U.S.A. Republic no more?
By CosmicConservativeI've been thinking about how to comment on the great concern I feel over the recent Hamdan decision from the Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS). I don't think it is possible to overstate how potentially damaging to the President's powers to lead the nation's wartime operations I think this is.
On the surface of it the decision is damaging enough. Basically it says that we have to treat terrorists and murderers as lawful combatants according to the rules of the Geneva Convention, even though the very purpose of the Geneva Conventions was to separate lawful combatants from unlawful ones. This is essentially saying that the United States has to play by one set of rules, while our enemies operate with no rules whatsoever.
It is hard to understand how such learned men could somehow not realize that treating unlawful combatants as lawful ones actually undercuts the very goals of the Geneva Convention. The purpose of the Geneva Convention was not to protect the rights of prisoners, but instead it was to encourage warring combatants to operate according to the generally accepted rules of war by promising them that if they DID, then their armies would be treated with respect and honor in return for demonstrating respect and honor in their own actions.
In other words, the Geneva Conventions were designed to PROTECT CIVILIANS from being used as human shields, human hostages, or genocide during wartime. It describes the responsibilities of armed combatants to wear uniforms precisely because doing so protects civilians.
By asserting that we have to treat terrorist murderers who routinely murder civilians and use them as human sheilds as though they were lawful combatants, this decision effectively tells our enemies "Hey, if you are fighting the United States, you don't have to abide by the Geneva Conventions yourselves, but they will! It is a free pass to commit atrocities by the bushel load, and then scream for protection as soon as they are caught.
So that's bad enough. But the real problem with Hamdan is that it provides a fulcrum to undercut virtually any Presidential decision in wartime. It effectively turns the process of running a war from a Presidential perogative, into a "decision by committee" where the President does not dare to implement any program or significant decision unless he has the agreement of Congress beforehand. This is precisely why the United States threw out the Articles of the Confederation and adopted the current Constitution.
A Constitution that our current SCOTUS must have read, but seems unable to comprehend.
Welcome to the Oligarchy of Judges, previously known as the U.S. of A.
Comments (0)
No comments on this post.