Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Best movie fight scenes, one on one

By CosmicConservative
So I was doing something I rarely do anymore tonight and was randomly surfing the net, following link to link, and among the sites I hit was one that supposedly rated the top ten 1 on 1 fight scenes in movie history. Of course, as with most such things, the list was dominated by recent action movie fights. Here are some candidates for best one-on-one hero/protagonist fight scenes in movie history. I won't rate them, we'll start with just a list.
  • Luke Skywalker vs. Darth Vader - This is really an extended fight that ranged over two movies, reaching the final climax when Luke defeats Vader as the Emperor watches. Although the choreography is somewhat lacking compared to today's fight scenes, the energy and emotion of the fight was palpable. And don't even talk about "save the world" consequences of the fight, this fight had the future of an entire GALAXY on the line.
  • Rick Deckard vs. Roy Batty - How do you top a fight scene where the "villain" spouts literary quotations and calmly discusses the philosophy of life and death?
  • The Black Knight vs. King Arthur - 'nuff said
  • Wesley vs. Inigo Montoya - "Why are you smiling?"
  • Rocky Balboa vs. Apollo Creed - Yes, the first movie was a masterpiece, and this was its climactic fight. Notably, this is probably the only one where the protagonist did not win.
  • Legalos vs. the Oliphant - Pure poetry in motion.
  • The Good vs. The Bad vs. The Ugly - OK, so this was either really The Good vs. The Bad, or it was a one-on-one-on-one. Still gunfight scenes are hard to make last more than five seconds, but this masterpiece of dramatic tension probably took five minutes.
  • Neo vs. Agent Smith - techno-god vs. spirit-god with the fate of humanity hanging in the balance.
Add your own favorites to the list. I'll probably think up some more.

Comments (23)

CosmicConservative
King Kong vs the planes wouldn't be a 1 on 1 fight. King Kong vs the tyrannosaur would qualify though. I tried to come up with a good 1 on 1 dogfight scene but just couldn't come up with one. I also thought about Kirk vs Khan, or at least the Enterprise vs Khan's stolen ship. Bruce Lee vs Kareem Abdul Jabaar also came to mind, but I'm not really a big fan of martial arts movies. I stayed away from superhero movies, but of those I'd probably pick the Spidey vs Dock Ock fight, where Spidey had to save a speeding train. I also thought about Bond vs Bambi & Thumper, but that's not really 1 on 1. I probably should have put Terminator vs Terminator on the list.
Dadman
Aragorn vs. Lurtz at the end of 'The Fellowship of the Ring'...and Ripley vs. the Alien at the end of 'Aliens'.
Cullen
Bruce Lee vs. Chuck Norris in Way of the Dragon.
CosmicConservative
I considered Aragorn vs Lurtz but decided to go with Legalos/Oliphant as my LOTR entry. Sam/Shelob was another LOTR fight I considered. Ripley/Alien is on every list I've seen, so my deliberate excluding of it was due to my anti-alien bias and my lack of appreciation of Sigourney Weaver as an actress. Some I considered but decided against: Rance Stoddard/Liberty Valance (decided against because it wasn't clear if Tom Donephan actually shot Liberty). Dutch Schaefer/Predator (too contrived) Dirty Harry/Scorpio (on reflection, I probably should have included). One I think belongs on the list: Hi McDunnough/Leonard Smalls (awesome ending)
CosmicConservative
Never seen any Bruce Lee movies. I've never gotten into the martial arts stuff. However, Bruce Lee vs Chuck Norris sure sounds like it belongs on the list.
Dadman
I've never seen any of these lists so my inclusion of the Ripley vs. Alien fight scene is based purely on the effectiveness of the scene rather than a built-in bias. The scene was exciting, suspenseful, and extremely well-crafted...imho. Also, you may or may not be aware that the Lurtz vs. Aragorn fight scene is lengthened in the extended version of 'The Fellowship of the Ring' improving it in a couple of simple, yet significant, ways. Ultimately, Lurtz vs. Aragorn is a very personal, in-your-face kind of battle that underscores the strength and mania of the Uruk-Hai. It's one of my favorite sequences in the entire LOTR trilogy...
CosmicConservative
I would agree that Aragorn/Lurtz is a more visceral and personal battle than Legalos/Oliphant, which probably should replace L/O based on that basis alone. It's a good scene. My only marginal issue with the fight is that there really wasn't any buildup of the conflict between the two, they just sort of meet and fight. Perhaps that's better in the extended edition. The Saruman/Gandalf "wizard-fu" fight deserves some mention here, even though it never remotely happened in the book. I suppose we're exhibiting unintentional genderism here since I haven't listed any female/female fights...
Tom DeGisi
I second Hi McDunnough/Leonard Smalls. Yours, Tom
staylor
For The Princess Bride a would be tempted to change the best fight scene from Wesley vs. Inigo to Inigo vs. Count Rugen the Six Fingered Man. Yes, W vs. I fight has better choreography and some some great one liners; but the I vs. CR fight was the culmination of a life long quest for revenge and was far more viseral emotionally. "Hallo. My name Inigo Montoya. You killed my father, prepare to die!"
CosmicConservative
It's a tough call between the I/W and I/C fight in TPB. I like them both. The first is more light-hearted, the second is more serious. Both have great choreography. I like the banter in the first fight better. I suppose "my name is Inigo Montoya. You killed my father. Prepare to die." is much more memorable than "I know something you do not know. I am not left handed!" But both are pretty memorable.
Dadman
I like the banter between Lurtz and Aragorn. ;)
Dadman
Another scene comes to mind... It's the fight to the death scene between Pvt. Stanley Mellish (Adam Goldberg) and an unnamed German in 'Saving Private Ryan'. The scene is over-the-top, squirm-inducing visceral and results in the death Mellish. It's tough, gut-wrenching scene to watch, but extrememly well-choreographed and gritty. It's almost too real.
CosmicConservative
Dadman, I managed to catch a portion of Saving Private Ryan during a Showtime free weekend on Direct TV and I saw that scene. Very gut-wrenching. Other lists have included that scene in their "best of" fight scenes. I didn't include it because I didn't watch the whole movie and so had no real idea of the context of the death of Mellish.
Dadman
It's hard to believe you haven't seen SPR from beginning to end. If you like cinema you've got to experience the battle sequences Speilberg created for this film. They are stunning and the most evocative battle scenes I've ever seen at the movies. They quite literally knock the wind out of you... BTW, I honestly haven't seen any of these 'Best of' fight scene lists, but I'm pleased to learn my assessment is in line with other movie fans - both professional and amateur (I suppose).
CosmicConservative
Well, I don't remember any of them listing the Aragorn/Lurtz scene, for whatever that's worth. :) One did list the Oliphant scene, and one listed the wizard-fu scene. Most lists are actually "fight scenes" not "one on one fight scenes" and the LOTR scenes that get mentioned are usually Helms Deep and the Siege of Gondor. FWIW I liked the Helms Deep scene more both in the book and in the movie. I'm surprised nobody has mentioned the fight scene in "Raging Bull". I didn't mention it because I haven't seen the movie, but that's a very frequently mentioned scene. The one on one fight scene with the highest general listing was the Luke/Vader fight scene.
CosmicConservative
... Actually another one-on-one fight scene from LOTR that I really liked was the Gandalf/Balrog scene, even if it was only presented as a sort of dream sequence at the start of the Two Towers. I loved the long distance view of the two combatants falling into the depths as the Balrog's flame illuminated the scene. And Gandalf willing himself to fall faster in order to catch the plummeting Glamdring and then engaging the Balrog in mortal combat as they fell..... Pretty cool stuff.
Cosmic Daughter
I was waiting for the Gandolf vs. Balrog to come up. That was an epic battle. I hope Harry vs Voldemort will be worthy of praise since it's been built through seven books and eight films. Eowyn versus the Witch King was awesome too. Alice versus the Jabberwocky, Jack Sparrow versus Barbosa, and Wolverine versus Dead Pool. Those are all I can think of for now.
CosmicConservative
CD, I may have to do another post on general fight scenes. Actual one-on-one fights are pretty rare in the movies. The Eowyn/WK fight, for example, was decided when Merry stabbed the WK from behind with his magic dagger, which allowed Eowyn to deliver the mortal blow. The Harry Potter vs Voldemort fight is also not a one-on-one fight, it's part of a much larger battle. But regardless of that, if the movie has a halfway decent fight scene it will have to depart significantly from the book since JK Rowlings can't write a decent fight scene to save her billion dollar bank account. The Wolverine fight that gets the most attention in the lists I've seen was Wolverine vs Deathstrike, the woman with adamantium claws coming from her fingers.
ASEI
Hmm, the Luke vs Vader fighting always struck me as perhipheral to the larger conflict. Certainly important on a personal level for the main characters, but largely irrelevant to the war.
CosmicConservative
ASEI, the Luke/Vader conflict was the key to the war, that's one of the main themes of the series. Without Luke's supernatural abilities, the rebellion would have been squashed on Tatooine in the first movie. The whole point of the Luke/Vader conflict was who would control the fate of the galaxy into the future. The emperor had clearly begun to lose faith in Darth Vader. His plan was to corrupt Luke and replace Vader with Luke as his Sith Lord accomplice to continue his rule for generations to come. Vader was beginning to have dreams of replacing the Emperor with Luke as his junior partner. While Luke himself may not have shown signs of being power-hungry, the reality is according to the Star Wars Canon that Luke became the leader of the reborn Jedi order, and it was the Jedi order that truly ruled the galaxy, which meant Luke essentially became the (hopefully benevolent) ruler of the galaxy after the rebellion was successful. So the actual stakes of the Luke vs Vader fight were no less than the determination of the ruler of the galaxy for generations to come. It was actually the "larger battle" that was truly mostly irrelevant.