Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Spot the logical fallacy, part II

By CosmicConservative
Their argument is deceptively simple and surprisingly powerful. Here's how it goes. If the universe lasts forever, then any event that can happen, will happen, no matter how unlikely. In fact, this event will happen an infinite number of times. This leads to a problem. When there are an infinite number of instances of every possible observation, it becomes impossible to determine the probabilities of any of these events occurring. And when that happens, the laws of physics simply don't apply. They just break down. "This is known as the "measure problem" of eternal inflation," say Bousso and buddies. In effect, these guys are saying that the laws of physics abhor an eternal universe. The only way out of this conundrum is to hypothesise some kind of catastrophe that brings an end to the universe. Then all the probabilities make sense again and the laws of physics regain their power. via Technology Review: Blogs: arXiv blog: Time Likely To End Within Earth's Lifespan, Say Physicists.
Just a hint here, but I wonder what would happen if you took this argument to an actual mathematician schooled in the field of infinite math.

Comments (0)

No comments on this post.