Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The Buckley Rule, strategy and tactics

By CosmicConservative

As one would expect from a tactical guideline, the Buckley Rule’s ambition is limited. Tactics are not strategy. They are what you use to succeed within a given strategic framework. If you don’t have a strategy, tactics become a poor substitute for thinking. If you have the wrong strategy, tactics are only the means by which you will fail to achieve your highest interest — because you have miscalculated what your highest interest is.

The Buckley Rule is sensible only in a strategic framework that assumes ordinary politics. To be sure, such times will always feature intense policy disagreements among conservatives. Yet the competing factions will be in agreement on fundamentals...

...

These are not ordinary times. The nation is in the grip of post-sovereign leftists who reject the premise that the country is essentially good — that’s why, they say, it needs “fundamental change.” They are locking in their redistributionist vision by borrowing the terrifying trillions they spend. They are not worried about governing against the opposition of a lopsided majority of Americans. Unpopular is one thing; transformational is something else.

...

The movement now ascendant in the country is not about anything so small as the question of which party has control over the Senate in 2011. It is about the future of freedom and prosperity, about the kind of nation we will be. Its goal is to return the United States to a pre–New Deal understanding of the Constitution’s limits on federal power, and to a pre–Baby Boom Left’s appreciation of the greatness of America. That is not a project for one election cycle. It is the work of a generation.

via Contra Buckley - Andrew C. McCarthy - National Review Online.

Andrew McCarthy makes the same argument I made a few days ago (startlingly similar in fact, to the point of even making the distinction between strategy and tactics, and the point that these are extraordinary times) but makes it better than I did.

Comments (7)

mtnlurker
Don't kid yourself. Andrew C. McCarthy does not read this blog. :)
CosmicConservative
Heh, I wasn't suggesting that he did, just that my argument was one that someone like Andrew McCarthy would also propose. I just would point out that I got there several days earlier than Andy did...
CosmicConservative
Oh... and while I'm sure he doesn't read this blog... maybe he should. :)
Drax
Uh... There's the same basic flaw with this reasoning as I pointed out earlier. The time for this "purity" (no better word) argument is in the primaries. In the general election, the Buckley rule still obtains. And, as a result of the two-party system, the Buckley rule must be modified to include the caveat "And, all else being even, vote for the candidate belonging to the most conservative PARTY (of the two major parties)." This talk of a third party is nonsense. The tea party is composed, at its roots, of people looking for fiscal restraint, smaller government, and a return to constitutional government. People who believe in those values do NOT belong to the Democratic party or vote for Democratic politicians (in the vast sum). Thus, members of the "third party" would come, in vast great part, from the Republican Party, resulting in two minority parties, neither of which could control the legislative agenda. Finally, as a result of party politics, one of those two minority parties would be subsumed over time by the other -- resulting in essentially the same bloc of voters in an essentially re-named (or transformed) Republican party. Accordingly, I'm with Reagan in that we don't need a third party. We need a transformed Republican party. We can do this (and are doing this) by voting for the most conservative candidates in the primaries, and, in the general election, voting Republican -- regardless of the politics of the individual member.
CosmicConservative
The argument I and Andy are making is that the Tea Party movement is essentially a transformative movement for the Republican party. I really don't think you and I are that far apart here, with the following exceptions. As I read what you are saying, you seem to continue to assert that the "strategy" that Andy and I are talking about is somehow to not vote for lesser conservatives in the general election just because a more conservative candidate lost the primary. That is not the strategy. The Buckly Rule itself is meant to apply to primaries, not the general election. In the general election it is assumed that Republicans will vote for Republican candidates. The entire strategy is about promoting conservatives in the primaries, which was the whole point of my original post on Christine O'Donnell. She won the primary. That's what primaries are for. Now all Republicans need to get behind her. Had she lost the primary I would have said the same thing about her opponent. Certainly a RINO is preferable to a hardcore socialist. However, even after electing a RINO, the strategy is to continue to pressure that RINO to move more to the right, and at the next opportunity, if that RINO is still a RINO, try to get them defeated THIS time with a true conservative. This is why I was so adamantly opposed to Arlen Specter's support by the RNCC and President Bush. They ASSUMED that Pat Toomey was "unelectable." I, and others like me, said "bullshit! He's at least as electable as Arlen Specter! And he's a CONSERVATIVE!" So when Bush and the Republican "brain trust" threw Toomey aside to promote Specter, I predicted that Specter would back-stab Bush and he did. Several times. Had Bush pushed Toomey we would not have had the turncoat give the Democrats a filibuster proof majority. This is a fundamental difference I and those like me have with the Karl Rove's and George W. Bush's of the party. It is NOT all about PARTY to us. We don't want to support THE PARTY, we want THE PARTY to represent US. And that's exactly what is starting to happen. If your prediction of a 60 vote swing in the House and a 12 vote swing in the Senate is even close to true, my contention is that is ENTIRELY DUE TO the strategy I have been promoting for a decade, but which Rove, Bush and the Republican establishment have actively fought against. The Tea Party are the ones pursuing the effective strategy to return this country to it's constitutional roots. Republicans for the past 12 years have done nothing but become lapdogs for the Democrats. If you end up correct, and the House and Senate both shift to Repubican control, THAT's when the true Republican Civil War will begin. That's when the Tea Party electorate will demand results from their candidates, and that will precipitate an inevitable battle for the soul of the Republican Party. How that battle goes will most likely decide the 2012 elections and the cultural agenda for the next decade.
CosmicConservative
Another point to make here is that the reason Christine O'Donnell is the Republican candidate for Senate in Delaware is not because the Tea Party set out to sabatoge the Republican's chances. The reason is because the Republican establishment from day one concentrated all its efforts on her opponent, instead of getting the message from the Tea Party efforts of the previous 18 months and looking for a better candidate than Christine O'Donnell OR the existing RINO. Rove and his ilk preferred to stick with the status quo and ignore the incoming tidal wave of anti-RINO sentiment and as a result the only conservative left in the race was Christine O'Donnell. So the conservative-hungry primary voters voted for her. As I said in my first post, the situation in Delaware is entirely the fault of Karl Rove and the idiots in the Republican establishment who have given us the Prescription Drug program, the first massive bank bailouts, acquiescence to a wide range of liberal initiatives (McCain-Feingold anyone?) etc. They are the ones who ignored the warnings, ignored the success of other conservative candidates and who plodded along with the failed policies of the past eight years. Christine O'Donnell may be a flawed candidate, but the reason she's the nominee is because the Republican party is run by idiots who have long conflated their own personal self-interest and the desire to keep an old-boy network in power with the interests of their constituents and of the nation itself. From a tactical perspective of getting as many "Rs in seats" as possible, this is a bad thing. But from a strategic perspective of waking up the Karl Rove's of the party and making them understand that the base is dead serious about promoting conservatives, this is likely a big win. I don't think Rove and his peers will ignore such a situation again, and they will be looking for viable candidates in such obvious RINO situations in the future. That's a big win for everyone. That's why it's a strategic goal instead of a tactical one.
Drax
What you don't highlight in the above, the most important part of a WINNING strategy as you outline is the set of circumstances where someone like O'Donnell can win in the general election (or Brown or whomever) in a place where, absent those circumstances, they would not even stand a chance in the primary, let alone the general election. (This has been proven the case in state after state, primary after primary, as, over the decades, more "conservative" candidates (such AS O'Donnell) have run and run and run with almost no success while "RINOs" have had much more in those areas. (Delaware, California, etc.) And, the Buckley rule ISN'T only about the primaries. That's what the "who is electable" is all ABOUT. THAT PART of the rule is directed towards the GENERAL election and is a WARNING not to vote for a "more conservative" candidate who CAN'T WIN in the general election, even if this means voting for a less conservative candidate in the PRIMARY because that's the "most conservative candidate who is electable" IN THE GENERAL -- otherwise the "who is electable" has absolutely no meaning. And, the problem with Rove and Krauthammer et. al. is that they are simply WRONG about "who is electable" in Delaware; they are misreading the depth and breadth of the wave of conservatism and the corresponding wave of disgust with Obama/Reid/Pelosi agenda. What that means is that O'Donnell, who would not be "electable" in another year (and hasn't been "electable" in other years) is THIS YEAR "electable," and, thus, the Buckley rule is in effect. If you're CONVINCED that a more conservative candidate HAS NO CHANCE of winning a primary, voting for that candidate is simply FOOLISH -- BY YOUR OWN EVALUATION ("your" being the person who votes for an "unelectable" candidate in the primary). The most likely outcome of such a vote in the primary is EXACTLY what Rove and others believe it will be in Delaware, i.e. the election of a representative who will be far more liberal than the "moderate" RINO would be. So, as a "strategy," just voting for the "most conservative candidate" in the primary without taking into consideration the likelihood the candidate can win in the general election has the potential of electing a primary candidate who almost ensures (in that district/state) that the more liberal candidate wins in the general election because that candidate is simply more palatable to the majority of the populace of that district or state. Then (in ordinary years) the power of incumbency kicks in along with the power of party politics, almost ensuring that the winner stays in office essentially until he/she dies, retires, or moves "up" the political ladder. This is the REASON for the Buckley rule, i.e., to vote for the candidate (in the primary) who is electable (in the general).