Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Randy Moss traded to Vikings...

By CosmicConservative
Receiver Randy Moss and New England Patriots quarterbacks coach Bill O'Brien were involved in a heated exchange at halftime of the team's victory Monday over the Miami Dolphins, according to player sources. The locker-room exchange, described as an "outburst" by one player, came two days before the Patriots traded Moss to the Minnesota Vikings for a 2011 third-round draft choice, and could have contributed to the team's decision to make the deal. via Sources: Randy Moss, New England Patriots quarterbacks coach in heated exchange Monday - ESPN Boston.
Perhaps it's just a coincidence that Terrell Owens' 220 yard day put him ahead of Tim Brown into third place all-time on the same weekend Moss didn't catch a pass, and Randy Moss blew up at the QB coach at halftime. Perhaps it's just a coincidence that Randy Moss was then traded two days later for a third round draft choice... Perhaps...

Comments (15)

Drax
Make waves in New England and they get rid of you. Moss has made no secret of the fact that he is dissatisfied with his lack of a contract. It has to be unsettling to be a 33 year old wide receiver with no job security. Minnesota has been signaling that they were willing to give draft picks for Moss for a while. Minnesota needs a wide receiver (or two) and Favre has been salivating after Moss since his trade from Oakland. He'll play on Monday. I think that it will be an amazing confirmation of my adage that football is a team sport. Moss is EXACTLY the kind of wide receiver that someone like Favre needs and wants -- one that can and will PROTECT him when he attempts to "throw Moss open." There are simply some throws that only Favre and other elite QB's can make which require an elite receiver to catch. Could be epic.
CosmicConservative
I agree that Favre has been salivating for Moss. A local sports reporter here essentially suggested on the air that sports fans should take any odds on a Vegas bet that Moss will catch a TD pass from Favre on Monday. No doubt an in-his-prime Favre throwing to an in-his-prime Moss would be epic. And I am sure the two of them will have their moments. Perhaps the addition of Moss will result in two more wins for Minnesota this year. That might even be enough to get them to the playoffs. Or it might be just enough to get them to 8 wins. We'll see. I suspect Favre-Moss will produce just enough highlights to keep the Favre fantasy alive one more year, and bury the Vikings chances to move on and build a new team for the same duration.
Drax
Gee "in his prime" (last year) Favre was 33-7. "In his prime" (last year)83 receptions, 1200+ yards, and 13 TD's. Yeah...longing for those "olden days..."
CosmicConservative
"Last year." This years Minnesota is (barely) 1 - 3, and Favre is looking like a 42 year old. Moss probably hasn't lost more than a step, but his attitude has sucked. I suppose he may become revitalized with Favre, but if Minnesota had real plans for the future, they would use Moss the way the Patriots were, as a tool to get more balls thrown to their young receivers. But they won't. They'll let Favre and Moss relive their glory days in the hopes of squeezing back into the playoffs so Favre can throw yet another season-ending interception and postpone Minnesota's development of a long-term QB solution one more year. That's pretty much what I said last year, and apart fom Favre's (too?) remarkable regular season rejuvenation, that's essentially exactly what happened. I guess you could argue that the fans got their money's worth last year since Minnesota did win a playoff game, but supposedly all they care about is a Super Bowl, and I believe they are further away this year than they were last year. Is Moss enough to get them to the Super Bowl? I don't think so. But I could be wrong.
Drax
Just a couple of things. 1) Minnesota isn't thinking about "the future." Minnesota is trying to win "now." The future will come regardless. 2) Favre has the same problem he had last year, i.e., an offensive line which allows him to get hit too frequently -- without the outlet of his two receivers of last year (i.e., "no one of any significance to throw it to") -- and with a more plodding game plan which, unlike last year, he can't check off to a different -- throwing -- play because he doesn't have anyone to throw it to. 3) Moss has made every QB he has played with a frapping superstar. (Except in Oakland...) He made Daunte Culpepper into what looked to be a future HOFer -- still marking places in the record books while he sells shoes or something every since he lost Moss. I can't remember the QB's name who threw like 8 td's in two games after (fillintheblank QB got hurt in Minnesota) but, he looked like -- well, Culpepper -- or Cunningham, who Moss made look like well, Culpepper even though Cunningham was as old as...Favre... He turned Brady (a consistent 25 TD a year QB into Dan Marino.) Sheesh. Moss can still out-run, out-jump any DB, corner or safety in the game -- and he fights for every ball. It will either be Epic (along the lines of what happened in NE before the Patriots decided not to give him a contract) or an Epic Fail. Either way, Favre is going out with a bang, heh.
CosmicConservative
I sorta wanna root for Favre, but I've rooted against him for so long that it's pretty much a habit now. I know he's a HOF first balloter but I can't help but think of him as a prima donna choke-in-the-big-game QB. I compare him to Troy Aikman and can't help but come away thinking I would take Troy (or, say, Aaron Rodgers) any day of the week (especially Sunday) over Favre. Give me steady, solid, dependable accuracy and game management any day over hyper-emotional gunslinging showmanship. There's a reason Favre has had so many seasons end with a freakishly absurd interception while Aikman (and Montana) just quietly and competently won championships. Troy (and Montana and Peyton and even Brady) WON a lot of games for their team, as has Favre, but those guys almost never LOST a game, especially a big game, for their teams, and Favre has made a career out of winning and losing games with his arm alone. Just never have been a big Favre fan, and I do think Minnesota has made a major mistake in partnering with Favre's desperate desire to be the next John Elway and retire in style after a statistically stellar career with very mixed playoff success.
esox67
I was very surprised the Patriots gave Moss away. The queens better throw a contract at him, or I doubt his attitude will improve. As I saw the Packers defense in action against the Lions last week, I did not think they needed to add him to beat the Packers, heck the Packers could not stop the Lions who can they stop. The queens need Moss to have a great game against Revis island this week, they really cannot afford to drop to 1-3. That is a big hole to climb out of with who they have left to play. ( packers notwithstanding )
Yup
Moss has the ability to save Favre's disaster year since Moss has the ability to make a long shot into a touchdown. But of course, Favre's no Brady so I wouldn't expect anymore than 10 touchdowns this year for him. Hell He may even save Favre from himself - although that's a long shot. In the end though - Minni will have spent over 20 million dollars to not make the playoffs. Their best chance is to shoot for wildcard.
Drax
I always love the notion that such QB's as Aikman and Montana were "competent" while Favre is a "gunslinger." Gee. Having Smith to force a team to defend against the run every play, an offensive line which protected Aikman while plowing holes for Smith, and a HOF receiver -- might have had SOMETHING to do with Aikman's ability to "competently manage a game." Gee. Having the first 1000/1000 running back, the best receiver to ever play the game, a solid offensive line, an insanely good defense (with 1 or 2 HOF'ers depending on the year) might have had SOMETHING to do with Montana's ability to "competently manage the game." Gee. Having two excellent wide receivers and a potential HOFer running the ball and a more than solid defense (even though cursed with a below-average offensive line) might have had SOMETHING to do with Favre's 33-7 season, i.e., his ability to "competently manage the game" and the lack of same which contributes to his "gunslinger" mentality. We'll see. With a great running back and a HOF wide receiver that has to be double-teamed every play, it's entirely possible that Favre might have a record year even with 3 bad games under his helmet. (And Moss was granted concessions - no franchise tag, for example, in the trade, so he's going to be a happy camper with great incentive to play well this season -- if he wants a big contract next season.)
CosmicConservative
Drax, this almost sounds as if you are arguing that quarterbacks are simply interchangeable widgets that do nothing but react to their circumstances. As if Aikman would suddenly start chunking the ball downfield into triple coverage if Smith had the flu or something. Or Montana would start throwing across his body while running to the right because Rice pulled a groin the week before. I don't buy it. Yes, it's a team game, but the team is made up of individuals and those individuals have tendencies and habits that make up their contribution to that team. I am not remotely the first person to point out that Favre has a notable and obvious tendency to throw the ball into highly questionable coverage situations. I am not the first person to point out that Favre has too much confidence in his ability to throw the ball through defenders. I'm not the first person to point out that Favre seems to abandon the running game at times when the running game is not demonstrably ineffective. Quarterbacks have tendencies and habits. I believe that Favre's tendencies and habits are highly questionable from a risk/benefit analysis. Aikman, Montana, Brady, Peyton Manning and many others I could name have highly beneficial risk/benefit tendencies and habits. Sometimes Favre's risk-it-all gambler style pays off. It won him one Super Bowl. Sometimes it craps out. It is my opinion as a sports fan that in the long term analysis, Favre's style craps out more than it pays off. I think the results of his career provide adequate support for my hypothesis. Your mileage may vary of course. But there were plenty of times that Favre had HOF teammates of his own, both on offense and defense. I will give him one thing. He's a hell of an entertaining QB. I do compare him very much to John Elway. For years Elway had exactly the same reputation. His career was saved by the running game, and that's probably what would save Favre's too. But instead of providing the support that Adrian Peterson needs to be an Emmett Smith sort of threat, the Vikings are catering to Favre's desire for another target to heave the ball at. Using your own argument it would be far more effective and valuable for Minnesota to beef up their running game, but that's not what they are doing, and Brett Favre is not demanding that they do so, instead he is clearly pushing for more chances to roll his favorite dice. That's why I think he's selfish.
Drax
I'm not saying that QB's are interchangeable widgets. I AM saying, and have ALWAYS maintained that football is a TEAM GAME, that a GREAT QB (Marino, Tarkenton, etc.) without all the other pieces of the puzzle (Including a defense and special teams) ain't gonna win the big one or, for that matter, get much of anything other than individual stats. I AM saying, as I have ALWAYS said, that a great receiver raises the level of play of a great QB and vice versa -- and add in other weapons and it raises the play each of the others. A great receiver makes catches that other receivers don't -- even more, turns what could be interceptions into receptions (while good/mediocre receivers do the converse. We see what Matt Cassel has done after being traded from New England. *cough* We see what Daunte Culpepper did after Moss was traded. We see what Montana did once on the Chiefs. We see the difference between Favre in GB at the end (with nada), in NY (with less) and in Minnesota (with all pieces). We see Marino with no receivers or even a decent running game languishing out of the Superbowl (but once) for his entire career. We see Kelly getting there 4 times but unable to get over the top. We see it over and over -- Plunkett suckage until Oakland. Resurgence of Cunningham with Moss. We see receivers with one QB as the suckage, then, next year killing them under another. It's a TEAM GAME. Marino would have killed for a Moss, a Rice, a Smith. He didn't get one. He didn't get a ring either.
CosmicConservative
It's a team game with a disproportionate contribution from certain players. Quarterbacks, running backs and wide receivers all contribute far more to the overall result than guards, safeties or tackles. Just a pulled-from-my-butt figure, I'd say that the QB, primary RB and primary WR on an average NFL team provide more than 50% of the overall effectiveness of the team. For the sake of argument let's say it's 60%. Let's say each one contributes 20% individually. That seems pretty realistic since you keep saying that adding a Randy Moss turns an ordinary QB into a Superstar and takes a good QB to the Super Bowl. That means that Brett Favre contributes at LEAST 20% of the team's overall value, and since you contend that Favre has never had a Rice or Smith, he must be contributing MORE than 20%. Let's say he contributes 30%. That means he accounts for 5 games ON HIS OWN each year. OK, I'll even buy that. Let's say that Aikman, being part of a very effective trifecta of players, contributed 20%. That means Aikman accounts for 3 games ON HIS OWN each year. I'll even buy that. Over the course of a ten year stretch, that means Aikman accounts for the outcome of 30 games while Favre accounts for 50. Favre's TD rate over his career is roughly 20% higher than Aikmans (4.2% vs 3.5%) His interception rate over his career is roughly 40% higher (4.2% vs 3.0%). That's about what I would expect from their play styles actually. Let's say, just for the sake of argument, that touchdown and interception rates are directly proportional to wins. That means Favre's influence on the outcome of a game would be 20% higher for a win, and 40% higher for a loss. Again, this more or less matches my "gut feel" for the comparison of these two QBs. Let's say that a touchdown is twice as likely to win a game as an interception is to lose one. That would mean since Favre throws touchdowns and interceptions with equal frequency, he wins twice as many games as he loses. Giving him the best of the rounding, we'll say that means he wins 34 games and loses 16 out of the 50 he directly influences. Since Aikman throws touchdowns 17% more frequently than he throws interceptions, that means that he wins more than twice as many games as he loses. Of his 30 games he directly influences, his touchdowns are 2.4 times more likely to win than his interceptions are likely to lose. That's roughly 22 wins vs 8 losses. Since losing to an interception is more likely to happen against a good defense, that means it would be more likely to happen in a playoff game. That means that Favre has basically twice the odds of LOSING a big game than Aikman. Yes, all of this is based on some debatable premises, but in the end looking at the two in this way almost directly matches my personal opinion of their impact on games. That's why I would NEVER want Bret Favre to be my QB in the NFL. He LOSES too many BIG games. And he loses them because he gambles too much.
CosmicConservative
Some additional thinking. If this analysis is close to being accurate, that means that over a ten year regular game season, Aikman will lose 8 games, and Favre will lose 16. That means going into a game you have a 5% chance of Aikman losing the game and a 10% chance of Favre losing it. Since the NFL playoffs are a single elimination format, that means that Favre is twice as likely to end your season with an interception than Aikman is. And you know, I think that may actually be quite generous to Favre. But even if that is true, I'd be very unwilling to put my team's fortunes on Favre's back.
CosmicConservative
Hmm... Joe Montana's TD and Int %s are significantly better than even Aikman's using this same logic Joe would be about 1/4 as likely to lose a playoff game than Favre. Peyton Mannings TD ratio is better even than Joe's, but his int ratio is closer to Aikman's. Still, I'll guesstimate that Favre is three times as likely to lose a playoff game than Peyton... This is fun. Hmmm.... surprisingly Elway's TD ratio is a bit worse than Favre's, but his int ratio is almost the equal of Aikman... So Favre is probably something like 1.5 times as likely to lose a playoff game than Elway.... Very interesting... Dan Marino throws the whole thing off though... According to this he should have won a Super Bowl.... Unless his running back was fumbling them away.... maybe another post opportunity. Oh well...
CosmicConservative
Well, I think Bret just proved my point. Again...