Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The root of all evil...

By CosmicConservative
Money, that is. A few months ago I dove into the deep end of the economics pool along with a group of highly intelligent folks on a Dean's World thread about the likely consequences of Obama's frenetic and profligate spending policies. I learned a lot about macro-economics at that time. Since then the debate has shifted a bit from a simple discussion of spending to a more complex discussion of the role of the Federal Reserve and the consequences of Obama's massive spending coupled with the quiet growth of the US money supply, all of which is tied into the drastic shift of bad mortgage debt from large banks to, ultimately, the Fed itself. This has sparked a simultaneous end-of-the-world dread of both hyperinflation and deflation of the currency. I wonder if there has ever been a time when the best and brightest minds of the world were locked in violent disagreement that the most dreaded threat to world stability was either hyperinflation or massive deflation, but nobody could agree on which one was truly the more dangerous, all the while each side was running around like Chicken Little screaming "Hyperinflation!" "Deflation!" in an incomprehensible cacophany. If nothing else worries you about the future, this fact alone should send shivers up your spine. We are truly adrift in an economic storm with no rudder and no compass. The stricken ship of state has four types of passengers, those shouting "the ship is sinking! Bail water!!" those shouting "The ship is overturning, we need water for ballast!" those looking around in confusion willing to help, but afraid that they'll make things worse, and those cowering in the bottom of the boat desperately praying for the storm to go away. I suppose there's a fifth group in the boat, those blissfully unaware of the danger of the storm who are standing on the deck with arms spread saying "I'm King of the World!!" to the howling winds.... More and more every day I am convinced that the world is on the brink of an economic transformation of massive proportions. Something along the lines of the 1930s when the gold standard was tossed overboard. And more and more I think that's probably necessary for the world to continue to thrive and grow. I tend to see things in very simple terms. When I view the world economy I don't tend to think in terms of gold supplies, dollars printed and fiduciary abstractions like stock prices. I tend to think of the economy as a means of measuring individual and collective wealth. And "wealth" in this sense isn't about dollars, it's a measure of an individual's or a nation's ability to contribute to the overall value of civilization itself. In that sense I see the world struggling to figure out how to further abstract the concept of "money" so that the risk of economic disaster is further mitigated, and so that individual contributions to the value of civilization are made more fungible across more arbitrary boundaries. Which inevitably leads me to the conclusion that the solution to our current crisis is the end of the "cash economy" itself. I think in the next months and years you will hear more and more about the limitations of the current system to deal with artificial economic obstacles and the limitations of the powers that be to manipulate the levers of the economy to avoid meltdowns like the mortgage crisis. In many of the discussions I've read about the current economic mess, the "causes" of the problem are almost universally blamed on individual mismanagement of the existing levers that were put in place after the Great Depression. Who was misusing the levers and which levers were misused are hotly debated, but there isn't anyone saying that the problem is due to some unknown or unknowable force that moves the economy without known source or motivation. That's the same thing, at root, as saying our current economic mess is entirely the fault of the folks who have been steering the economic ship for the past generation or so. If that is believed to be the fundamental root cause of the problem, then the only solution will be to create a new set of levers and put new people in charge of them. And with the current administration in Washington, that implies to me that they are looking for solutions that they feel will create a global world currency, a global economic engine and a global set of financial overseers who will control the levers that manipulate the world economy. Such a thing is inevitable unless the forces of darkness succeed in sending us back to a new dark ages. Since Obama is such an academic groupie, I am quite certain that he is very interested in radical new economic theories, especially those that support his ideological views about the world being run by elites who know what is best for the "little people" and that the idea of the USA as a unique and special economic entity is an idea his mind recoils from. If I am correct, the logical next step for Obama's think tank is to start promoting a debit card economy, instead of a printed cash economy. That would be the first step for creating a virtual foundation for the world's economy, which would provide those elitists with the most flexible and powerful levers they could imagine to control the economy. In principle I'm not even really that opposed to the concept. Money, after all, is just a marker, just an expression of the trust people have in their ability to trade value for value. What that ability is based upon is somewhat arbitrary and fashionable, not really so much rooted in "actual value". This fundamental need to free people up to create value without the need to exchange it with another concrete thing of equal value is why "money" was created in the first place. All forms of "cash" since then have been refinements of the idea of creating an abstraction to allow value to be exchanged between two or more people who have something of value to offer, but who do not need the specific item or service that the other is offering. In the end it is probably best to have that value exchange process be as abstract as possible, to avoid problems of supply and demand (inflation and deflation), boundaries (exchange rates) and intentional manipulation of the system to generate false value (such as the bundled bad mortgages which eventually ended up at the bottom of the current economic model, almost as if they fell there by sheer weight of bad karma). Again, listen for the mention of putting the US money supply on a debit card basis instead of printing cash. That's probably the first step.

Comments (26)

mtnlurker
I am not sure but I think there must be some sort of "marker" to trade between people rather than between a person and a entity like a store. This allows transactions that are not tracked by the government.
CosmicConservative
Mtn, in the end, it does the government no good to not track your transactions. Apart from pure barter, the government will eventually know every transaction you undertake. That's the whole point. In the long run barter itself will likely be criminalized as a crime against the all-powerful, all-knowing state. After all, if they don't know about it, how will they tax it?
Tom DeGisi
I'd rather go to an all cash economy, with no checks, debit cards or credit cards than a no cash economy. Yours, Tom
CosmicConservative
Tom, I can't claim to be smart enough, or knowledgable enough about economics to understand all the complexities of the debates, but from what I do understand the long-term debate is going to eventually be between a "concrete" and a "virtual" foundation for the economy. The argument for a "concrete" economy is that the sheer need to create and monitor physical artifacts will provide some cushion to mitigate unexpected dramatic economic upheavals. The argument for a "virtual" economy is that it would provide far more powerful tools to manipulate the economy directly to avoid or mitigate those same unexpected impacts. For example, let's be real Luddites for a moment and suggest that the economy should be based on the gold standard. Then one day some brilliant entrepeneur hauls an asteroid into near-earth orbit and overnight the gold supply available to the economy increases tenfold. The impact to that economy would be devastating. (This actually happened to Europe's economy when gold and silver were discovered in great quantities in South America.) If the economy was purely cashless and based on digital markers, the influx of new gold could be mitigated almost instantly without the massive deflation that would occur in the pure gold based model. In other words, the value of gold itself might suddenly drop, but the value of your home would not be affected much. That's the theory anyway...
CosmicConservative
... also... in the end the fundamental question of economics is how do we use economic models to maximize the potential of human civilization itself? Cash-based systems are self-limiting. There is no way around the inflation/deflation problem. Money itself is constrained by and reacts to the laws of supply and demand. Money becomes an absolute marker which determines value. In the virtual model "money" is merely an abstract notion that tracks value. Supply and demand affect goods and services, but not the abstract markers that act as a tool to exchange value. Think about all the people who profit from transactions simply by exploiting the fluctuation of currency values. All of that would go away. In theory even financial instruments like mortgages themselves would go away to be replaced by algorithms that manipulate your "credit" values directly as you exchange goods or services to pay off your "loan." Of course you have the problem of what happens if the Fed's servers crash....
Tom DeGisi
Cosmic, I intuitively understood that, actually, and I like the way you spelled it out more. My point was only implied, and not spelled out at all. I would prefer a system where transactions could not be tracked by the government, for freedom's sake. Also, any system which gives the government more economic levers to manipulate without a dramatic increase in human wisdom will not maximize the potential of human civilization itself. It will maximize the potential of humans to screw up human civilization itself, usually by mistake. Yours, Tom
staylor
A couple of thoughts... Could there not be sixth type of person in the boat who is quietly building a life raft out the deck furniture and planning on charging passage for whomever wishes a ride in the event of a sinking? A single planetary monetary system would inevitably entail a world government. As we have seen with Europe one currancy is worthless without one economic policy and if an overarching world government controls the economy than they might as well control everything. Such a debit card system as you describe would still be subject the effects of inflation and deflation just as current curencies are. For a means of exchange to have any meaning at all it must be limited in some respect and thus becomes subject the laws of supply and demand and thus the inflation deflation cycle. A symbol is still symbol whether or not it is printed on paper or exists electronically. I agree the Tom that I would prefer an all cash system before an all electronic system. Speaking of Dean's World, there actually is a pretty good economic thread over there right now if you want to check it out. I must say that I do find it ironic that Dean keeps ranting on how a Free Market system allows the concentration of too much money and power in the hands of "megacorperations" which he wants to rectify through the use of regulations which is also the best vehicle for corperations to exert said power. End of random thought stream.
CosmicConservative
Drax... I disagree. In fact it is the concrete based economies that require a closed system, as I tried to demonstrate with the asteroid full of gold example. Tom, freedom from government intrusion is going to disappear regardless of the type of economic system we use. It is an inevitable consequence of Moore's Law and the need for government to intrude. staylor, if the means of exchange is merely an abstract tracker of individual "wealth" it will not be subject to the law of supply and demand. You assert that it "must be limited in some respect". It will be limited only by the size of the economy. That's it's fundamental purpose, to track the value of the economy. As the economy grows, the supply of "credits" will grow. What an individual credit buys will be solely determined by the powers who control the levers. Of course we lack the wisdom to manage such a system, and it will inevitably blow up in our faces too. But that won't remotely stop us from doing it.
Drax
How does one buy something from Europe, unless it is on the same system?
staylor
Your last post pretty much describes the system we have now. The Fed creates dollars to keep up with the current growth of the economy along with a couple points of inflation and since the dollars are not tied to anything of physical value their value is purely symbolic. If the Fed needs inflation, they create more dollars and if they deflation they take them out of circulation. A great deal of the money used today already has no physical manifestation and only exist in computor somewhere. My point about that the currency must be limited holds true because since the economy is not limitless this supply of debit dollars can not be limitless either. For the laws of supply and demand to apply to something it needs to be finite and valued and the money in your system would be both, and if there is supply and demand then there is inflation and deflation. The two factors that have people talking about massive inflation and deflation today would also hold true in your system. The inflation fears today are driven by shakey US economic policy that seems intent on decreasing the value of the dollar in order to better get out of debt. To do this the Fed is increasing the dollar supply, something that the government in your system could actually do easier. The defaltion fears are driven by corperations and banks hoarding instead of leding it or investing it because they are afraid that future government regulations are going to slam them hard and they want the extra cash on hand so they can survive. I dont see how a governemnt's urge to create money or a bank's urge to stockpile money (under the right circumstances) would be negated under your debit card system.
CosmicConservative
Drax, I stated in the original post that the goal is a single world economy. I said the debit card would be the first step. staylor, you and I may not be understanding "supply" in the same way. In a sense, if you are looking at the number of credits at any given time being a finite number, then yes the supply is "limited." But that's not the true "supply" of the credits. The true "supply" of the credits is whatever arbitrary value the powers that control the economy choose to give them. Done right that will be based on an algorithm that calculates total net worth of the entire economy where the total number of credits x the value of a single credit = the total economic value. If someone hauls an asteroid into earth orbit full of gold, the powers simply add that value of gold to the total economy (using some algorithm that factors in the relative decreased value of gold vs. the total amount of gold to come up with a new value for the economy) and credits are modified to reflect the new value. Yes, this means that an individual's "net worth" is also arbitrary. But that's true today if you think about it. Yes, the fact that the powers that control the economy could do these things easier is the whole point! That's why they want it! Think of it this way, when the government's power to control the value of "currency" is restricted by some finite limit (in the case of a pure gold standard) or a physical limit (in the case of printing money, you can only print so much, so fast and distribute it so fast) then the powers that control the economy are constrained by those limits. In today's world the US Government is actually also constrained by how much money the Fed will print. It may be a fine point to make, but neither the White House nor the Congress have direct control of the Federal Reserve. It was set up that way on purpose in part to create an artificial hedge against the government printing money on a whim. That's what they will want to change. I am not saying this will be a better system, nor that it will be less liable for abuse. I'm saying it is what the elites in power today want, and it is what a one-world economy and world government will desperately need. That's why it will happen. Not because it stops the government from fiddling with the economy, but because it makes it easier.
Drax
The problem with such being the "first step" is that it can't be the "first step." It can't functionally exist without there being a single global economy in place. It is more like a "last step" thus only existing in a closed system, which was kinda my point.
CosmicConservative
Drax. The government is actively pursuing debit cards for distribution of entitlements. They are already being used as a replacement for food stamps. Rebates are being sent out on debit cards. There is work underway to distribute social security and medicare disbursements this way. This has already started. Once the system is predominately controlled by digital cards which track "dollars" to provide services, all it takes is software to change the "dollars" to something else.
Drax
Oh, I agree that entitlement programs, completely in the hands of a centralized government in a closed system (can't buy food with food stamps in Canada or receive medical assistance via Medicaid anywhere but in the U.S. (and protectorates). I agree that we will move to a completely cashless society at some point - internally. I believe this for entirely different reasons than do you. I believe it will happen because there's billions of tax dollars (and, accordingly, billions of opportunities for graft and corruption) in the "underground economy" which would be captured by the government. But, until there IS a "one-world" (government/economy) then moving to a completely digital model for the transfer of wealth simply won't happen.
CosmicConservative
Drax, you and I have a completely different idea of cause and effect on this issue. You seem to think a world government is necessary before we go to a completely cashless world economy, and I believe exactly the reverse, we can't move to a world economy until we have a completely digital economy. The complications of managing hundreds of individual physical currencies will create too much friction to achieve the world economy goal. Plus, it's just easier to create the digital infrastrucure for a cashless economy than it is to create the political framework for a single world economy. It will be done first just because it suits the needs of individual governements for reasons quite separate from the one-world economy goal. Also, attempting to move individual countries onto a single currency while their economies are still separate has its own issues, as we can see with the crises in Europe over the Euro.
CosmicConservative
Oh, and your reason for believing in a cashless economy are not "different" than mine, that was the point I was making earlier in my response to mtnlurker, a major reason for the move to a cashless society is to make it as difficult as possible to have an underground economy. That's part of the reason for it. Not the entire reason, but a significant reason.
staylor
But I would think that an underground economy would still exist, it would just use an unofficial form of currency. Such an unofficial currency would have value purely for buying things on the underground market and as a form of wealth that is not subject to aribitrary adjustments by the elites. In fact I would expect the underground economy to balloon under such a system.
Drax
From the perspective of "motive," I suppose the motive is unique to the individual(s) who are pushing for it. As to the "cause/effect" reasoning... See, I believe that the main barrier to going on a global economic unit is nationalism. Until that barrier is overcome, there is no potential for going to a national economic unit. If nationalism obtains, then no global economic unit. Once nationalism is "defeated," then there's the potential for a global economic unit. Thus, I can't see the adoption of a global economic unit while there nationalism (and, therefore, nations) obtains. Once nationalism is "defeated," then it would follow (cause/effect) that a global economic unit would be created. Of course, a global economic unit could be first, i.e., be adopted while there are still "nations," but, since I assert that "nationalism" must first be defeated for countries such as the U.S. or China or Russia or any of the significant powers to adopt a global currency, those "nations" will be nations in name only -- since "nationalism" will, necessarily, be a thing of the past. (See, e.g., the adoption of the Euro (along with the associated problems -- especially in hard times -- which are solely attributable to nationalism.)
CosmicConservative
staylor, the general process of law enforcement throughout history has never been to make it impossible to commit crimes. It has been to make it as inconvenient as possible. An underground economy is probably always going to exist, but the more control and awareness the government has over the distribution of economic "marks", the harder it will be to profit from one. There is a reason most organized crime members are prosecuted under tax evasion or money laundering charges. The underground economy is tax evasion by definition, and if you want to utilize your underground "marks" to purchase legitimate products (like a new car) then you have to "launder" them so they appear to be legitimate "marks." One of the major goals of a completely digital economy will be to make it virtually impossible to launder money illegally (the government, of course, will be able to launder money legally at will). If they are successful in making laundering money virtually impossible, then the underground economy will only be able to exchange existing goods and services, which will make the profiting off of the underground economy limited to what the underground economy itself can provide. That will significantly reduce the incentive to participate in the underground economy for anyone who's real goal is to use their profits for legitimate purposes, like buying a house, for example. A cashless, digital economy is a game-changer for lots of reasons. The sorts of illegal activities that are super profitable today won't be profitable in such an economy. No doubt there will be new ways to profit, but it will take some time for those to develop.
CosmicConservative
Drax, if nations individually move to a cashless, digital economy, then the move to a global economy is simply a case of changing the parameters of each nation's system so that they conform to each other. In fact, it would not even be necessary to have every country adopt a single worldwide currency unit (although I think they would anyway) because all of the conversions would happen in completely transparent transactions that occur completely out of sight of the individuals in the transaction. So an American tourist in Moscow would use their digital card to buy something and the entire transaction would appear to be in "dollars" to them, while the identical transaction would simultaneoulsy apper to be in "rubles" to the Russian merchant. Such things are possible today with debit and credit cards. What is lacking is a global framework for these things to happen according to a single set of rules. Those rules can be put in place while "nationalism" still exists. It would be quite possible and feasible for those rules to become an unseen foundational "currency" that is the real value of every person's wealth, and the view of that wealth in "dollars" or "rubles" or "marks" or whatever would simply be a seamless conversion done for the convenience of the person involved. Once that is done, a complete worldwide converson to a single "currency" would require nothing more than removing the conversion layer and showing the true value in the fundamental units of the worldwide currency. The worldwide economy operates more or less in this fashion today, it just uses the dollar as that "foundational currency" and all the conversions are done painfully and there are profit-mongers who suck their share of the transactions from the process. Also, since much of the process is still manual, there are ways to profit from the delay of information moving from place to place, which allows people to manipulate currency exchange rates for profit. That would also go away with a fully digital system.
ASEI
Personally, I don't like the idea of any one-world monetary system. While free trade is important, and there is nothing to stop credit companies from easy conversion of currency, the actual money supply is quite a different thing. Right now, different countries manage their money supplies differently. Some are near hard, with very conservative management. Other countries like Turkey use and abuse their money supply to finance public works, and their money is useless as a store of value. If ever there was a one-world money supply, then the country in charge of it would abuse the issuing of the money and essentially loot the rest of the world in an inflationary spiral, rather than resorting to more transparent modes of taxation of it's own citizens. The EU is a perfect example of why a one-world money system sucks. Italy wants to keep the money supply loose to keep its exports up. Germany wants to keep it's money supply tight so that it reliably stores value. France and Greece want to fund bread and circuses on the backs of everyone else.
ASEI
"The worldwide economy operates more or less in this fashion today, it just uses the dollar as that “foundational currency” and all the conversions are done painfully and there are profit-mongers who suck their share of the transactions from the process." PS - the only reason why there is a market for the "profit mongers" at all has nothing to do with the actual conversion of the currency itself. It has to do with the facts that the economies and management of the money of different countries is in an objective sense actually very different. When you have a country whose real economy is growing and money supply is remaining relatively constant, then their money is a good store of value, and it makes sense to invest in them. When you have a country that makes nothing and prints bills, then you want to unload those on some sucker. Money is a promise to repay someone for wealth created or services rendered. It is fundamentally about trust (which is why references to it being the root of all evil have always struck me as somewhat bizzare). Different nations and cultures have different levels of faithfullness in their repayment, different levels of meddling in the economy to avoid balancing their books, and hence warrant different levels of trust in the currency they issue.
ASEI
PPS - Other than baroque complexity, and the fact that humans are psychologically too authoritarian to ever allow it, I see nothing that would prevent, with good enough computerized tracking and rating systems, everyone on earth to act as an issuer of their own currency. It worked (with certain spectacular exceptions - trust, in the wild west). The market would decide how trustworthy your promises to repay someone are, and the value of your means of doing so. That, and the number of obligations you incur would in turn determine the value of your new promises to repay new obligations. Well, it would be a mess, but the one thing that would be absent from the system would be a third party (the government) being able to manipulate the value of your money so that it can avoid it's own obligations.
ASEI
PPPS - Finally, I ultimately don't like one-world anything, other than trade and travel. Having a one world money supply is saying that you trust the entire rest of the world to repay it's obligations. Having a one world government is saying you trust the entire rest of the world to defend your family and protect your liberty. I doubt PT Barnum could push those concepts without wanting a bath afterwards.
CosmicConservative
ASEI, I hope you don't think that my prediction of the inevitability of this is a ringing endorsement of it. It is inevitable. And the more I think about it, the more I think that's not necessarily a bad thing. Yes, it means individual countries will no longer to be able to manipulate their currencies like we've seen so many "banana republics" do. Also, the powers that be won't be beholden to any single country. That's part of the foundational premise of this. That's why it will be a precursor to a one-world government. That's the ultimate goal of these people.