Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

End of the world ruminations...

By CosmicConservative
Steven Hawking has gotten into the news for saying something that every reasonably well informed and reasonably intelligent person should know by now. If we don't spread human civilization beyond the earth, our future is likely to end from some sort of global calamity, most likely one with a cosmic source (an asteroid collision, a rogue black hole, a gamma ray burst in our direction or a local supernova...). Why it is possibly news that Hawking states the obvious is a mystery to me. However, the "news reports" which cover the statement report that Hawking listed the Cuban Missile Crisis as one of the "end of the world" scenarios, and some "reporters" mention "Global Climate Change" as another. This is a source of irritation and frustration to me, and has been ever since a group of "scientists" (including Carl Sagan) testified in front of Congress in the 70s or 80s about how even a single nuclear blast could trigger a "nuclear winter" and kill off all life on the planet. First of all, let me make this clear. Killing off all life on planet earth would require a truly incomprehensible disaster. Life has survived hundreds of climate swings from a near total snowball earth, to sweltering temperatures all the way to the poles. Life has survived super volcanoes and hundreds, probably thousands of massive asteroid and comet impacts. Unless something turns our atmosphere into a corrosive acid bath such as Venus, or the earth heats up so much that it boils all the water into space, life is going to survive on earth until the earth is swallowed by the eventual red giant that our sun will swell into in about five billion years. Of course "life surviving" is not the same as "humanity surviving" and "humanity surviving" is not the same thing as "modern civilization surviving." My personal opinion is that it will be more difficult to wipe out humans than it will be to wipe out cockroaches. Humans are a cussedly determined bunch when it comes to survival. Human civilization is much more fragile. While humanity itself would almost certainly survive even a global thermonuclear war, I'm not sure our current civilization will survive the current administration in the White House.

Comments (3)

staylor
"and some “reporters” mention “Global Climate Change” as another." Usually something like this would be enough for me to change whatever channel I am watching. It is partly because I think Global Warming is a bunch of bunk, but even if one does accept the theories behind Global Warming this is still hysterical nonsence. Even the very flawed IPCC does not predict warming of more than a degree or two over the next hundred years and this equates to life ending catastrophe..... how exactly. Even if the Earth warmed by incomprehensible 50 degrees, something not even Al Gore the windbag predicts, I am sure that life and humanity could eke out a living in the Polar regions. Antarctica would probably be quite nice. Of course any warming beyond a few degrees is quite impossible short of moving closer to the sun so I am not worried. Just a pet peeve of mine.
CosmicConservative
A couple of points. 1. Global Warming is real. There's really no doubt about it. The earth has been warming for the past 10,000 years. There have been fits and starts in the warming with some periods of cooling, but the overall trend has been a definite and obvious warming trend that has pushed the glaciers back into the poles and has ushered in a golden age for most life, including human beings, on this planet. 2. The earth has been much warmer in the past. As much as ten degrees warmer. It has also been much colder. In fact on average the earth tends to be an ice planet, not a steam planet. But neither our current period, nor the most hysterical projections from the Global Warming alarmists, are anywhere near the hottest the earth has been, even in the last million years, much less over the life of the planet. There are really only two things worth debating on the subject of climate change. The first is how much of the current variation of temperature can be attributed to human activities. The second is whether or not those temperature variations are net positive or net negative for life in general, and humans in particular. I am unconvinced of the need for drastic action on either of the only two things worth debating. That's my position on climate change in a nutshell.
staylor
I agree, my post is purely relating to human caused global warming.