Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Lady Gaga, as seen by Camille Paglia

By CosmicConservative
Gaga seems comet-like, a stimulating burst of novelty, even though she is a ruthless recycler of other people’s work. She is the diva of déjà vu. Gaga has glibly appropriated from performers like Cher, Jane Fonda as Barbarella, Gwen Stefani and Pink, as well as from fashion muses like Isabella Blow and Daphne Guinness. Drag queens, whom Gaga professes to admire, are usually far sexier in many of her over-the-top outfits than she is. via Lady Gaga and the death of sex | The Sunday Times.
So, I'm a big fan of Camille Paglia and in this article (what I was able to read of it) I think she is spot-on as usual... But a person of consequence critiquing "Lady Gaga" is sort of like shooting fish in a barrel don't you think? Isn't Lady Gaga pretty much a self-critique? Is it possible to take her seriously? I guess my take on this is that any culture that can take Lady Gaga seriously is not a serious culture. But I've noted that before, haven't I? I seriously am starting to believe that American and Western culture is pretty much all over but the shouting. And that's more or less what I see a "celebrity" like Lady Gaga as. Just the shouting.

Comments (14)

Drax
We have always been a culture of celebrity. And, by "we" I mean humanity. Do you know who the highest paid athlete in the known history of the world was (after adjusting for inflation and comparing his pay to that of his civilization) Gaius Appuleius Diocles, a Roman charioteer. http://news.discovery.com/history/highest-paid-athlete-hailed-from-ancient-rome.html While the calculations are, without question, imprecise, the meaning is pretty clear.
CosmicConservative
Perhaps that is true, but I don't think the comparison here is apt. A comparison of Diocles and Tiger Woods (as was done in the article you linked) would be apt. "Celebrity" obtained through sheer athletic prowess is entirely different than pop culture celebrity. Before I wrote the above post, I forced myself to go watch Lady Gaga's most frequently mentioned "masterpiece" video, Bad Romance. To say I was unimpressed would be putting it mildly. And it went on and on for five full minutes! Five minutes of "Rara blah blah blabla, Gaga bla bla blabla..." The only thing less interesting than the song was the video. This won two major music awards? Sheesh...
Drax
Well, considering that "entertainment" at the time was pretty limited, I think the comparison is apt. But, your overarching point is valid, I think. By the time my daughter is grown, tatoos will be out of style and body sculpting will be in style. Celebrities will need to be more and more shocking to capture the attention of the masses who have become ever more jaded -- probably, at a minimum, hard core porn as commonplace as soft core porn is now. (Well, to the extent that actual people remain celebrities...) Going to be a very interesting next 50 years to be sure.
CosmicConservative
More and more I see today's world as one that is caught between deliberate cultural self-destruction and inevitable technological transcendence. Thirty years ago I used to talk about the coming war between "knowledge" and "ignorance." By that I meant the war between the advance of technology and the atavistic tendencies of certain religions and political movements. I think I got that dead right, but my crystal ball was fogged. I only saw part of the overall picture. The knowledge-ignorance battle is really only one front in the overall battle that I now see. And while I thought the consequences of the knowledge-ignorance battle were another dark ages or something like a Star Trek society, now I think the consequences of the real battle will be more like a post-apocalypse vs a world totally unrecognizable in any meaningful, cultural way. Sometimes I don't know what to root for.
Drax
As bad a movie as it was, "Idiocracy" had some truth to it. I am constantly distressed (long since stopped being "amazed") at just how ignorant the vast bulk of our citizens are - voluntarily. At a time when anyone can learn just about anything about just about everything with relative ease, the past two generations are populated in the main by people who spend their lives studiously avoiding learning anything about just about everything. Sigh. I know that the converse is also true, though. We have a pretty significant minority of people who are amazingly informed about an extraordinarily eclectic knowledge base. Perhaps, with technology getting soon to the point where a very small percentage of the population will be required to perform actual work in order to support the rest of the world, that will be enough.
Drax
But, to be fair... Maybe it's simply that there's too much knowledge out there, and, in almost every subject, the amount of knowledge is so vast that, to be even informed on a subject (let alone be an "expert") would require devoting a lifetime to learn. It has been only 200 years or so since someone could know just about everything about just about everything -- have read every significant book -- kept up with (and understood) every significant technological advance. Now, it's impossible to even know everything about anything -- even a small sliver of a subject specialization -- and, in most of the scientific areas, much of what we "know" could not be "known" or manipulated without computers. Sigh. When I began reading science fiction wherein this type of scenario was addressed, it was far off in the future -- even in the early '70's. But, it ain't any more. And, it's going to do nothing but get worse.
CosmicConservative
I both agree and disagree with you. This is going to sound unbelievably egotistical I'm sure, but up until very recently I had a pretty good understanding of pretty much every practical aspect of a modern jet fighter. I understood how jet engines worked, how control surfaces worked, how the hydraulic systems worked, how the radar worked... There wasn't much that I didn't have enough of an understanding of that I couldn't have worked on one pretty confidently if somebody gave me a manual and access to engineering documents. The truth is that most of it is not that complicated, it just seems complicated when you put it all into one thing. I could say the same thing about nuclear reactors, internal combustion engines, electronic components... In most cases if you have a sufficient understanding of the fundamental technology, it's not that hard to pick up a manual or do some research to figure out the details. But overall I do agree with your point that it's impossible to be an "expert" in everything. But I don't think it's been possible to do that for more than 200 years. Calculus was invented about 400 years ago. Most of the "renaissance men" that are used as examples of mastering all areas of science (such as Thomas Jefferson or Benjamin Franklin, for example) never showed any mastery of even basic calculus, so I don't think they mastered as much of their contemporary science as they are given credit for. But knowledge is getting deeper and deeper all the time, even if it's not getting that much broader anymore. And it's so deep that while any really competent mind can pick and choose any of several fields, it is certainly not possible to be truly a master of every field. But then I don't think it's necessary. The change I see coming isn't a result of the quantity of knowledge in the world, it's a result of the technology that is being created to manage it. That's a different thing entirely.
Drax
Well....you're one of the significant minority who have a very eclectic (and a comparatively deep) knowledge base. However, to even come close to an assertion that you have a handle on a significant portion of the knowledge available (even a working knowledge) is going too far. (I was going to list the areas in which you are far from "expert" and others in which you have but a passing knowledge, but the list was simply too long. This is not in any way a slam on you -- you are the most informed person I know about just about every subject I can imagine.) There is simply too much to know. Even the "experts" in a field are only "experts" in a small sliver of their respective fields. This will accelerate (as you know) exponentially so that the management of information, the ability to ask questions properly, to program computers to solve questions, will become our new role. Or something along those lines... (And, btw, I think that you underestimate Jefferson. I will send you my copy of his letters.)
CosmicConservative
This is worth pursuing... I think there's a very fine distinction here between what you are calling "knowledge" and what I'm calling "knowledge." For example, let's say you want to use the example of something I have shown no interest in whatsoever, say, entomology, for example. I just don't care for bugs. The sheer volume of information on bugs stored in books, databases and scholarly papers is beyond anyone's capacity to "know." But "knowledge" is not now, nor has it ever been, about memorizing discrete facts. Nobody can memorize every fact in every field. In astronomy alone that would mean memorizing every data element known for millions of cataloged astronomical objects. But astronomers are not people who memorize astronomical objects, and have not been for hundreds of years. And an entomologist is not someone who memorizes beetle species. Astronomers are people who have mastered the fundamentals of astronomy and who know where to go to find out any particular facts about astronomy. I was reading an interesting article the other day, an interview with a professional astronomer who was discussing the recent discovery of an important anomalous galactic object by an amateur astronomer who found the object by poring over thousands of NASA released photos. Basically he said something about how amateur astronomers knew more about individual objects than professional astronomers because professional astronomers don't have the time to pore over photos, and frankly, they aren't looking in telescopes much anymore either. Professional astronomers use computers to crunch huge databases of objects to identify and catalog similarities or to look for specific objects with predicted behaviors. To put it more clearly, it is far more likely that you can find an amateur astronomer who has memorized the 400+ exoplanets that have been discovered than a professional astronomer. Professional astronomers are too busy creating the algorithms, writing the software and designing the optical devices that do the searching. So who has more "knowledge?" The amateur or the professional? The "knowledge" of the professional astronomer isn't about memorizing discovered exoplanets, its about creating the means to discover them. And frankly that's a skill set that many, many people in (and outside of) science have. I have no doubt that a competent computer scientist could sit down with a professional astronomer and within a few days have a complete and detailed understanding of what the professional astronomer does, and could do it themselves. This is true across a vast area of science. It is generally not necessary, and in fact is probably a huge liability, for a scientist to have a huge mental database of "facts" in order to do their job. What they have are generally a still fairly manageable set of skills, mostly involving mathematics, computer programming, methodology, technology and tradition. And for the most part, that mathematics, methodology, computer programming, technology and tradition is remarkably similar, whether you are talking about entomology or oceanography or astronomy. Even today.
Drax
I understand the distinction you're making. In fact, as an attorney, I was involved in many cases where I had to become familiar with many different areas, familiar enough to not only understand the essentials of the subject matter, but able to effectively cross-examine experts in those subjects, not only understanding what they were saying but the weaknesses or flaws in their own reasoning in the areas in which they were "experts." (I have cross-examined mechanical engineers, doctors (too many in too many areas of expertise to count), mechanics, dentists, forensic scientists, electricians, plumbers, and a host of other, lesser, "experts" through the years - a result of an eclectic practice...) Knowing where to find "knowledge" is extremely important. As you say, it isn't that hard to get a basic understanding of the fundamentals of just about any subject. But, I again assert, that it hasn't been much over 200 years (maybe more, but not twice that) since one could actually KNOW just about everything of significance, have READ every book of significance, PONDERED every significant thought -- and still live a full life in other pursuits. Maybe you think differently (I'll admit that there were some "knowledge" areas -- data rich areas (such as entomology or astronomy where the DATA in those subjects were, even then, too voluminous for anyone to "know" -- but ALL the theoretical "knowledge" could be known. I do not confuse "data" with "knowledge." Perhaps a better word for my contemplation of what I'm asserting is "understanding," i.e., one could have an almost perfect understanding of every significant discipline WITHOUT the necessity of "knowing where to look" for that knowledge was fully known.)
CosmicConservative
Heh... I think debating whether it's been 200 or 400 years since someone could literally read and understand every "important" scientific discovery, report, book or paper is really not worth arguing. Certainly at some point in the last millennium we crossed that line and have been accelerating ever since. I guess what I'm trying to say is perhaps a different thing, and that is that in spite of the inability to read EVERYTHING published, a sufficiently motivated and educated person could still keep up with dozens of fields and know the truly important issues and advancements in them. Usually any single branch of science only has a few really important discoveries or disagreements at any time, and those usually last for decades. Whether someone like Richard Feynman could read every paper published on engineering materials or not, based on his performance in the Challenger Presidential Commission hearings, he clearly was up to date enough to provide the critical understanding and demonstration of the now universally understood cause of the Challenger's solid rocket booster's failure. And he was a theoretical physicist, not a materials engineer. That's sort of my point.
apohle
Well, I'm jumping late to the conversation, but while I agree with you both that the knowledge issue is significant, I wonder of the problem is not in another area. Freedom requires responsibility and that is something that our culture seems to be moving away from. It takes not only time and effort learn enough to make informed decisions about life, but it also takes a willingness to make that choice and accept the consequences. That can be a hard thing. It's much easier to let someone else do it for you. Let them study and learn and if they make a bad choice, well at least you have someone to blame. Then you can find someone else to make the decision for you and on an on. That may sound overly harsh, and in some cases I think it should be. In others it makes sense. That, in essence, is what our form of government is about. We elect people to be the decision makers on our behalf, because it simply isn't possible to involve everyone in the decisions. I think, however, that our society overall has embraced that concept too far. We've lost sight of the value of freedom and seem too focused on the cost. I fear that for many people the idea of a benevolent lord who can manage their life for them is more appealing than taking responsibility for their own lives. I'm sure something will happen that will remind people of the value of the freedom that comes with that responsibility. I just hope that the lesson doesn't come too late and doesn't have too high a cost.
CosmicConservative
apohle, I tend to agree with you. As I keep reminding myself, our problem is not our elected leaders, it is the people who keep electing them. I am more and more coming to the conclusion that there should be some threshold of responsibility that one has to demonstrate to be able to vote. Voting is too precious and too powerful to simply allow any imbecile to exercise it. But that's sort of elitist I suppose. In spite of that I can't help but think that our current system is going to self destruct because we've got people who don't know if the sun is larger than the moon selecting the most powerful person on earth.
Drax
Not elitist, I don't think, but practical. Socrates/Plato recognized the danger of a democracy and the widening of the franchise to people with little to lose and much to gain merely by the casting of a vote. Guarding the country against a tyranny of the majority required a careful guard of the franchise. That guard almost entirely retreated, we see the results. It is a truism that, even today when it is utter simplicity to inform one's self as to the issues of the day, a majority of those who vote don't bother and simply "pay attention" (mostly by watching advertisements on television) only in the last few days of an election cycle. (And, of course, and thankfully, only a bare majority of the potential voters even bother to vote at all. I couldn't IMAGINE just how bad it would be if everyone who could vote did vote if the only change in their behavior was the act of voting...)