Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Movie Review: "Voyage of the Dawn Treader"

By CosmicConservative
It's been a long, long time since I read the Narnia books. I enjoyed them, but not as much as I enjoyed, say, "The Hardy Boys" which I read at about the same time. I know they are "beloved" books in the Christian literary community, but the truth is that even at the height of their popularity they never really hit the mainstream. Of the people I know who read any of them, they basically just read "The Lion, The Witch and the Wardrobe". "Prince Caspian" was a box office disappointment, and Disney dumped the franchise. I thought that would be the end of it, but Fox decided to pick it up and try to show that "Prince Caspian" was mostly a victim of timing, obviously betting on a Christmas season release as a way to restore the franchise. Early returns are not real promising for "VotDT", in part no doubt based on some snarky reviews. But perhaps word of mouth will save the movie and the franchise will continue. Right now I wouldn't bet on it though. There wasn't anything "wrong" with this movie. I disagree with much of the negative commentary I read in reviews. The special effects are fine, certainly as good as most modern fantasy movies. The acting isn't inspired, but it's not "dull" either and there were certainly some good moments in the film. I thought the character of Eustace was well acted, but it was a deliberately annoying character so I'm not sure that's a good thing... All of the Narnia stories suffer from Lewis's heavy-handed moralizing, and this one is no different, but for many people that's a feature, not a bug. VotDT has more action than either of the previous Narnia movies, but lacks the epic sweep of TLTWaTW and the tense sibling rivalry of PC. The attempt to play up rivalry between Edmund and Caspian is one of the more jarring moments in the movie and comes off as a bit forced. Perhaps the biggest reason the movie may suffer is that it lacks any real identifiable antagonist. It never puts a face on evil, leaving a sort of a hole in the traditional story arc. That lack of a clear target for the protagonists to challenge makes the movie feel a bit adrift at times, and hampers the sort of deep satisfaction a movie-goer typically gets when the "bad guy" finally gets his just desserts. But that's how the book was, and if they had done it differently, they'd have been castigated for changing the story too much. But overall it's an engaging movie with plenty of action and some nice scenes involving the mostly annoying Eustace. As an afternoon diversion for kids and adults during the holiday kerfuffle, it's certainly worth the time and money. Cosmic says check it out.

Comments (0)

No comments on this post.