Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Comments (2)

qwerty182764
I thought insanity was the reason for her guilt? Is it just me, or is not guilty by reason of insanity completely missing the point? I think it stems from the old fallacy of seeing any influence whatsoever (including those completely contained within your brain) as external to the end product which we call our "wills". If anything motivates our decision, then we "aren't acting with 'free' will". But no one thinks to ask what decisions we would make (or be capable of making) if nothing motivated us!! It's the (false, or illusory, IMO) free-will vs. determinism dichotomy that bad philosophy has foisted on us. Eventually, you just have to draw a box around something, call it "you", and take responsibility for it. (Unless you want other people taking responsibility for it, in which case the only option available to them is to imprison you and absolutely rule your life). The logical choice for that area of responsibility is what you have the easiest and most direct control over - your body and mind.
CosmicConservative
I don't know if I can think that deeply about subjects like this. My thought process is decidedly simple and straightforward. Basically it goes like this: "If a man had done this, do you doubt for a second that he would have gotten the death penalty?" I don't discount the existence of post-partum depression, and I don't discount the possibility that Andrea Yates snapped and went off the deep end. But she did not go off the deep end so far that she did not know that what she was doing was wrong. You could make an argument (and I have seen it made) that all violence is a manifestation of some mental disorder or another. Cold blooded murder is, in effect, a symptom of insanity. Sane people don't kill people indiscriminately, especially their children. But, even acknowledging that Andrea was "not sane" does that mean she wasn't responsible? I don't think so. So I put this in the "travesty of justice" category.