Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Mosque at "Ground Zero"

By CosmicConservative
I've avoided commenting on this so far because I've had conflicting opinions on the subject. For example, I'm not really one to be swayed by arguments about "sacred ground." I understand the emotional response to the event, but in the end, land is land and real estate is real estate. Do we really want to make a monument out of a terrorist act anyway? I've said from day one that the best response to the act is to rebuild a bigger, better and more capitalist enterprise on the site. The best way to show what it means to be an American isn't to bow our heads in silent homage as we pass the area, the best way is to build a better economic engine which leads to more freedom and liberty for all people. If it were up to me, I'd build a taller, larger and more dynamic World Trade Center on the spot. And that, in a nutshell, is what this Mosque is all about. It's a deliberate attempt to co-opt the location as an icon for Islamic jihad. It's a way for Islamists to claim victory over America. If the mosque is built, you can bet there will be worldwide celebration when it is opened, and the message spewed from Islamist pulpits across the world will be that this shows that Islam is superior to the decadent west. But in the end, the real message behind the spin and the hype will be that the mosque was built because the mosque builders paid what the land owners asked to buy the land. Which is fundamentally a capitalist message. They can build a mosque because they bought the real estate. Isn't that what capitalism is all about? Isn't that what liberty is all about? Is this the land of the free?

Comments (23)

Tom DeGisi
Spot on with your capitalist day one response. Big fuss on Dean's World. By word count I am clearly the fussiest. Here, I disagree only with your characterization of what the mosque is about. Rather vehemently, actually, but I don't want to do the outrage thing here. Ron Coleman does it with excellent logic. Read his post. The people who are building the mosque talk about building bridges, Muslim outreach, Islamic cultural centers and the mosque. I think it is only fair to take them at their word. Here is a simple thought process I've seen many times, whether it is Christian mega churches, sports complexes or mosques. It's a mosque. Those are always good. How could anyone object? It's an Islamic cultural center. Those are always good. How could anyone object? It's Muslim outreach. That's always good. How could anyone object? It's building bridges to our fellow victims of the 9/11 attacks. That's always good. How could anyone object? Do not underestimate rosy enthusiasm (as opposed to deadly enthusiasm) for a beloved cause as a perfectly sufficient reason behind this. Yours, Tom
CosmicConservative
Tom: Both your and my interpretation are likely true in their own measure. I am quite certain that there are nefarious purposes behind the building of the mosque at that location. I am also quite certain that there are sincere good-hearted people who truly want to build bridges. These are not mutually exclusive options. And we can wait until it is opened to see if I am right about how it will be used as Islamist propaganda. I am quite certain I am right, as I am also quite certain you are right. The issue here is that I don't have any problem with the good-hearted bridge-building intentions, so I don't mention them. I do have a problem with the Islamist, nefarious purposes, so I point them out. Both are in play.
Tom DeGisi
> I am quite certain I am right, as I am also quite certain you are right. I have evidence though, because it matches what they say. You either have to mind reads, or you have evidence you aren't presenting. Now this is a much better than normal conspiracy theory, because it requires only a few people to keep a secret, and it does not require any convoluted logic at all, but without evidence it's still a conspiracy theory. I don't think it's right to advance such a theory as probably true without evidence. Did you read Ron's post? I'm not seeing the difference between your theory and what he is complaining about. Yours, Tom
CosmicConservative
No, I don't get on DW much anymore. I'm basing my "conspiracy theory" on my understanding of human nature and history. If you think there won't be Islamists gloating about a Mosque being built on ground zero, I don't think I'm the one torturing logic. Here's some evidence for you Tom. If the true and only purpose of the Mosque was to "reach out" and "build bridges" then the immediate and obvious reaction to massive backlash from ordinary Americans outraged at the concept would be to do as the Pope did when people complained about a convent being built on Auschwitz, and simply say "Oops. Right you are, that is insensitive. We'll build it somewhere else." The reaction instead is "go to hell, we'll build it anyway."
Dadman
CC is quite right on this one... Fair minded people interested in outreach and building bridges would be more sensitive to the controversy this mosque is generating and offer to locate it elsewhere. No question.
Drax
Frankly, only a deluded fool would think (feel) that the purpose of building the Mosque THERE had any other purpose than to claim victory for the Jihad. Period. The notions of any Muslim religion or religious leader caring about "outreach" towards any other religion or members of any other religion or citizens of any other country which is not a Muslim religion is ridiculous, and anyone who believes any words to that effect are deluded fools. These hypocritical SOB's want us to exercise our cultural "tolerance" to tolerate their religion in its full form (as practiced in Iran, for example -- or in the mountains in Afghanistan) so that they can advance a barbaric "religion" which has, as its fundamental core, an utter (and violent) intolerance of any religion other than Islam. These lying SOB's want to conquer the U.S., impose Sharia law -- enslave women -- and turn this country and the rest of the world into mindless drones who follow the orders of "religious leaders" in every aspect of their lives. This "mosque" should not be built here. In fact, no more mosques should be built anywhere in the U.S. until and unless each and every other religion which desires can build churches in the heart of any Islamic nation and any person in those countries can convert to those religions and live their lives in accordance with those religions (or none whatsoever) without being stoned, hung, or imprisoned. Islam, unless it's stopped, will take over the world simply because it takes but never gives ground (except through force). I like bikinis. Really. Bastards.
esox67
mmm Deluded Fool = democrat = elected official in NY = they see nothing amiss here
Tom DeGisi
CosmicConservative, > No, I don’t get on DW much anymore. I didn't ask you to read the thread. I asked you to read the post. > If you think there won’t be Islamists gloating about a Mosque being built on ground zero, I don’t think I’m the one torturing logic. No, in fact, even the deluded liberals on the thread agree this is true. But it doesn't mean the people building the thing had this in mind. Yours, Tom
Tom DeGisi
Drax, > Frankly, only a deluded fool would think (feel) that the purpose of building the Mosque THERE had any other purpose than to claim victory for the Jihad. > Period. You lack imagination on the subject. I have a politically conservative orthodox Jew who disagrees with you, and so does this politically conservative Evangelical Christian and neither of us are deluded fools. Period. > The notions of any Muslim religion or religious leader caring about “outreach” towards any other religion or members of any other religion or citizens of any other country which is not a Muslim religion is ridiculous, and anyone who believes any words to that effect are deluded fools. Hmmmm. What do you think outreach means to members of a religion that encourages converts? It's true historically that Muslims mostly go for conquest, subjugation and tax relief to encourage converts, but they also historically have always done successful missionary work in non-Muslim countries near and far. This has always been particularly true of Muslim traders. I have been proselatized by a very well meaning Muslim. A nice guy. He really wanted to convert me. Totally disagreed with him in very important ways I did not want to explore and you might guess - since we were co-workers and who wants to interest the EEOC for no particular reason. Especially since it was a great way for me to learn about an important issue. (My wife and I also went to an Organizing for Obama meeting once. Heh.) It's not like he was a jerk about things. He even arranged for a speaker at our men's group, whom I cut no slack at all on one issue. > These hypocritical SOB’s want us to exercise our cultural “tolerance” to tolerate their religion in its full form (as practiced in Iran, for example — or in the mountains in Afghanistan) so that they can advance a barbaric “religion” which has, as its fundamental core, an utter (and violent) intolerance of any religion other than Islam. > These lying SOB’s want to conquer the U.S., impose Sharia law — enslave women — and turn this country and the rest of the world into mindless drones who follow the orders of “religious leaders” in every aspect of their lives. An excellent description of some Muslim SOB's. Other Muslims have lived under sharia law and don't miss it. Others want sharia law to influence our law. Well, I'm a Christian. I want my religion to influence our law too. I suspect many want that influence to be a lot more extensive and intrusive than we are used it. Others want to smoke, drink, not worry too much about halalel food and go to strip joints. Those aren't nearly as interested in extensive sharia law. Others are the sorts of Muslims who take their missionary outreach seriously. What you haven't done is give evidence placing the builders in the group of which you are suspicous. > This “mosque” should not be built here. In fact, no more mosques should be built anywhere in the U.S. until and unless each and every other religion which desires can build churches in the heart of any Islamic nation and any person in those countries can convert to those religions and live their lives in accordance with those religions (or none whatsoever) without being stoned, hung, or imprisoned. I've often thought this, especially when really angry. But it's not Constitutional and I don't think the necessary amendment stands a snow ball's chance. > Islam, unless it’s stopped, will take over the world simply because it takes but never gives ground (except through force). Spain, Eastern Europe, Russia, Armenia and India all used force. Force can be very good. I'm not familiar with a nation that Muslims took over by missionary work or immigration yet, although Christians have done so repeatedly. There's always a first time, but so far, America seems to be resisting pretty well. I'm not sure about Britain. Yours, Tom
Tom DeGisi
I forgot Thailand in the litany of countries that had sucessfully used force. I apologize to those fierce fighters and capable diplomats, the Thais. IIRC, Thai means free. Yours, Tom
CosmicConservative
Tom, you and I seem to be in more agreement than disagreement here. I don't know why you would be so concerned that I suspect the motives of some of the financiers of the mosque, and my point about the builders operating in direct contradiction to your claim that they are trying to build bridges remains un-rebutted. I am quite comfortable in my accusations that the motivation behind this mosque is in part, and I think in LARGE part, to try to make a statement of the superiority of Islam. You're certainly not going to convince me otherwise with the sorts of arguments you are making here. However, in spite of that, I still say that as long as they bought the land legally and it doesn't violate any zoning laws, they should be able to build it. That's what it means to be a free country.
Tom DeGisi
> You’re certainly not going to convince me otherwise with the sorts of arguments you are making here. There's a reason I keep referring to Ron. Then again, as far as I can remember no one's arguments on the web have ever convinced anyone to change their mind on any political subject. Except mine. Some I have read have changed mine. Maybe even some I've participated in. I have copied some of Ron's post below, since you won't click on a Dean's World link. (Not that you have any reason to grant me this request. And clearly you have multiple good reasons not to do so. Shoot, I might be one. I'm a stubborn cuss. And I can't deny that Dean's World can really take it out of a guy.) Here's what he was criticising: How better to honor the victims of 9/11 than by building a shrine to their murderers at the crime scene? Here's his response: 1. How better to honor the victims: This formulation starts out on the wrong foot, and ispremised on numerous logical fallacies. One is the positing of a false dichotomy or false dilemma: The Islamic Center either honors victims’ memories or dishonors it. But while the Freedom Tower and the Memorial going up at Ground Zero are intended to, among other things, “honor the victims,” but the Islamic Center is not meant to, nor is there any reason it would, “honor the victims.” It is an independent project not related to (albeit woefully insensitive to) 9/11. 2. building a shrine: Again, those of us seeking to “honor the victims” by “building” are not building the Islamic Center. Those who are building the Islamic Center are not seeking to “honor the victims.” Thus the only meaning of this could be that for those forces that are seeking to honor the victims — i.e., “America,” as embodied in government — to permit this exercise of the First Amendment right to freedom of religion is to dishonor the victims. But “America,” axiomatically and by virtue of being “America” — yes, exactly what Mike Bloomberg said, and he’s right, damn it! — has no legal or even lawful way to prevent the people behind the Center from being dumb, insensitive and self-defeating. So the implication that the unnamed actor here is failing properly to “honor” the victims is completely divorced from reality and even internal logic. 3. a shrine to the their murderers: The Islamic Center, and the mosque within it, are shrines to Allah, not to (a) a religion, (b) any particular member of a religion — indeed this would constitute idol worship, which is, to put it lightly, frowned on by Islam — and (c) the 9/11 murderers. 4. their murderers: Focusing in a bit on the last point, the implication here, and this really was the point of my post, is that the “shrine” that is “the mosque” is meant to glorify “Islam,” and hence Muslims. That is illogical, and false, enough. But the next step is the most insidious one: Even accepting this preposterous math, you must then go to two more steps and say, “To glorify ‘Muslims’ in general is to glorify, therefore, all Muslims who have ever acted in the name of Islam to do wrong and thus to glorify their crimes.” This is not only idiotically unsupportable as an argument, it implies the horrible corollary that all Muslims are guilty of the crimes of any Muslims– and deserve punishment (starting with excision from civil rights) for them. 5. at the crime scene: It’s located two blocks away from Ground Zero. Yes, that’s close. But if it were four blocks away, would that be better? Eight? What exactly is the appropriate distance for insensitivity-based suspension of the Constitution? Here's your formulation: > It’s a deliberate attempt to co-opt the location as an icon for Islamic jihad. It’s a way for Islamists to claim victory over America. Now Ron clearly agrees with you and I about the Constitution. And all three of us think the builders are wrong. And your formulation about the motives of the builders is not the same as the one given. But they are similar. Since I agree with Ron about the offending tweet, I am concerned about the similarity. I don't really have any heat behind this, CC, because I don't have the energy right now to tear apart your formulation and see if it suffers the same defects. However, I think this explains why I am concerned. Particularly since this was the mildest part of Ron's post. Perhaps later I'll be more energetic. Yours, Tom
Tom DeGisi
Besides which, I'm a Royals fan and a Cheifs fan. How can I possibly comment on your Rockies and Broncos posts? I can tell the truth like this: My teams peak during spring training and the preseason. That sounds like sour grapes. Or I could be optimistic. That sounds silly. Yours, Tom
CosmicConservative
Here is Ron's weakest, of several weak, arguments: "their murderers: Focusing in a bit on the last point, the implication here, and this really was the point of my post, is that the “shrine” that is “the mosque” is meant to glorify “Islam,” and hence Muslims. That is illogical, and false, enough. But the next step is the most insidious one: Even accepting this preposterous math, you must then go to two more steps and say, “To glorify ‘Muslims’ in general is to glorify, therefore, all Muslims who have ever acted in the name of Islam to do wrong and thus to glorify their crimes.” This is not only idiotically unsupportable as an argument, it implies the horrible corollary that all Muslims are guilty of the crimes of any Muslims– and deserve punishment (starting with excision from civil rights) for them." Not only is it completely logical to suggest that the mosque's intent is to "glorify Islam" that is in fact it's fundamental and obvious purpose. That's what churches/synogogues/mosques ARE. That's what they DO. That's why they EXIST. Ron's next fallacious leap off the top floor of the edifice of logic is to say that if the first "formulation" (that a mosque glorifies Islam) is correct, then it must glorify every crime ever committed in the name of Islam. This is so brazenly stupid that it amazes me a human being with Ron's brainpower could type it. The question isn't whether every mosque ever built anywhere on earth by nature MUST glorify every crime committed in the name of Islam, the question on most Americans' minds is "Why here? Why now? What connection could possibly be made with this location?" And the answer is pretty clear and pretty chilling. Sure YOU say "oh, that's just paranoia." Well, sometimes they really are out to get you Tom. His final point saying that to accuse one Muslim of bad intent is to accuse all Muslims of being evil isn't worthy of rejoinder. I remain unconvinced by the lickspittle level of argument Ron has presented here.
Drax
Tom: Where, exactly, are these "moderate" Muslims? Indonesia? Standing up for those killed, raped, maimed by the "radicals?" Nah. Few and scattered voices amongst the millions of silent "moderates." Africa? Standing up for those killed, raped, mutilated over there? Nah. Another few and scattered voices, mostly from the relatively safe haven of "civilized" nations. Middle East? Searching, searching, searching....Nah...not there either. No. What you'll find, for the most part, are so-called "moderate" APOLOGISTS for Islam who just want those in NON-CONQUERED countries to accept (tolerate) the further expansion of this "religion" to the extent that they want THEIR barbaric "culture" to TRUMP the laws of their adopted land, said barbaric "culture" accepting of the enslavement of women, honor killings, mutilations, trial by clergy under "laws" set forth 1500 years ago. Yet, once they have taken over a country, unless the country is taken BACK, it becomes a MUSLIM country, governed by THEOCRATS, enslaving women, etc. etc. etc. And, they want to EXPAND HERE. Screw 'em. Have no use for 'em. It's a barbaric religion as written and as practiced. Once we have "moderates" who actually allow for actual equality and freedom for all their citizens in MUSLIM STATES, I'll start believing that there's such a thing as a "moderate" Muslim when he has the POWER to be otherwise. Ain't happened yet. Ain't gonna happen. This is a WAR between Islam and the civilized world. Unless we understand that, have the balls to say that out loud, and take action based on that understanding, WE ARE GOING TO LOSE that war.
CosmicConservative
Drax, no doubt Tom would tell you that you are exhibiting precisely the sort of anti-Muslim, prejudicial behavior that leads to cultural division and exacerbates the problem. Obama would no doubt point to your attitude here and say that you are demagogueing the issue. Even Sarah Palin would probably caution you to avoid lumping all Muslims in the "barbaric" category. They all have a point, but it's a point that has lost most of its purpose as the years go by and the Muslim nations of the world continue to demonstrate no real desire or intention to "reform" Islam. Islam in general remains what many of its critics call it, a barbaric, thirteenth century religion characterized by a propensity towards violence against every other religion (or lack of religion), violence against women, violence against gays, violence against children, violence against those who criticize or question Islam, and frankly, violence against reason and rationality itself. While there is a small contingent of noteworthy Muslims who seem intent on throwing off the medieval shackles of Islam, their voices are barely heard against the crashing cacophany of roadside bombs, honor killings, car burnings, suicide bombers and rocket fire into Israel. I acctually very much like the idea of putting a moratorium on authorizing the building of any mosque in the United States until Islam allows the free construction of churches, synogogues and cathedrals in Mecca. Of course that's not going to happen, but it drives home a very valid point. If Muslims truly want to demonstrate their desire to "build bridges" to the rest of the world, let's start with ending the practice of criminalizing the construction of competing places of worship in all Muslim countries. If that's not going to happen, then I won't lose any sleep if it turns out that we refuse to allow a mosque to be built in close proximity to ground zero. Or anywhere else for that matter.
Tom DeGisi
CC, > Not only is it completely logical to suggest that the mosque’s intent is to “glorify Islam” that is in fact it’s fundamental and obvious purpose. That’s what hurches/synogogues/mosques ARE. That’s what they DO. That’s why they EXIST. You misread what he wrote. Key phrase is "the mosque” is meant to glorify “Islam,” and hence Muslims." Ron was saying that it was illogical to say the mosque was built to glorify Muslims. > The question isn’t whether every mosque ever built anywhere on earth by nature MUST glorify every crime committed in the name of Islam, the question on most Americans’ minds is “Why here? Why now? What connection could possibly be made with this location?” And the answer is pretty clear and pretty chilling. This is a really good point. > His final point saying that to accuse one Muslim of bad intent is to accuse all Muslims of being evil isn’t worthy of rejoinder. He's arguing against that idea, CC, not making that point. Did you get disgusted and start skimming? Drax, Most of the things you are saying are easy to support with good evidence. > Where, exactly, are these “moderate” Muslims? The ones I'm talking about are all over the planet. But they are mainly protecting their own interests, like booze and porn. They don't really care about Christians or Jews or the classical liberal emphasis on protecting our liberties. The problem is that our interests and theirs don't perfectly align. In one important case they are diametrically opposite because they tend to be quite disgustingly bigotted against Jews. > governed by THEOCRATS Now this just isn't true. They are governed mainly by Socialists, Fascists and other assorted autocrats with a thin Islamic veneer, most of whom don't appear to practice Islam very rigorously. Some of them increase the thickness of the Islamic veneer. Iran seems to have the only functioning theocracy. CC, > Drax, no doubt Tom would tell you that you are exhibiting precisely the sort of anti-Muslim, prejudicial behavior that leads to cultural division and exacerbates the problem. No, actually I think Drax is admirably like Arnold Harris or Francis Porretto. Those, like Dean, who denigrate those members of the great American middle who want to defend our land, our people, our way of life and our ideas and who are properly concerned about Islam itself are being particularly dense due to an over emphasis on tolerance. They (but not Dean) had the same problem with anti-Communists, and this one is exacerbated by our very proper defense of religious freedom. This is hard, because I tend to an over emphasis on tolerance myself. I also had a rather automatic reaction to the phrase "deluded fool". And I like arguing. I still want to treat Muslims fairly by making ethical arguements. I don't like conspiracy theories that sound suspiciously like the blood libel. > I acctually very much like the idea of putting a moratorium on authorizing the building of any mosque in the United States until Islam allows the free construction of churches, synogogues and cathedrals in Mecca. I prefer a moratorium on immigration of natives from countries with a Muslim population over 60% until all Palestianians have been moved out of Gaza and the West Bank and given land and citizenship in other Muslim countries. It would be Constitutional. Or come up with another useful demand. Any religious tie ins would be unconstitutional. Yours, Tom
Tom DeGisi
BTW, a lot of the problem with Islam is that people graft nationalism (and lots of other things) onto religion and start using religion to justify and promote those things. See this non-Dean's World thread and work your way down if, it interests you. It is a side discussion, but the whole thread is good. The really bad part is that all the ancient tribalist junk that was grafted onto Islam gets dragged along for the ride. Frankly, I don't see how Islam is going to become tolerable until there are a big chunk of liberal Muslim theologians who treat the Koran (and other holy writings) and Mohammed like liberal Christian theologians do - so the Koran is not true and Mohammed is mainly a fictional or legendary character. Yours, Tom
CosmicConservative
Tom: Yes, I did get pretty disgusted with Ron's "logic." But I still think my rebuttal was on point. First, Ron may be saying that it is "illogical" to say that a mosque glorifies Muslims. He's dead wrong. In fact this is just one of many egregious logical fallacies and downright inaccurate statements Ron makes, each using his previous error as a launching pad to further push his argument into the realm of absurdity while desperately trying to make his argument seem rational by invoking the word "logic" as if merely saying it will make it so. What Ron is attempting to do here is set up a straw man and then claim that his "logic" knocks it down. I don't accept that the straw man he is setting up is anything but his own imagination. But even if the straw man were real, I don't think Ron's argument knocks it down.
Drax
Tom: I agree that "Theocrats" was imprecise. Rather "supposed Theocrats" who use religion to control the masses while not adhering (in the main) to the tenents of the religion they use to shackle their own people -- whether the governing principles are fascism or socialism or simple tyranny. It is the masses' willing "submission to the will of Allah" as set forth by those "theocrats" which allows for the continued subjugation of those same masses. Much in the way the Catholic church subjugated the masses of nations (in its own name and through the heads of nations who were either fully submissive to the Church or, were using the Church for their own purposes, or were simply bowing to the power of the Church -- Islam is an enemy of the very people who submit to its will, and, until those same masses shake off those religious shackles (as did the masses of Christians over the centuries) and decide that the "word of God" as set forth by man in the holy works isn't subject to be FAITHFULLY taught (and therefore followed) by MAN, and must be internalized to individual compasses, Islam will REMAIN a scourge on the face of the Earth.
CosmicConservative
Tom, either I didn't read your last paragraph, or else you added it while I was working on my last post, but I think you've pretty much nailed the issue. What your last paragraph means is that Islam is still a medieval religion, and until it allows for rational thought, analysis and criticism, it will remain a medieval religion. What Drax and I are saying is that there is precious little that we've seen indicating that Muslims in general, or more specifically, Muslim LEADERS in general, have any desire to allow rational thought, analysis and criticism into their religion. For the most part they appear to be quite happy with it as it is.
Tom DeGisi
> What Drax and I are saying is that there is precious little that we’ve seen indicating that Muslims in general, or more specifically, Muslim LEADERS in general, have any desire to allow rational thought, analysis and criticism into their religion. For the most part they appear to be quite happy with it as it is. When you are on top, why change the supporting belief structure that got you there? This one is going to have to come from the bottom, as a mass movement. This is hard, because the leaders in question have been very successful at suppressing mass movements. Unfortuneately the Muslim terroristic rebels who arise almost like clockword every forty years has given the leaders a lot of practice at suppressing movements. Caught in between are Muslims in general, who have a lot of practice keeping their heads down. Ataturk came so close though. Yours, Tom