Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Writing analyzer

By CosmicConservative
Over at Andy's Place he has a link to a writing analysis web page that supposedly tells you whom you write like. I did it three times with posts from this blog, here are the results: From my "true life story" about the alligator staredown:

I Write Like by Mémoires, Mac journal software. Analyze your writing!

From my "Toy Story 3" review:
I write like
Stephen King

I Write Like by Mémoires, Mac journal software. Analyze your writing!

And from my post on the fellow who demonstrated plausible means for ancient workers to move and build with huge blocks of stone, I got this:
I write like
Dan Brown

I Write Like by Mémoires, Mac journal software. Analyze your writing!

I find it particularly hilarious that my movie review of a child's animated movie reads like Steven King. In the end I think this is like most such website analysis sites, a bunch of bunk.

Comments (13)

JSullins
I think you should craft an article specifically to see if you can get the site to say you write like "Dr. Seuss"
CosmicConservative
Based on these results, I think you could do that if you wrote anything that included "green eggs and ham" or "sneetches." I came out as RLS on the first attempt because my writing included lakes, boats, fishing and alligators. I came out as SK on my second attempt because I wrote about toys and other childhood things, along with some more adult sounding words. And I came out as Dan Brown because I wrote about technical things and had some vaguely scientific sounding technical jargon in the piece. I'm convinced that 90% of the analysis is based entirely on content, and that actual "style" is barely looked at.
Andy
Let me go try another one with much different content. Will report back.
Andy
Okay, a remembrance of a dear friend, and the report of her funeral... My review of Pam's pie she made... Still Stephen King. I'm 5 for 5.
CosmicConservative
I think the site is just a ploy to steal people's writing ideas.
Andy
Nyuk! I pasted Christ's Sermon On The Mount, and got the result Douglas Adams.
CosmicConservative
I pasted in the first page of "Moby Dick" by Herman Melville and got back "Robert Louis Stephenson" which supports my theory that if it has nature, animals and elements in them, that's what you get. I pasted in the first page of "Siddartha" by Herman Hesse and got back "James Joyce." I pasted in the first page of "A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court" by Mark Twain (Samuel Clemens) and got back "Kurt Vonnegut". I pasted in the first page of "Frankenstein" by Mary Shelley and got back "Vladimir Nabokov". Like I said, a total waste.
Andy
A total waste??? Yep! That's what I specialize in...
CosmicConservative
lol... Well, perhaps not a "total waste". I suppose it qualifies as a harmless diversion from my current work effort which requires searching through page after page of resource requests and contacting resource managers to see if projects can begin assigning tasks and dates to their plans... Yeah, thinking of it that way, the writing analyzer was pure candy and ice cream.
Andy
Heh! One more, and I'll quit bugging you. I pasted the first page of "Green Eggs and Ham" in to the analyzer. Result: Raymond Chandler. From his wiki page: "Anglo-American novelist and screenwriter who had an immense stylistic influence upon the modern private detective story, especially in the style of the writing and the attitudes now characteristic of the genre. His protagonist, Philip Marlowe, is, along with Dashiell Hammett's Sam Spade, considered synonymous with "private detective", both being played by Humphrey Bogart." Yeah...
Dadman
I did this 'analyzer' with two different writing samples and was pegged as H.P. Lovecraft and Chuck Palahnuik. In the first writing sample I mention ghosts, ectoplasm, etc., hence H.P. My 'Ascent of Obamalot' post from 2008 was tagged as Chuck. Not sure why...