Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Comments (5)

Dadman
Yes, this and generous grants to obsequious, boot-licking scientists...
CosmicConservative
They can try to spin this any way they like, it is crystal clear that the man's work is completely in line with his department's mission statement (investigate industrial chemical impact on people), but his conclusions are not providing the proper PC outcome.
ASEI
I was pretty certain back in 9th grade that the secondhand smoke issue was exxagerated horribly by the media. I took the relative volume of a typical room (assuming the smoke disperses relatively evenly - probably a good one), and a smokers lungs, and came up with some ratio like order 1/10,000. You can't tell me then that that smoke dispersed over a far greater volume is going to have 1/10th the effect of smoking a cigarrette yourself.
ASEI
Unfortunately, people have a long history of abusing science for political ends. The moment the political class figured out that maybe there was some power and importance in what those nerds were doing, we saw a whole rash of pernicious social doctrine dressed up as science. "Scientific Socialism", "Social Darwinism" (which misses the point of natural selection entirely, even if it wasn't tribal murderousness dressed up as rational thought). Scientific progress will never be made by organizations that have been grabbed by politicians. Even absent outright malicious manipulation, if they have a mandated mission, that will preclude any observation or retention of data that suggests the mission itself is flawed. If there's any hope for scientific and technological progress, it lies with independent groups of people who are truly interested in knowing and understanding, or in building the tech respectively. While I am not advocating any sort of crankery, or throwing out the accumulated knowledge of an institution, established institutions themselves have entirely different sets of motivations than what gave rise to the knowledge/technology in the first place.
CosmicConservative
ASEI, this has been a central philosophical debate point since Plato's "Philosopher Kings" and no doubt goes back long before that. The supposed "intellectual elite" enjoy fantasizing about ruling the world, and yet it seems that there is little, if any, correlation between high intelligence and effective government.