the idea of "belief" with such casual abandon that it becomes a ubiquitous, inchoate rationale for any philosophy or ideology. Which is unfortunate because I think "belief" is a key attribute of most religions, but not much else. One thing I see and hear a lot from people is that "you have to believe something." For example, if someone challenges a particular religious concept of the creation of the universe, it is not uncommon to hear the retort "well, you BEELLIIEEVVEE in the Big Bang, that's the same thing!" Except it's not. See, here's the problem. In the purest, most intellectually profound, philosophically important sense, I don't "believe" anything. I "accept" certain things as practical reality, but that's not the same thing as "belief." For example, I accept, as a practical reality, that if I step off a roof, I will fall. But I don't "believe" any explanation of why I fall. I don't "believe" in gravity. I accept as a practical reality that I will fall. This is why I don't follow any particular religion. I simply don't "believe" any religious back story. They all sound equally absurd and unrealistic to me. But this is also why I'm not an atheist. I find it just as hard to "believe" that there IS NO GOD as I find it to "believe" that there IS A GOD. There simply isn't sufficient evidence to reach a rationally defensible conclusion on the subject of the existence or non-existence of god. Oh I have IDEAS about God. But they don't match any religion that I have ever encountered. And for most people, my ideas about God would no doubt qualify as heresy or worse. So I don't talk about it much. Now, as a matter of practical use of language, I will frequently use the word "believe" in the colloquial sense, and could well do so in this very post, but I don't apologize for that. It is virtually impossible to communicate with others without relying on colloquialisms. But take my word for it, I don't "believe" anything in any sense of the word which implies that I have any certainty whatsoever about the fundamental nature of the universe. So, getting back to "spirituality"... well, what is "spirituality?" I'm sure there are thousands of mutually incompatible definitions of the word, but I'll go ahead and explain what I mean by the word. It's pretty simple. The universe as we observe it appears to follow certain immutable principles. Among those principles are things like the Laws of Thermodynamics (particularly the second law), and other things like the Theory of Relativity (which describes limits to causality and the direction arrow of time). My view of this can be generalized as the concept that our universe is governed by physical laws that appear to be unbreakable. Now, remember I don't "believe" anything. So I don't "believe" this. However, I am willing to accept as a practical reality that these limits describe reality better than anything else humans have ever used to describe reality. And my experience and review of the history of the world indicates to me that these principles effectively describe pretty much everything that can be objectively verified. As an example, I accept as a practical reality that death is permanent and irreversible. I know there are all kinds of stories from just about every religion on earth about death being reversed. I don't believe them. I know there are millions of stories from people who claim to have encountered "spirits" who were once living humans. I don't believe them. (Besides, I find the whole concept of the spirits of my ancestors "watching over me" infinitely creepy. If spirits are watching me all the time, they are seeing lots of things I don't want them to see, ranging from me picking my nose to me perhaps throwing childish temper tantrums. Such voyeurism is highly objectionable to me on principled grounds.) In spite of this, I don't reject the notion that there is something beyond the expression of universal principles such as thermodynamics. In fact I, like pretty much every human being, desperately HOPE that there is something beyond what we understand about those principles. This is in large part because I don't like what those laws predict about the final disposition of the universe and everything in it. But beyond even that, I have some odd notions about things such as "free will" and "physical continuity". I find it philosophically unappealing to conclude that our universe is completely deterministic, and I find it equally philosophically unappealing to conclude that our universe is driven by some combination of deterministic laws and random quantum effects. Neither of those explanations allows me to explain "free will." I think I've said before on this blog that there is nothing that is as important as the concept of "free will." Nothing. Without free will there is no purpose to the universe, no hope for individual accomplishment and no purpose in valuing the concept of "quality of life." And yet free will is completely outside the ability of our current understanding of the principles of the universe to explain. In fact, our current understanding of the principles of the universe would seem to exclude free will as a concept. Perhaps I should say that although I don't think I "believe" anything, the only thing I MIGHT BELIEVE IN is free will. But that's purely a selfish thing. I want to believe in free will because I can't conceive of a universe with any meaning or purpose in the absence of free will. So, in a nutshell, my concept of spirituality is totally and inextricably intertwined with the concept of free will. So when I talk about how I need to work on my "spiritual side" that can almost always be interpreted as a need to address making better choices and exerting more willpower to make those better choices. My pursuit of understanding "free will" takes me to some pretty weird places too. I wonder sometimes if the "real world" is just some sort of illusion and our "spiritual nature" is expressed through the real world as part of some process to provide growth opportunities, or even testing, of our moral compass. In that sense my concept of "spirituality" wanders into the realm of religion. But it wanders strange, uncommon and potentially untracked paths through that realm. During those moments I can entertain the notion of extra-physical continuities of will, something that might be construed as a "soul". However, when contemplating that possibility, I rarely venture into the brightly lit venues of organized religion, tending towards shadowy realms with treacherous philosophical foundations where anthropomorphic interpretations are almost rejected out of hand, even if that leaves the realm unformed and chaotic. In that sense I am a deeply spiritual person. It's just that most people probably would not recognize my travels in that realm as what they mean by "spirituality." Not sure if this helps or not.

Comments (45)

mtnlurker
Just so I have this straight. So you "believe" that working on your "spirituality" will help your state of mind which will in turn help your physical well being?
CosmicConservative
Mtn... Working on my spirituality will most likely, as a matter of practical reality, lead to making better choices which will help my state of mind and improve my physical well being. Presumably.
CosmicConservative
... but as I said, that's the hardest part. Working on the spiritual side is all about digging deep into my motivations for why I make the choices I make and judging as accurately as I can where my current execution of free will is falling short of my moral and ethical obligations. Here's an example. Am I morally obligated to be happy? I have not been happy in a long, long time. Perhaps never. I dunno. "Happiness" has never been a driving moral imperative for me. Perhaps it should be. Being happy would almost certainly make my life more enjoyable. But beyond that, being happy will almost certainly make the lives of people I care about more enjoyable. Except perhaps if my happiness involves actions which conflict with their happiness. So should my free will be tightly bound to making choices that make me happy?
Drax
Hmmm...nice post. I believe, however, that you have conflated "belief" with "faith." Other than that, a nice, thought-provoking post.
CosmicConservative
OK Drax, if I have, then what is the difference?
Drax
Well, as I understand it, "belief" IS (in this context) accepting something as factual or truthful. "Faith" is the belief in something without any evidence or "acceptance of something as factual or truthful without the necessity of evidence." Thus, one can "believe" in something AND require that there be supporting evidence (you "believe" that you'll plummet to the ground if you step off a roof because you have evidence that this is the certain result). You can ALSO "believe" something to be factual or true WITHOUT any supporting evidence -- which becomes "faith." (Of course you can have "faith" in something WITH supporting evidence...) What I got from your post was that you DO "believe" in that which you have REASON to, but do NOT in that which you have none. (E.g., the existence of "God" (however defined) is something which does not survive critical examination from either direction; therefore, you neither "believe" nor "disbelieve" it - you leave it as an open question.) Anyway, that's what I got from the post.
CosmicConservative
I used it as I intended. I am not convinced that anything in our universe is "factual" or "truthful." As I said in the above, I am open to the interpretation that the universe is an illusion. Which, if you think about it, is pretty much what all religions claim, whether they realize it or not.
Drax
So, you're not convinced that it's a fact that, if you step off a roof, that you'll plummet to the ground? You don't accept as an established fact that you're married and have two children? That they exist? That you exist? That there is an Earth, a universe (or more), or anything at all? I'm sorry, but I find that extremely difficult to swallow. You sure ACT as if you "believe" those to be established facts. But, I guess that, when you lay your (perhaps) non-existent head upon your imaginary pillow and close your eyes and go to sleep (if that's what is actually happening), that you can conceive of the notion that, intellectually (but not practically) you don't actually "believe" that any of that is actually happening...
CosmicConservative
Well, the question is whether we are discussing the universe practically or metaphysically. Practically, of course. Metaphysically. Not so much. And this post was addressing it metaphysically. My experience has been that religious people can treat their religion the same way. "Do you believe God watches your every move?" Metaphysically, of course. Practically, not so much.
Dadman
Best of luck on your spiritual journey. For the record I also believe free will is foundational to human spirituality. However, my faith teaches me (and I accept it) that to attain a greater spiritual state in this life I need to focus my free will on being faithful, hopeful, loving, kind, selfless, patient, humble, etc. Of course, as a seriously flawed human being my ability to focus my free will on these things is a work in progress. I seem to fail more often than I succeed, but in those moments I have succeeded I have experienced the promised rewards firsthand - not just personal rewards, but the rewards/blessings that my good works bring into the lives of others.
CosmicConservative
Dadman (and JSullins): I concur with this, but I also feel that there is much more to explore in this matter of "faithfulness" and that there is very little benefit to be gained from my pursuing it, since my conclusions will almost inevitably be construed as attacks on particular religions or people. I'll just say that of the items Dadman delineated, my own spiritual journeys have provided the same list, with the notable exception of "faithfulness." And just to clarify the point, I don't think this diagnosis has caused me to embark on any new "spiritual journey," but I do think it may get me to stop resting on the rock and looking over the spiritual landscape and get me back on my feet again. Which is probably a good thing.
Dadman
Faith or faithfulness is a very, very tough concept for me as well. My organized church teaches me that walking in faith, or excising free agency in a manner that relies on faith, e.g. tithing a percentage of my income because I am asked to and because certain blessings are promised, is often very difficult. One of the promises associated with paying an honest tithe is that the temporal needs of my family will always be met. I believe, on faith, this is so, but after many, many years of paying tithing myself and observing the lives of others who pay tithing I must say some of my faith has been replaced by compelling anecdotal evidence. Faith applied leads to experience and experience, over time, can approach knowledge. For me at least...
CosmicConservative
Dadman, other people who have expressed their faithfulness every bit as diligently as you have done have not seen the same benefits. Not me, but very close to me. One reason I find the claims of the benefits of faithfulness to be unsupported by personal experience.
Drax
Yeah. The notion that adherence to a religion's teachings (especially any which promise temporal benefits by donating to the church) is reflective of divinely received benefits is one which can only be believed if one cherry picks one's "anecdotal evidence." Sigh.
Dadman
Drax, your utter lack of respect and tact toward other people's experience that differs from your own is appalling. I will now direct my free will toward being more patient with all the jackasses of the world...starting with Drax...
Dadman
Cosmic, I understand what you are saying and it's one of the reasons why doing anything based purely on faith is a very difficult thing. I really struggle with it. As an aside, someone should put a muzzle on that condescending moron, Drax. He invariably makes me regret sharing anything on this blog...
Tom DeGisi
I didn't find Drax's comment at all over the top, Dadman, but I did find your responses to be so. But perhaps that is because I believe the Gospel of Prosperity is both heresy and empirically false. Not that you actually endorsed that doctrine! What you said sounds like that doctrine, and could be interpreted as advancing it. Drax's reply was a good argument against the Gospel of Prosperity. > As an aside, someone should put a muzzle on that condescending moron, Drax. He invariably makes me regret sharing anything on this blog… Sounds like local history to which I am too late. Either that, or a joke I'm not getting. > … don’t make me pull this blog over! This was really good, Cosmic. I got that joke. Yours, Tom
Drax
Dadman, I don't have a problem with your "belief." I'm sure that your belief is a force for good in the world on whatever scale, as it is with many people of good faith. That, however, doesn't mean that I have to give your belief any more credence than you give any OTHER belief. Or, are you of the opinion, that one who believes in Islam is in equal standing with that which you understand to be "God" as is a Mormon? I think not. But, for ANYONE to say "Give to (fill in the blank) church and good things will happen to you" is one thing. To believe that there is a cause and effect between the giving and the getting is quite another. You say that your "anecdotal evidence" convinces you that there is a casual relationship between the giving and the getting. I say that, to believe that such is the case is to deny reality. What of the faithful in the destitute countries of this world? Are they less faithful? Must they give (fill in the blank) percentage of their non-existent income in order to somehow stave off starvation or genocide? I'm sorry, but your "anecdotal evidence" flies in the face of historical evidence, and I can give it no credence. Do you give historical evidence credence, or do you just think that they were not "worthy" in the eyes of God and deserved the rapine, pillage, genocide, starvation in the tens and tens of millions?
CosmicConservative
Sigh... this is why I typically avoid this subject, both here on this blog, and in my personal life... Just too much bad karma....
Dadman
Some on this blog are so eager to debate that they miss the supremely salient fact that I was speaking to my own experiences and observations and how they have over time supported behaviors that are purely a matter of faith. I was not offering my observations as proof of anything. I was not advocating the so-called 'Gospel of Prosperity'. I even agreed with the notion that acting is faith is very, very difficult for me (and impossible for others I suppose). Sometimes it seems some who post on this blog are afflicted with a terminal case of cynicism for which their is no cure. Finally, I will say that I believe Drax enjoys denigrating, challenging, criticizing - pick your action verb - my experiences and perspectives particularly on this topic for reasons that elude me. And yes, Tom, there is a history. That's all I'm going to say on this...except to wish you all a Merry Christmas. Oh, and I do sincerely apologize for directing perjoratives at Drax. It was a poor application of free will on my part...
CosmicConservative
Just one minor point and I'll let this go. This is a blog. One of its primary purposes is to engender and promote discussion and debate. I do my best to deliberately couch my comments on subjects like this in the least confrontational terms. And even so I get accused of cynicism and a desire for bare-knuckle offensive debating. A charge which I find to be completely at odds with my actual behavior, especially when compared to other blogs I read and on which I post. This is by far the tamest, most civilized blog I know of. It really is. And I try to keep it that way. FWIW, I did not think Drax's comments were "over the top" or overtly combative. Certainly he could have danced on the eggshells as I do, but he's got no compelling reason to do so.
Drax
Dadman. You, on this blog, advance your notions of the universe. If you don't want them challenged, don't advance them.
Dadman
Like I said, I invariably regret posting personal experiences on this blog. The trend continues...
CosmicConservative
Dadman, that's simply not true. It's only certain subjects that tend to get all wrapped up like this. Everyone on this blog greatly appreciates your contributions, especially your personal experiences. This is why people avoid discussing religion and politics. You seem to do fine on this blog with politics, pop culture and personal anecdotes. But not religion. I personally find both to be deeply interesting subjects which I can debate for hours. Mostly without fisticuffs even.
CosmicConservative
... and for what it's worth Dadman, you certainly don't shy away from posting things that directly challenge other posters.
Dadman
There's a difference between a thesis statement open to debate and the expression of deeply personal experiences which faith-based experiences invariably are. Ironically, my comfort level with faith or faithfulness is similar to your own, but given I have been active in an 'organized religion' for over 30 years now I thought I would share my personal experiences with a purely faith-based behavior (tithing). In my own experience, and many others I know, tithing has proven to be a temporally positive experience...or that is the perception with virtually everyone I know who pays a tithe. The fact that some who post and comment here can't seem to recognize the distinction between personal experience and thesis bothers me. It seems like an easy, obvious call to me. Ultimately, I do not intend to debate the quality or veracity of my own experiences, but I also am bright enough to avoid presenting them as empirical proof of anything. I get that you and Drax reject the idea that there is any correlation between tithing and temporal blessings. That's not been my experience. Do you really want to debate that?
CosmicConservative
Nobody is debating your personal experience. What Drax is saying is that there is a difference between anecdote and data. You have anecdotal evidence that tithing helps your financial situation. I have anecdotal evidence that it does not help mine. I also have additional anecdotal evidence of others who "religiously" tithe and yet have struggled financially. I have further significant philosophical issues with the whole concept of tithing, but that should be no surprise since I have significant philosophical issues with virtually every edict of every organized religion. That's just me. Until there is some worldwide, multi-denominational scientific study of the effectiveness of tithing, we are left with exactly what Drax says we are left with: Competing anecdotal experiences which can be cherry-picked to "prove" or "disprove" whatever side one wants to pick. Your personal experiences are valid anecdotes to present to support your view. Mine and Drax's personal experiences are equally valid anecdotes to present to challenge your view. Doing so does not in any way challenge the truthfulness of your statement, or of your faith in the value of it. In many, many threads here on this blog I have gotten a strong sense that when you have such strong feelings on a subject, you tend to take any challenge to your position on that subject as a direct personal attack on you, on your sincerity or your truthfulness. I don't know what to do about that. It's simply not the case, and it's frankly somewhat insulting that you continue to accuse me and others of attacking you when we are simply responding to your own statements of life experience with statements of our own life experiences, which are sometimes at odds with your own. I am sincerely glad for you that your life experiences in this, and many other areas, have been so positive and that you trace the source of that to your faith. I can assure you that I know others, some very, very close to me, who have at least the equal of your faith, but whose life experiences have been far less positive in spite of it.
Dadman
My issue is with Drax for reasons both old and new. I think his 'cherry picking' comment was at the very least snarky and snide. 'Cherry picking' implies a certain level of intellectual dishonesty or shallowness, something I assiduously avoid in my life. And the 'sigh' implies impatience with a ridiculous notion. I'll reiterate - I offered my personal experiences only as examples of my own struggles and successes with the application of faith in my life not as evidence of universal truth. You don't need to tell me that others experiences have been different. I know this all too well. In fact, my awareness of this inconsistency is one of the reasons faith-based behavior is so difficult for me. But, I know where my tithe money goes, I know who it is targeted to help, so I'm comfortable paying a tithe in the absence of any empirical evidence that my family will receive any benefit at all from the gesture. The anecdotal correlation is good enough in my small corner of the world...
CosmicConservative
As I said, I dance among the eggshells as much as I can. Drax doesn't. I don't see you dancing among the eggshells much either Dadman. I know that you've made equally condescending and snarky comments, some directed at me, so I can't muster up a whole lot of outrage at Drax even if he did condescend. I do think you have certain subjects that pull out a hyper-sensitivity to criticism, real and perceived. You might notice that on several recent threads Drax and I have gone at each other hammer and tong. So whatever you perceive, I don't believe it was personal on Drax's part. In fact I am quite sure the "yeah" which started his post was directed at MY comment, not yours, and that his comment was as much a reaction to my comment as it was to yours. I have mixed feelings about this whole thing. I set up this blog to talk about things that I wanted to talk about, and I have been avoiding certain issues because of this sort of reaction. But that's not being true to myself or my original intentions for the blog. So I may do more in the future, not less.
Drax
While I don't much dance on eggshells, I do try to avoid personal attacks. I'm not always successful, but, almost always, I only start being an asshole when someone starts calling me names. Dadman: You really need to calm yourself down. This "history" to which you refer is one which is viewed quite differently by me. I remember it as beginning when you decided to assert that Romney was being continuously attacked by Mormon haters and that the Evangelicals were going to ensure that he wouldn't get the nomination because he was a Mormon. I disagreed with that. You, from that point forward, began personal attacks upon me as if I was PERSONALLY ATTACKING YOU AND YOUR RELIGION. Then, again, the "history" heated up when those self-described Mormons were arrested and YOU brought up the subject. I presented my thoughts and, again, you decided that I was personally attacking you and your religion, and you became personally offensive -- as above -- with the name calling. It's childish. It's wearing. I even stopped visiting my brother's blog for months simply to avoid your childish, personal attacks. Here, you have made the ASSERTION that tithing WORKS. You may have attempted to couch it in terms of it working for YOU, but, your ultimate statement was that TITHING WORKS. Give to the church and you have good things happen. That's bunk. Empirical bunk. You may choose to believe that it works, but the MILLIONS for whom it does not "work" bear out its bunkishness. Millions of true believers live their lives in squalor with little hope in this life except the hope of a better existence in the afterlife. Millions upon millions upon millions -- BILLIONS throughout history. But, it works for you. It works for others you have observed. So you believe. Fine. Believe it all you wish. It hurts no one and your tithing almost surely has some beneficial effect on someone somewhere other than the churches which are built, the pastors who are paid, the property which is bought in the name of the church. Some small percentage of your tithe surely helps someone somewhere. There's no harm in that. I have no issue with you or your religion any more than I do any stranger who namecalls me or any organization which claims to have discovered the the nature of God and the Universe. But, if you are so convinced of your beliefs, then you shouldn't have such a damn thin skin about them. That chip on your shoulder must be heavy and you must be weary from carrying it for so long...
Dadman
Hmmmm...interesting rewrite of history. I think the name-calling began around the time Drax called me a bigot. Anyway... I would define what you refer to as 'walking on eggshells' as a basic sensitivity to other people's perspectives and experiences, elements of a polite society that apply most everywhere but the blogosphere it would appear. But, if 'walking on eggshells' is too much of a burden for you two than so be it. I have much better things to do with my time than spend it here in this little blog-bubble. Just remember this, Cosmic. This 'walking on eggshells' you refer to, or accommodation of others, is a two way street - particularly with friends - and I can assure you I've done plenty of it over the years for you. Now, I know you'll likely reject or minimize that notion, but it's the profound truth. I wish you well with your lifestyle changes, truly, and a stunningly successful redirect of personal willpower...
Drax
Dadman, I think you may have your history mixed up. First, I doubt that I directly called you a "bigot." If such assertion was made, however, I supported it with direct quotes or by pointing to your actual words which, in my opinion, were bigoted. (If memory serves, it began in a thread, started by you, accusing ALL "evangelicals" of being bigots towards Mormons because they wouldn't vote for Romney. I quoted you, pointing out that you over-generalized, and were, therefore being just as much of a bigot towards evangelicals as you were accusing them of being bigots towards Mormons, and you flipped out, beginning a long period where you appeared to be trolling my posts to take snide remarks about me, personal attacks on me, at every opportunity.) Then, when directly confronted (as here) you make some snide remark, then don't directly address the substance of what is causing the problem, choosing to indirectly address me to CC or someone else. Now, I'll try to, again, explain. You're ticked off about my "cherry-picking" remark. I stand by it. You say that it is your experience with the success of tithing which informs you. I say that, if this is the case, then you are cherry-picking your experiences. Let's just take your congregation. Of them, how many have declared bankruptcy? How many of them have suffered financial disaster? Do you know? Have you considered them in your "tithing calculus?" How many have lost their children to illness or accident? Lost loved ones early to illness or accident? Do you know? Have you considered them in your "tithing calculus?" How many have had children born with severe disability, mental or physical? How many beset with dementia or other infirmity rendering them incapable of caring for themselves? Do you know? Have you considered them in your "tithing calculus?" The point is that, for every one of your "tithing success" experiences for the faithful, if you considered the hardships which beset others, even in your own congregation - equally "faithful" - equally tithing - then, I find it extraordinarily difficult to believe that, when the "tithing calculus" is performed, you could conclude that tithing creates temporal benefit. Because cause and effect means exactly that. If you do this, then that happens. Every time. Without fail. So, if those members of your congregation who have suffered such hardship (and there is no question but that some have) then, either you must have concluded that there was something which EXCLUDED them from your "tithing calculus," and, therefore, you could conclude that "tithing creates benefit," OR you were "cherry-picking" your own experiences and not including them in that calculus even though there is nothing which EXCLUDES them from such. In either case, it renders your assertion to be without any merit, i.e., "bunk." But, again. If you choose to believe such, I have no issue with it, any more than I do with your religion. However, when you come to a public blog, and make positive assertions as to the objective effectiveness of your internal beliefs, i.e., that your religious beliefs and practices (and therefore your "God" actually affect the human experience and YOU'VE SEEN IT), you're going to get some push-back.
CosmicConservative
Drax, Dadman has apparently left the building, so you can stop with the beat-down. Dadman, in case you read this, I hope that you don't abandon this blog. Your participation is appreciated. But I have to agree with Drax, on this subject your reactions demonstrate to me a hyper-sensitivity that is off the charts. And if you have been "walking on eggshells" around me, it's OK with me if you stop. Really. I don't mind.
Dadman
It's all about the beat-down with you two, even if the truth suffers. I'm sick of it...
CosmicConservative
I fail to see how the "truth" has suffered here, or in other cases of "the beatdown." And you've dished out your share of beatdown yourself. And in general, as in this case, your beatdown tends to be more personal and demonstrates more obvious anger and venom. That's the truth, from my perspective. I'm sure you don't see it that way though.
Dadman
Drax's recitation of our past interactions is PURE fantasy. If you can't see or acknowledge that, well, that tells me a lot...
CosmicConservative
It is not "pure fantasy." It is not "objective truth." It is Drax's interpretation of events. Just as you have yours and I have mine. Mine is somewhere in between yours and Drax's. I think Drax's general disdain and possible contempt for certain positions on certain issues is plain to see. He doesn't attempt to disguise them. I think you react more to that disdain and possible contempt than you do to his actual points. But he makes good points, even when he does phrase them indelicately. And when these things flare up, my opinion is that your reaction is aggressive, which engenders a more aggressive reaction from Drax. And your tendency is to then address the tone instead of the substance of Drax's points, which just frustrates Drax more and convinces him that he must be right since you aren't addressing the substance. And that makes Drax post more smugly and more condescendingly which, understandably, inflames you even more. Usually I'm in the middle trying to calm both of you down. That's my view. I think you both contribute to the situation. In this case I think you went to DefCon 5 immediately.
Dadman
Yes, I did and my apology for that was completely ignored...not surprisingly. I am leaving the building now...
CosmicConservative
Dadman, here is your apology:
Some on this blog are so eager to debate that they miss the supremely salient fact that I was speaking to my own experiences and observations and how they have over time supported behaviors that are purely a matter of faith. I was not offering my observations as proof of anything. I was not advocating the so-called ‘Gospel of Prosperity’. I even agreed with the notion that acting is faith is very, very difficult for me (and impossible for others I suppose). Sometimes it seems some who post on this blog are afflicted with a terminal case of cynicism for which their is no cure. Finally, I will say that I believe Drax enjoys denigrating, challenging, criticizing – pick your action verb – my experiences and perspectives particularly on this topic for reasons that elude me. And yes, Tom, there is a history. That’s all I’m going to say on this…except to wish you all a Merry Christmas. Oh, and I do sincerely apologize for directing perjoratives at Drax. It was a poor application of free will on my part…
So out of the five paragraphs of your apology, three paragraphs were direct attacks on me and Drax. Then you say you were sorry for directing pejoratives. Are you really surprised that the apology was "overlooked" among the escalation of your low opinion of us?
Dadman
Now I'm really amused... Man, I really hate this, but let's take a brief moment and look at what I said: I offered my honest, very personal experience with a faith-based behavior. I didn't offer my experience as evidence of anything, just that it's been a positive experience for me and my family, and many others I know. The beatdown ensued. I got angry and called your brother, Drax, a 'jackass' and a 'moron'. I regret doing that and I apologized for it. Now, I'm informed my apology is somehow not sufficent for the Golden brothers. Why? Well, because I said some on this blog love the debate and the prospect of a beatdown so much that they missed the fact I was only saying tithing has 'worked' for me and many I know. That's why I and others keep doing it even in the absence of empirical evidence, or in the face of contrary evidence. It's purely a matter (and a difficult matter for my part) of faith (my original seemingly innocent point). Then I accused Drax of being cyncial. I really wasn't thinking of you when I wrote that, but I suppose it applies. Are you suggesting the both of you aren't cynical? I know you've told me you are on countless occasions. Cynicism can be a good thing. I know it works for me quite often. I then suggested that Drax enjoys challenging, criticizing, and sometimes even snarkily denigrating opinions and perspectives he does not agree with, particularly views I've voiced here on faith-related matters. Untrue? I then had the temerity to wish you a Merry Christmas and offer what I thought was a sincere apology. Sorry about that. My gall runneth over I'm afraid. I guess I got the order all wrong...
CosmicConservative
I'm pretty sure that if I tendered you an apology after spending three paragraphs explaining why you are unworthy of one, you'd probably react the same way Dadman. I say again, you have your interpretation of events, Drax has his, and I have mine. All of us, no doubt, are equally convinced that theirs is accurate. The real truth is probably different than all three of our personal version of events. Merry Christmas to you too, and to your family. I hope you continue to read and comment. You bring a valuable and much appreciated voice to the conversation here, and I would hate to lose it. I appreciate your attempt to provide me with the benefit of your experience as it pertains to faith. I hope you understand why I remain skeptical and cynical about such things.
Dadman
Whether or not you or Drax is worthy of an apology is not relevant. I was wrong to call Drax the names I did regardless of how angry I may have been. BTW, cynicism and skepticism don't bother me. It's pure condescension that does and Drax is very good at it. Please notice how I responded to your response to my original post relative to how I responded to Drax. Your tone was respectful; Drax's was not (imho). I've told you before that I come to this blog with the expectations of a friend sitting around a table. In my (real) world, personal experiences are not criticized with derision and condescension. If I did it in my job around a lunch table I'd be fired. I understand you view the purpose of your blog as a vehicle for debate and discussion, which I grok, as long as I'm not debating the veracity of my own personal experiences. That's just rude in my book. If the standard rules of polite society don't apply here I have many other places I could spend my time. The irony is I was trying to empathize with you with respect to how difficult faith-based behaviors can be. They are for me (as I said) and I fully understand why they are for you, and others...
CosmicConservative
Well, you are always welcome here. I'm going to try to lock this thread now.