Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

One for SCOTUS to rule on

By CosmicConservative
A federal judge has ruled in favor of a public university that removed a Christian student from its graduate program in school counseling over her belief that homosexuality is morally wrong. Monday's ruling, according to Julea Ward's attorneys, could result in Christian students across the country being expelled from public university for similar views. via FOXNews.com - Court Upholds Expulsion of Counseling Student Who Opposes Homosexuality.
So, I'm not a hardcore social conservative. I frankly don't care a lot about people's sexual orientation. I figure I've got more important things to worry about than what two grown people do behind closed doors. But expelling a student who has a religious belief that homosexuality is morally wrong sure seems to fit in the category of religious prejudice. My guess is that today's SCOTUS would overturn this on a 5-4 ruling. Let Obama replace a Scalia or a Kennedy on the bench, and that would become a 5-4 confirmation of the lower court ruling. Now, the real test of this would be for a school to expel a MUSLIM for the same belief. Think that's gonna happen? Not in this lifetime.

Comments (6)

pace
Technically, they expelled her for refusing to participate in a remediation / diversity-awareness program. A subtle point, maybe. She reportedly initially agreed to attend the remediation sessions, then refused after further consideration. Honestly, I couldn't give much of a hoot either way. But if I were a homosexual needing counseling related to sexual abuse or discrimination, I certainly wouldn't be thrilled at being assigned a counselor who believed my sexuality to be 'morally wrong'. One hopes though that the counselor would remove themselves from such a situation and have the patient assigned to someone else if they were not able to treat them appropriately.
Andy
Cosmic, I have been reading about this case/suit over the last couple of days. It's muddy. Pace kinda typed some of my thoughts, somewhat. My knee jerk reaction was to be ticked off. But, the more I've thought about it, the muddier the whole situation seems. I don't really believe that the young lady (Who is quite attractive btw. Just sayin'...) was really told that she had to give up her Christian beliefs on homosexuality. Actually, I need to go back and read some of the articles to make sure of that. But, it seems to me that the requirements of her graduate program would have been something she should have known about...or at least anticipated. Gotta go back and read those articles again. It's muddy.
CosmicConservative
pace, I more or less agree with you on this, but I'm worried that such an approach essentially closes certain career paths for people of strong religious faith. Should that hold true for a psychologist or a psychiatrist? Do we need to have all people who provide "counseling" to explicitly list their religious convictions so that people can decide whether they want to see them? Is it possible that a person with a religious conviction that homosexuality is a sin could still provide solid counseling to a person seeking help? Is it necessary that such counseling would be to refrain from homosexual activity? What about the reverse? Should a homosexual have to divulge their sexual preferences if they are providing counseling to the general public and therefore end up with fundamentalist Christian patients?
Drax
Heh, "strong religious faith..." Ain't "homosexuality is a sin" Christianity 101?
CosmicConservative
Whether something is "Christianity 101" or not has very little to do with the average Christian follows that particular dogma. "Turn the other cheek" is certainly "Christianity 101" but I don't know many Christians who follow that either.
Andy
Cosmic, my Great Uncle Clifton was a psychiatrist that graduated from Baylor. He got his PhD at CU in Boulder, though. (I think...could have been Purdue, because he went to both after Baylor) He actually went back to academia, and was the Chancellor at Baylor when he retired. I have visited with him (really more like listened to him) about subjects similar to this. The whole subject is so murky. But, what I come away thinking is that any "professional" should be able to put religious convictions aside to do their job...if they are presenting themselves as a secular professional. There are thousands of Counseling Services/Clinics, etc. that make no bones about the fact that they counsel from a Christian/Biblical perspective. And, there are many dozens of Masters/Doctorate degree programs available for Christians to enter at accredited Christian Universities and Colleges in this field. I'm not saying that this young lady was not done wrong. I AM saying that she should have known what to expect going in.