Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The Case for God

By CosmicConservative
Everyone knows that I am a firmly committed agnostic when it comes to theology, but on occasion I entertain the arguments for and against the existence of a supreme deity that created the universe and all that is in it. Today, as I was preparing and eating my breakfast I think I hit upon the strongest argument yet for the existence of God. Fresh-picked, fist-sized strawberries.

Comments (12)

staylor
Don't forget beer. "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy." Benjamin Franklin
Dadman
Everyone knows!? Wow, that's a lot of people. ;)
Reggie Wooster
"I believe in Christianity as I believe that the sun has risen: not only because I see it, but because by it I see everything else." C. S. Lewis
Dadman
Strawberry Growth Hormone is a wonderful thing...
Andy
Pal, I ate enough strawberries this afternoon to make the red man red. God is GOOD!
Drax
Yeah? So, explain chocolate. Or, better yet... Chocolate covered strawberries...
CosmicConservative
One thing I've sort of idly wondered about over the years is how much impact on human cultural evolution our culinary desires themselves have had. I'm sure there are a lot of doctoral dissertations on the subject, but I've never done any research on the subject. I suspect that the prevailing notion among anthropologists has been that humans began cultivating food out of a sheer desire to stave off hunger. But I'm not so sure about that. Even into the modern day hunter-gatherer cultures have lived with relative ease. In the area that is presumed to be the birth of civilization (Mesopotamia) food was then quite plentiful. So I can't help but wonder whether the actual urge to cultivate crops came not from hunger, but from a desire to have a ready supply of succulent vegetables without the necessity to search far and wide for a particular favorite, and then have to carefully remove noxious weeds and vermin that tend to accumulate in the wild. Think about how important eating is to humans today. In virtually all important respects humans of today are no different than humans of 250,000 years ago. Maybe our entire agricultural civilization grew out of one person's desire to have tastier dinners.
Drax
I'm of a different mind. Of course... See... People are inherently lazy. Just like every animal is. We don't work, as a general rule, except that we must. (And, those who enjoy their "work" ain't "working...") Thus, while food is plentiful, it would be a difficult task, indeed, for a leader to force his tribe to start a garden. Why do that? What possible purpose is served by CREATING work which doesn't need be done? Except, maybe, getting yourself cracked over the skull whilst sleeping??? Nah... what happened is more likely that the food WAS plentiful and, therefore, children were born and food became LESS plentiful. But, there was always more food "over there" somewhere along the nomadic path traveled for untold generations. Until it became too far to walk, since, you know, I figured out how to make more of what we want to eat... Here. And, hey! Instead of having "this" for a while and "that" for a while as we travel along the nomadic path (this is assuming that they are landlocked rather than fishermen...), if we do a bit of work now (and here) we can have both "this" and "that" here (but later). And, hey! Since we won't be picking up stakes every month or so, we can build permanent shelters! Close to water! In a defensible place! Etc. Etc. Necessity is the mother of invention...then and now.
CosmicConservative
Drax, I would say that's probably the "consensus view" of anthropologists (not having actually researched the consensus view) but I'm not sure I buy it. Humans are lazy, except when driven by some powerful desire. I am wondering how powerful the desire for tasty food is. In today's world it's pretty dang powerful, routinely ranked second to sex in a person's desires.
Drax
I could argue... Nomadic tribe has stop-n-go's at several places in the course of their nomadic wanderings. They eat "this" here and "that" there and "some other thing" elsewhere. And... One (or more) of the tribe likes "this" much better than "that" and hates the necessity of leaving "this" for "that" and has the bright idea of bring "this" from "there" and see if it will grow "here." Here, I could easily agree that necessity could have nothing to do with invention. Little work would be required in the beginning (drop some carried seeds from "there" into the desired "here...") So...I could buy it...
CosmicConservative
I doubt the "necessity is the mother of invention" argument holds up to scrutiny for this case or in general. It's simply a platitude, not a rule or a law of nature. "Necessity" did not lead to any of the recognized great breakthrough inventions of history, those were accomplished by visionaries who saw a different way of life, not hungry, desperate individuals trying to claw their way out of starvation or despair. In fact I would be willing to bet that you could prove that the more "needy" a culture is, the less inventive it is. It is far more likely that invention is the result of leisure time and opportunity rather than "necessity." I'm just speculating here, but I suspect I'm onto something. I find it far more likely that early humans began planting certain crops because they liked them than because they felt a need for a permanent supply of food they could store in yet-uninvented granaries. Planting what they liked came first. Storing the excess of their harvest was likely an unintended positive consequence. Just my theory. I should write a paper and submit it to Nature....
Drax
I must agree. "Necessity is the mother of invention" is a truism which is less "true" and more "ism..." I also agree that most inventions throughout time were not created of necessity but through desire or simple curiosity (or accident). To support this assertion, I merely point backwards in time to all points existing prior to the (any/whichever) invention and say: "We didn't need it before as we've existed for thousands of years without it heretofore!" Thus fire...we didn't "need" fire. We had lived for thousands of years (generations?) prior to the "discovery" of fire. Yet, once the supply is created -- thus, too, the demand. Thus the wheel...again, no "need" for such, but once the supply is created/harnessed, follows, then, the demand. Car, computer, telephone...doesn't matter. Plug in the invention. Recognize that, prior to its invention, there was no "need" for it. Follow its creation (the supply) with a subsequent creation of a demand. Of course, there are some inventions which are created to fill a "need" (whether or not there is a demand). I submit many medicines, tools created specifically to perform a needed function and which do not yet exist, etc. But, in the main, I agree. Most inventions are simply created through desire, curiosity, or accident, then, if they are desired by the rest of those who come into contact with it, a demand soon follows.