Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

WoW 4.0.1 release notes

By CosmicConservative
I won't call this a "review" because I've only played my rogue since the release came out Tuesday, I haven't even logged onto my paladin, or my even rarer characters, the druid and the mage. I've been playing World of Warcraft for a little over two years I think. In that time there has been one MAJOR release (Wrath of the Lich King, which upped the level limit from 70 to 80) and several minor releases, some of which introduced new content, and some of which introduced new items or abilities. This Tuesday Blizzard released the "4.0.1" version of WoW. Of course we have highly motivated WoW players in our guild, and our guild website is pretty active, so I knew that there were some pretty big changes coming. I had read up on all the conversions of the old loot types into a greatly reduced number of loot types, and I knew that there was going to be some changes to the talent trees. But I frankly was not remotely prepared for what they did to my rogue. In fact the main reason I have not played my paladin is because I've been spending too much time trying to figure out how to rework my rogue to have something remotely comparable to my old damage per second. Before Tuesday the talent tree was, I think 71 talents. You could split them up any way you liked between one of three trees for each character. For rogues that meant you could choose talents from the "assassination", "subtlety" and "combat" trees. They are called "trees" because the talents have dependencies which means you can't choose some talents until you pick other talents, and you have to pick a certain number of lower level talents in one tree before you can pick higher level talents from that tree. Talents offer bonuses to existing abilities or entirely new abilities that are only possible if you choose that talent. Most of the trees include some super powerful ability that is at the very top of the tree which forces you to invest lots of talent points into lower level talents just to get that super powerful one. Most players picked one tree to focus on and dabble a bit in the other trees for specific needs. But you COULD build a character with more or less equal investment in all three trees. That's all gone. Now they have cut the number of talent points in half to 36 and you have to pick one tree as your main tree and spend all but a few of your talent points in that tree before it "unlocks" the other trees. Why Blizzard felt it was necessary to force all characters to be specialists is a mystery to me. Of course if you are a raider, you'll specialize in a raid tree. If you are a PvPer you'll specialize in a PvP tree. If you choose to be a jack of all trades you gain lots of flexibility, but at the expense of excelling in one thing. Now you don't have a choice, you have to pick one thing to excel at and throw a few remaining points at a couple of talents from the other trees. But that's not terribly bad for me since I am a raider. My main spec and off spec have always been raiding specs, so it's a little irritating that I am forced to fill in one tree before the other trees unlock, but I would likely have wound up with something similar anyway. It's just the lack of an option to generalize that irks me. What if I LIKED being a jack of all trades? What if I LIKED being an average DPS raider who could throw in some unusual talents for specialized situations? (For example, only one rogue tree used to have any significant multi-attack capability, and that is not on the main raid tree, but is sometimes very useful in a raid when you are fighting several mid-level monsters instead of a single boss.) But I figured, "oh well" and just redid my talents, wondering how the end result would work out after trying to figure out entirely new talents for my rogue. Well, so I raided Wed. and Thu. night. Ug. In most raids for the last several months my rogue has been one of the top DPSers in the guild. There is one other rogue who usually outdoes me, but in most boss fights the three rogues in the guild were usually 1,2 and 3 in damage. Which is as it should be, since rogues are by far the most fragile melee character and as such SHOULD do more damage since they are taking much higher risks than, for example, a paladin who wears plate armor, or a hunter who roams around the edge of the fight plinking their arrows at the enemy. So our first big boss fight, and I was number 11 in damage. Surely some sort of fluke. In fact I did mess up and forget to trigger one of my new talents that provides a boost in haste. Aha! So the next big boss fight I remembered to trigger that talent.... and I moved up to #7. #7. This is just insulting. Well, in the course of two days we cleared out all but the final two bosses in Ice Crown Citadel. Usually we make much better progress than that, but many guild members were having problems re-learning their characters, and so we wiped probably about twice as often as we normally would. By the end of day 2 though we were all doing pretty well. But I never got higher than #6 in damage for a boss fight. This is an ego-crushing thing for me. To put some raw numbers on it, pre-4.0.1 on a typical boss fight, I would easily top 10,000 DPS. So would our other two rogues. In fact we had gotten to where we were typically in the upper 11,000 to mid 12,000 range, depending on how much the fight required the melee to run around in the fight. In straight standup fights where you could just slug it out and optimize your attack rotation, two of us were topping 13,000 DPS with regularity, and the third was topping 13,000 on occasion. Those are the fights I excel at, so I was routinely the top DPSer on those fights and all three top slots were pretty much always rogues. Now I only topped 10,000 on one fight. And that was one where you gain a damage buff during the fight. Most fights I was at 7,000 - 8,000 DPS. That means my average DPS dropped from the mid 11,000s to around 8,000. That's a drop of 3,000 DPS (to put it into perspective, there are quite a few raiders who find it hard to top 3,000 DPS on their own, so that's like losing an entire raid member's worth of DPS). Now, our most highly equipped rogue did manage to get into the 10,000 DPS range in a couple of fights, and was consistently doing about 1,500 DPS more than my rogue, so I have some hope of regaining some of my DPS leetness, but even so other classes were doing far more damage than us rogues. Warlocks, in particular, seem to have been buffed to an insane level. My DPS may have dropped by 3,000, but warlocks were reporting gains in DPS in the 5,000 DPS to 7,000 DPS range. They went from being one of the least effective raid DPSers to becoming the unquestioned champs of DPS. And this is doubly irritating since warlocks also have some of the best multiple attack options, meaning that they were leading DPS in EVERY fight, no matter what type of fight it was. Blizzard has some rogue-haters on their game design team is all I can figure. Every time they have messed around with fundamental build options, rogues absolutely suck for months afterward. Finally the withering barrage of complaints pointing out that rogues are uniquely vulnerable and must be played with a high degree of training and skill and as such SHOULD be the highest DPS class in the game, finally that argument seems to remind the game designers of simple common sense and rogues regain their role as the pinnacle of melee single-target DPS. But in the meantime rogues are virtually banned from raiding in pickup groups because if a rogue can't lead the damage, then a raid leader is taking a huge risk with very little reward when they choose to add a rogue to the raid. So rogues are back to being the last kid selected for the game, and if there are enough other classes looking to raid, rogues will be left out again. So yeah, I'm a little ticked off. It would have been one thing if they had nerfed rogues a bit to bring them back to the pack a little, but instead they beat the rogue black and blue with the nerf bat. I will say that I like what they did with the types of loot quite a bit. I had grown tired of all the different levels of emblems and marks and other means of keeping score. Now it's simple and tidy. They also reworked the "glyph" mechanic pretty significantly, but I haven't really looked into that in enough detail to know if I like it or not. All I know right now is that my rogue has three "prime" glyph slots, but I have only been able to find two prime glyphs that give her any benefit at all, so the third slot is basically worthless. I assume that there is some new glyph that is rare and hasn't yet made its way to the auction house or something. But that's still irritating for now. It is possible that my talent build is not optimal. I will be chatting with our rogue leader in the guild this weekend to see how his build was put together. Raiding or PvP players typically go to one of the WoW character forums (like "elitist jerks") to see what the "experts" are saying to use as a talent build. I'm stubborn and always do my own talent builds instead of following an "optimized" template. However, with such a dramatic decline in DPS effectiveness, I may just have to go sneak a peek at the new top talent builds to see if I've done something really stupid. One thing about the release is that it seems more unstable than usual. I've had several really unpleasant things happen to my character since the release, including having the game tell me I had been kicked out of the guild when I had not. I've also had many glitches where using a weapon ability triggers summoning my mount and other weirdness. It seems to have trouble placing characters into raid groups and we've had half the guild raid party on occasion wandering different instances of the same raid instead of being in the same instance. I am confident that Blizzard will quickly fix all those bugs. But for a limited minor release like this to have that many bugs doesn't bode well for the upcoming "Cataclysm" release. Hopefully by then rogues will be back firmly ensconced at the top of the DPS meters where they belong... So my take right now is that

Comments (13)

Boyd
Interesting perspective, Cosmic. I disagree with much of the non-Rogue parts of it. Or at least, understand some things differently. First and foremost for your Rogue, Blizzard has acknowledged that this build has punished melee classes, and they've said they're going to fix it. So you're justified in your frustration, but just be glad that Blizzard knows they screwed up. Second, this was not "a limited minor release" by any means. By definition, it was a major release, from 3.whateveritwas to 4.01. There were some major changes in the game infrastructure with this release, and in a programming sense, this release is much more vast than the actual expansion pack will be. That will have the cosmetic changes that will make the world look completely different (especially when you're flying over stuff you never could before, apart from a fleeting glimpse while you took a ride from one flight point to another), but 4.01 was the major overhaul. In fact, there are even more changes in this release than we've seen on the live realms that will be enabled later. Then again, I've been playing the Beta since May, so I've gotten used to having things go wonky in a major way, I suppose. But that's another reason why they put this release out two months before the actual expansion pack, so they can fix the things that several million people can find that remain hidden to the thousands of folks in the beta.
CosmicConservative
Boyd, I do understand your points above, but I was using "MAJOR" release more or less as defined as one that introduces large new content areas and raises the level limit. I do realize that this 4.0.1 release is more of a "MAJOR" release from a software engineering perspective. But I think most players view "MAJOR" releases the way I used it above. You are probably right though that this will actually make the Cataclysm release more stable since they have most of the software changes already introduced. In fact I'd say that's probably a bit of brilliant marketing on their part if it works out since Wrath of the Lich King had several major problems when it was released. I do seriously and honestly believe that there is a significant component of the Blizzard design team that hates rogues. Since I began playing WoW every single time there has been a significant change to the classes, rogues have been slammed the hardest. Then when the changes are supposedly "fixed" with subsequent patches, rogues typically get half a page of "fixes" while death knights and paladins get page after page of attention. It usually takes months and months before the rogue is a viable character again. There was a time after WOTLK came out that people were openly ridiculing rogues on the chat channels when they were looking for raid groups. Most raid invitations explicitly said "no rogues." I simply can't come up with any rational explanation for this repeated nerfing of rogues other than that there is a serious dislike of rogues within the design team itself.
JSullins
I hate rogues. Nerf rogues. They should put a trap mechanism into the game. This would both slow down some of the kids who run through instances and annoy the hell out of codgers like me, and also give rogues somewhere to direct all that angst. Rogues should steal stuff and disarm traps. Stay in the shadows where they belong. :D
CosmicConservative
LOL. You are not alone in your hatred of rogues. Rogues are undoubtedly the single most despised class in the game. My guess is that is based on several things, more or less in order of importance:
  1. Rogues are gank-masters, and nobody (not even another rogue) likes getting ganked out of the blue.
  2. Rogues have many unique and useful abailities that are not merely useful, but are quite fun to use, some of them allow rogues to routinely avoid annoyances that other characters are unable to avoid.
  3. Poorly played rogues require huge tank and healer intervention to keep alive. Dead rogues threaten the entire raid or dungeon party. The only class that seems to cause as much grief for raiders is probably hunters. It is only worthwhile to raid with a rogue if they do massive damage and can manage their threat. This require a level of skill that is not always available.
  4. Rogues deal massive damage and played well, rarely take damage themselves. A skilled stun-locking rogue can humiliate a PvP opponent, and can frustrate even a raid team member in their ability to go 1 on 1 on elite trash mobs.
  5. Rogues require almost no pre_raid prep and don't have to wait to recharge mana even after a huge and difficult fight. Rogues are always jumping around impatiently waiting for the mana dependent group members to mana up. They can be annoying little energizer bunnies while other classes have to laboriously regain mana.
  6. Rogues are pure DPS, no matter what talents or gear they have. You can't ask a rogue if they have a "heal" or "off-tank" spec. This reduces the overall flexibility of the party.
In other words, rogues are hated precisely because they are the awesome, and everyone knows it.
JSullins
But they aren't the awesome. Healers are the awesome! ....just watch me heal the hell outta that guy! YEAH!
CosmicConservative
Having now done DPS with two classes, and tanking with one, I feel pretty confident in saying that rogues are far more difficult to play than other DPS classes, and that tanking is almost entirely an equipment and buff thing. The paladin tanking rotation is quite literally a rotation between 3 or 4 cooldowns with a taunt thrown in every now and then if someone (probably a rogue) grabs aggro. If your gear is inadequate or your buffs are not set, no amount of skill will help, and if your gear is adequate and your buffs are set, you have to really suck to screw up tanking. I have not healed a raid or dungeon yet. Healing appears to be, as you have called it, a "whack-a-mole" endeavor where you have to constantly scan and react to party members' health bars. From what I've seen of tank GUI mods, I have sort of assumed that healing requires the right mod to be effective. Even so, I can't imagine that healing is easier than tanking. Is it as difficult as playing a rogue? I dunno. Is it as much fun? Probably not for me. To survive a typical boss fight as a rogue, and do maximum damage without pulling aggro, means you have to manage all of the below tasks simultaneously:
  1. Monitor aggro. Since a single crit on a 5 point finishing move can do as much as 20K damage, it is not uncommon for that single attack to bump me from #6 on threat to #2 (or even #1). Many bosses have secondary attacks that target the #2 or #3 threat target, so if I get to #2, I usually start taking damage. To avoid or fix this I have to interrupt my rotation and use "feint" or some other technique (like "tricks of the trade" to bleed off threat, or if I am in really dire straits, "vanish" to dump all threat). Of course all of those things significantly reduce my damage output, so the only way to maximise damage is to be right on the knife-edge of threat for the whole freaking fight (some of which last for 10 or 15 minutes straight). This is by far the most stressful part of raiding for me.
  2. I have to stay behind the boss at all times to avoid higher parry and dodge rates as well as avoiding any cleave or other frontal area of effect damage. On many bosses which do constant cleave damage, if I am in front of the boss for even one second, that's more than enough to kill my skinny, leather-clad ass. This require constant repositioning in most fights, and any dragon has a tail-swipe attack that can be just as deadly, meaning I end up having a small area of safe attack that might be an area just behind the hip or just off the left leg. That means constant running around as the tank repositions the boss, or the boss jumps from target to target.
  3. I have to constantly monitor my power points to avoid wasting time or damage. Since several talents and magic items grant bonus power points randomly, I can't just find a steady rotation and stick to it. To attain max damage, every time I have enough action points I have to trigger a finishing move. Since I am a mutilate rogue that also means I have to monitor my poison stacks since damage is proportional to both poison and power points. On occasion I will have 5 (the max) power points but ZERO poison stacks, which means using my primary finishing move ("envenom") actually won't even work, so I have to use an alternate finishing move (usually "eviscerate") which scales damage only on power points and ignores poison.
  4. Rogues have (had actually, some of this changed with last Tuesday's release) two major damage increasing abilities which are triggered and refreshed on different timers and with different effects. "Hunger for blood" gives a 30% damage boost, so if that fades away or isn't triggered, you may as well just log off. "Slice and Dice" gives a boost in haste with similar impact. It is largely these two abilities that keep rogues at the top of the damage table. They simply cannot be allowed to expire, and if something makes it impossible to keep them refreshed (such as being stunned, having to run out of melee due to an effect that kills your neighbors, or the boss becoming temporariily invulnerable, etc) it becomes imperative to retrigger them as soon as possible.
  5. Melee is a very dangerous place. Beyond the "cleave" and "tail swipe" attacks which are very common, virtually every boss fight has a number of spells or effects which are dropped right on top of the melee classes. Since virtually all damage is reduced by armor, and rogues are the ONLY non-plate armor melee class, rogues typically have just a second or two at most to react to these effects. To put this in perspective, in the Sindragosa fight our paladins and warriors simply ignore a melee effect that forces our rogues to run for their lives.
There's more to deal with, such as timing any enhancement cooldowns so that you maximize the impact, but all classes have to deal with that sort of thing. But I honestly don't think any class has nearly as much to deal with in a typical boss fight. At the end of the Lich King fight I was sweating and nearly exhausted just from the stress of all the simultaneous tasks require to not wipe the entire raid. That's why, when you do it right, it feels like a real accomplishment.
Marv
Rogues were indeed fked up, but they were not dps kings pre 4.01, what about warriors and dk's pulling 18k to 20k dps? And this patch is really weird for lots of ppl but just hang on, they will eventually fix things with catalcysm and rogues will be fine again, just roll your pally while it comes.
CosmicConservative
Well, all I have to go by are the PUGs and guild raids I was in. In pretty much every single one of them rogues were the lead DPS in any fight that allowed rogues to stay on target for the majority of the fight. On occasion a hunter might keep up or surpass a rogue, but that usually required multiple targets and volley. I never saw anyone in any straight up fight without major buffing (like the spores in rotgut) getting over 14K. Never. Not rogue, not DK, not warrior, not hunter... But since the 4.0.1 release even our least effective warlocks are topping 15K with ease...
CosmicConservative
OK, so I learned something today. I don't know if it will help, but one of the other rogues in the guild told me to exchange critical hit bonuses for mastery bonuses on all of my gear. That's supposed to give bonuses to all poison damage. I did all that and my straight up target dummy damage was well over 7K, which means in a raid with all raid buffs it should be well over 10K. I'll have to check it out to see if it makes any difference. I also had neglected a particular talent because a mutilate build previously did not benefit from the ability (rupture) but now mutilate rogues apparently need that too, so I had to re-spec slightly. Plus I had to change a couple of glyphs around to try to optimize things. Perhaps I'll get back up to the top five at least. Dunno how anyone is going to top warlocks at the moment. Warlocks are just pouring out damage like water.
undone
if u think warlock got buffed up u should check out the mages some in guild r literally topping 30k! dps and yes rogue's dps went wayyyy down but then again they really werent all that great in ice crown hard modes at least not as much as warr, dk wit shadowmourne or mages
undone
p.s as a druid healer i dont mind rogues but as a priest healer i personally hate to see too many rogues or enh shammy in the raid since they have little utility to survive when things go south that the healer literally needs inhuman reflex to heal them through. not to mention about 25% haste or over
CosmicConservative
undone... I've done a lot of raiding as a rogue. Our guild usually has two or three rogues in every 25 man raid. In general the rogues aren't any more likely to die than other classes, and in fact we frequently are the only ones who survive the raid "going south." There's a couple reasons for that. One is that all three of us are hyper-sensitive to our threat, so we rarely are at #2 or #3 threat for long. We tend to stay around #5 or #6 on the threat meters. We use feint a lot for that, and we also use vanish in most fights at least once to gain the temporary haste boost, but it also sheds threat. So when things go south, unless we just happened to crit on a major finishing move, it's usually a hunter or some other class that is next in threat when the tank bites it. If our vanish cooldown is refreshed, we can vanish and sneak away from the fight when it's a totally lost cause. If it's not a lost cause and we just need to deal with a down tank while another tank is taunting so that the raid can continue, we can use evasion and actually rogue-tank for 8 - 10 seconds, which is frequently long enough for the second tank to grab aggro. If it's a multiple threat situation where the raid is going south due to too many mobs, we can usually stun the biggest hitters long enough for the tank and healers to recoup. Not always, of course, but frequently. Now, with the latest changes in 4.0.1, we can also use "fan of knives" to hit multiple mobs with a 70% slowdown effect, which can also give the party a chance to regroup.