Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Cloth vs. Disposable diapers

By CosmicConservative
Back when the Cosmic Wife and I were going through the birth of the Cosmic Daughter, I had a discussion with our doctor about the benefits of cloth vs. disposable diapers. To my surprise my doctor was adamant that disposable diapers were healthier for the baby. In her mind there was simply no debate on the issue. Since the prevailing narrative at that time (and to this day) was that cloth diapers were a superior environmental choice, I decided to check into the environmental impact to see if there was any compelling reason to put my daughter's health at risk (the risk primarily being increased diaper rash and minor infections of various sorts, as well as the potential spreading of various diseases through leaky diapers). So I looked into the major environmental impacts that disposable diapers were supposed to cause. At that time the major opposition to diapers from hard-core "environmentalists" was that diapers were filling up landfills at an alarming rate, and that we would soon run out of landfill space if we didn't stop using disposable diapers. There was also the claim that entire forests were being wiped out by disposable diapers and that the creation of them produced chemical toxins that were poisoning the earth. Well, it turned out when I examined the actual data around disposable diapers that each of these claims ended up being seriously over-stated by environmentalists and the actual environmental impact of diapers was vastly less than the hype being spewed over the national airwaves. In fact, in a bit of delicious irony, the production and distribution of just the newspapers alone which were spreading this disinformation was several orders of magnitude more than the disposable diapers themselves. In fact, not only were newspapers, phone books and magazines creating thousands of times more landfill waste in bulk and by weight, but disposable diapers actually biodegraded much more rapidly than newspapers and magazines. Also virtually all disposable diapers were produced using the same pulp tree-farm techniques that were used to create paper, and the amount of wood harvested to produce paper in its various forms was tens of thousands of times as much wood as that used to produce disposable diapers. And, as it turned out, the chemical byproducts of diaper production were similarly comparable in quality, but vastly less in quantity, to that which the paper and ink industry turned out. In other words an average daily newspaper was far more impactful to the environment than the average box of diapers. And the more I looked into cloth diapers the more I discovered the environmental impact of cloth diapers was vastly underrated by these same "environmentalists." The production of the cloth itself required the planting and harvesting of cotton, a product that is vastly less efficient than the planting and harvesting of wood products. In other words an acre of pine trees produces thousands of times more raw material suitable for creating a diaper than does an acre of cotton. So each cloth diaper had a comparable impact to the environment of thousands of disposable diapers, just in the area of land, the irrigation and fertilization of the croplands. Croplands that routinely lost tons of topsoil through erosion and plowing, compared to the minimal loss of topsoil to tree-harvesting processes. And then there was the problem of cleaning the cloth diapers. No matter what process you use, cleaning a cloth diaper introduces chemicals to the environment, and to clean them thoroughly requires bleach, which is one of the most environmentally damaging chemicals there is. Of course you can decide not to use bleach to clean your cloth diapers, but doing so introduces additional risk of health issues since bleach is one of the most effective anti-biotic agents known to man. In the end I decided that the actual environmental impact of cloth vs. disposable was not easily determined, and was potentially even too close to call, but my own feeling was that in the long run, disposable diapers were actually less impact to the environment than cloth. And since we were talking fundamentally about the health of my infant daughter, it was a no-brainer and we went with disposable diapers and never once regretted it. Well, it so happens that I know a couple who are about to have their first baby. The mother is determined to use cloth diapers. I mentioned to her that the Cosmic family went through that same decision process and decided to go with disposable, and she immediately cut off discussion on the issue declaring that cloth was better for the environment and that was the end of it. I know when there is no point to trying to change someone's mind. This woman clearly had convinced herself that it was her duty to sacrifice the health and comfort of her baby to achieve a socially desirable goal of presenting herself as morally superior to other mothers. She wasn't interested in analysis, she insisted that she had done her own analysis and that cloth was the answer, end of discussion. I politely told her that it was a personal decision that each family had to make and that I wished her the best. But privately I can't help but feel sorry for a baby who is undoubtedly, at the very least, going to suffer from chronic diaper rash due to his or her mother's insistence that she conform to the environmental narrative, comfort of her baby be damned. Oh well, my guess is that a few months into the baby's life, the mother will grow tired of the unnecessary hassle, mess and chronic diaper rash of her baby and will gravitate towards disposable diapers. Or at least I hope she will.

Comments (30)

Andy
Cosmic, we used cloth diapers for our first three sons (29, 27, and 20 years old now). None of them ever had diaper rash. In fact, when we would take trips and put them in Pampers they would almost always develop it. Dunno. It's all anecdotal, but we had bad experience with paper diapers. However, by the time #4 son came along (now 14), Pam had heard from other Mothers that paper diapers were "much better" than they used to be. So, we were older...better fixed financially...and went with the paper diapers. No problems. It was fine. I think it probably has more to do with how often that little bottom gets changed than it does with cloth v. paper. I know that we probably were not nearly as "quick on the draw" to change the boys while we were traveling, or visiting somewhere that we had them in Pampers/Luvs, etc. That may have had something to do with our original poor experience with paper.
CosmicConservative
Andy, yes, in general the driving factor is how quickly you change the baby. However, for parents who are not as "quick on the draw" disposable diapers pull the moisture away from the skin faster and more efficiently than cloth diapers. For most parents that means fewer opportunities for diaper rash. But I bet you used bleach when you washed them. :)
JSullins
The pampers I use with my 8 month old are amazing. They absorb so much, swelling and growing in size, yet do not leak. Easy, convenient, cheap. To hell with the environment... I'd use them anyway :D I suppose that makes me a bad person. I'm so, so bad.
CosmicConservative
I've seen a number of comparisons of environmental impact of cloth vs. disposable diapers. Most simply assert the standard narrative, that disposables are evil and cloth is purity and goodness. Some actually do an actual look at actual impact, at least comparing the laundering and distribution/delivery of cloth diapers compared to the creation and disposal of disposables. Most of those end up saying they are pretty comparable. But what I've never seen is a simple end to end comparison of the lifecycle of a typical single baby's use of cloth vs. disposable. If I had the time or inclination I would do it, but I can hazard some pretty good guesses/estimates to show why I am convinced that cloth are more impactful to the environment than paper. Here's a sampling of how my mind works... 1. Cloth diapers are made primarily out of cotton. Cotton is grown with traditional irrigation/fertilization farming techniques. Techniques which are known to contribute the bulk of soil erosion that is one of the top five environmental threats this world faces today. 2. Cotton farms are typically huge fenced in fields with no diversity of plant or animal life. Pesticides are used extensively to control pests like the boll weevil. There are no bird nests or deer wandering around in cotton fields. In effect from an ecological perspective a cotton field is something like a desert. 3. Converting cotton into cloth is an energy intensive process which starts with the farming and harvesting of the cotton and continues on with the removal of cotton seeds, the spinning and weaving of the cloth and the bleaching of it to make it as white as possible. Every part of this process has a significant impact on the environment. 4. Paper is produced by farming trees. In today's world that is almost exclusively pine trees grown in huge cultivated "forests" which have individual rectangles harvested on a rotating basis keeping the area mostly forested year over year. There is little to no irrigation, fertilization or pesticide use. The area where pine trees are harvested are rich with wildlife, so rich, in fact, that most of my hunting in Louisiana was done on tree farms which fed the paper industry. 5. Converting trees to paper is roughly comparable to converting cotton bolls to cotton fabric, with the major difference being the sheer amount of paper produced when compared to the cloth produced. Acre for acre a tree farm produces thousands of times as much product as cotton plants. In the end, just looking at the actual farming and production of the basic material needed for diapers it is clear to me that disposable diapers are far, far friendlier to the environment than cloth diapers. And I haven't even begun to look at the process of laundering the cloth diapers. I've never yet seen a comparison of cloth vs. disposable diapers that looks at this most fundamental aspect of the production of either or both of them. It's as if the analysts assume that raw cotton cloth and raw paper material is somehow magically produced out of nothingness itself. That's how superficial most comparisons are.
Andy
Cosmic, I do not remember if we used bleach while laundering the cloth diapers or not. Pam did most of that, even though I was often given diaper pail duty. I'm pretty sure that she probably did bleach them. If not for health reasons, to remove the blueberry & spinach stains. If you know what I mean... ;)
pace
Baby #3 should arrive within in the next week or two. We will be using disposable diapers, as we did with the first two. They are way more convenient, arguably healthier for baby, and less obnoxious to the immediate environment (ie. everyone else living in the house). I don't think the lady and I gave even the slightest consideration to using terry cloth diapers, even though we were both raised with them.
CosmicConservative
Well, I did give serious consideration to the decision, as did the Cosmic Wife. I even went to the library to do some of my research since the Internet didn't exist back then. I still think my analysis is the most complete I've ever seen and I am firmly convinced that overall disposable diapers are more friendly to the environment than cloth diapers. Although it would have had to have been a strong case against disposable diapers to overcome my reaction to the doctor's adamant statement about disposable diapers being healthier for the baby.
seriously?
Who are you? It is funny that you are telling people about the use of cloth diapers when you yourself have not used them. We don't bleach our diapers at all. In fact, you use only 1/2 the amount of detergent that you would use normally. The detergents are all biodegradable, with no additives or perfumes or dyes. My children did not get rashes from them, either. And, if you were aware of the cloth diaper products, you would know that many cloth diapers are not made from just cotton. Many are made from organic cotton (so grown without pesiticides), bamboo (renewable), hemp, and wool. All together, we have about 80 diapers that 3 children have used. That is considerably less horrific for the earth than the 18,000- 30,000 disposable diapers that they would have dumped into the landfill(6,000-10,000 per child depending on potty-training). I don't know in what world you think diapers biodegrade quicker than newspaper, but that is just plain silliness. Besides, newspaper should be recycled, an option not available for disposable diapers. Telling yourself that disposable diapers are better for the earth is an excuse to make yourself feel better about using them and creating all that garbage. And telling yourself that they are more comfortable for your child than cloth is also ridiculous. You don't where paper underwear that scratches and crinkles when you move, why should they? I love it when people take a look at reviews of a few articles written 2 or 3 decades ago and funded by the "unbiased" Proctor and Gamble corporation and say that they know the "facts". Seriously? That is just irresponsible.
CosmicConservative
seriously, you obviously have bought into the narrative and it makes you feel good to use cloth diapers. Knock yourself out. But don't kid yourself that you're saving the planet. As far as whether diapers or newspapers biodegrade "faster", that was not based on any "theory" but was based on actual emperical evidence of newspaper decay rates in actual landfills. Typical examples were newspapers buried in landfills over a hundred years ago that were still readable today! And "newspapers and magazines should be recycled" is a nice platitude, but that's not what happens is it? This is why I frequently refer to liberals as the "platitude based community." Do what makes you feel good, and I guess you can believe you're "saving the planet" if it helps you sleep nights. But you're not. You're making a virtue out of whole cloth. Heh.. That's a pun, in case you missed it.
CosmicConservative
Oh... another thing that constantly bugs me about feel-good "environmentalists" is this whole "organic is better" nonsense. Organic farms are far less efficient than modern agricultural farms. That means it takes a lot more organic farms to produce the same amount of food or cotton than a modern agricultural farm. It has been calculated that if we tried to convert all modern corporate agricultural farms to "organic" non-pesticide, non-fertilized farms of the sort "seriously" seems to prefer, that world starvation would be rampant. But then again, that's what some of these eco-enviro-zealots seem to want. Too many people, ya know? Just take a hike down to your local WalMart and you'll see what they mean...
Drax
Hehe...uses cloth diapers. Reads by candlelight? Washes by hand? Spins own cotten? Just how "environmentally conscious" is this dweeb? Oh, just enough to feel good about it, I guess...
Andy
Not to be a pain in the butt here, but "seriously?" really should get a life. We did it both ways, and I will restate that I believe it has way more to do with how often you change the thing than whether it's paper or cotton. Pam was a firm believer in cotton, and is now a firm believer in paper...so, BOTH! Gals like "seriously?" take themselves way too...(you fill in the blank).
seriously?
Well, according to the EPA, 70% of newspapers are recycled....0% of diapers, so I guess that wouldn't make them equal in the landfill, would it? By the way, nothing biodegrades in an airtight landfill. You can call me a liberal, I would hope so, because I would never want to be in the "hypocritical" conservative crowd....the "do-as-I-say-not-as-I-do" group. People are so selfish these days, and think only of their own convenience. So you can tell yourself that pitching over a ton of diapers in the landfill for each of your children is better than washing a few dozen for the entire family if that is what makes you feel better at night. But don't spew it out on the web like it is the truth. If disposables were better than cloth because the washing is so hard on the Earth, then we would all be walking around wearing paper clothing around. Can't be better to wash one and toss the other. And maybe Andy should get a life. He is degrading the fact that others care about the Earth. If the planet was populated by a bunch of Andys we wouldn't be around much longer. And, go Pam, the woman probably didn't like being inconvenienced. Guess, firm believer doesn't mean much in that family, if being a believer is just to inconvenient.
Drax
But, seriously...how serious are you? Live in a cave? Eschew television? Walk everywhere (they "manufacture" bicycles, don't you know)? Wash everything by hand? (Whatcha use for detergent?) Candlelight only? (Make your own, I hope...dang that "manufacture" and "transportation" stuff). Grow your own food? Make your own clothes? Seriously? How serious are you? Because, unless you're DAMN serious about your efforts to "save the planet" I'm just not hearing you, because you, like the rest of us, make trade-offs for cost and convenience -- just drawing the line in a different place HERE while we might draw a the line in a different place THERE -- without, you know, all the snobbish fingerpointing and breast thumping...
CosmicConservative
As I said in the original post and have repeated, most of the "eco" lifestyle is about feeling good about yourself. There is almost certainly very little difference between the environmental impact of "serious" and any of us "hypocritical" conservatives. For example "serious" do you have an air conditioner? I don't. If you do, that alone probably makes me half as damaging to the earth by your own standards than you are. What kind of car do you drive? I drive a car that gets 42 mpg and is certified as "green" by the state of Colorado. I don't even have to get the emissions checked it's so green. Do you use city water and city sanitation services? Massive environmental impact. I have a well and a septic tank. I take care, literally, of my own crap. Go ahead and lecture us, that's the true mark of a liberal.
CosmicConservative
By the way, "serious," wearing disposable paper clothing was "seriously" proposed not so long ago by "serious" environmentalists for precisely the reasons I've stated here. And one more thing. Are you "seriously" unaware that landfills are stabilized by paper products? Did you know that landfills are converted into neighborhoods and schoolyards? It's true! You might be living on an old landfill right now. The "crisis" of overfilled landfills is just one of the many, many, over-hyped "environmental crises" that the trendy "environmentalist" is led to fret over (so they can have the appropriate amount of guilt) when the real global environmental calamities are almost totally unknown. Things like topsoil erosion, for example. Or water depletion by folks who live in cities which suck water out of the surrounding area like giant hydro-black holes. Or depletion of the oceans. Eaten any seafood lately "serious?" Those are three of the real environmental crises. Landfills are so passe that they're not even trendy anymore. You're way behind the times "serious." The "trendy" environmentalists are all about global warming now. Guess what contributes to global warming... yeah, farming cotton. Guess what doesn't contribute to global warming.... paper tree farms. Paper tree farms are net carbon reducers, don'cha know... Not to mention forests are atmospheric coolers and farms are atmospheric heaters.... You know what happens when you bury paper underground for a century or so? It's called "carbon sequestration" and it's all the rage now for stopping global warming. Seriously. But who wants to be confused by the facts anyway?
Andy
Hey seriously, you're dang right. The goal of my wife and myself is to destroy the planet. We've been doing our best for 51 years now, but just can't seem to get it done, dangit. I think production of computers, and the electricity to power them, and the carbon emission of vehicles used by fellows to run cable lines, and telephone lines that bring the internet to users is evil, also. I'm thinking "seriously" is helping destroy the planet by participating in it all. I mean, a "true believer" wouldn't join in on the destruction just because of personal convenience, or desires. Just sayin'...
CosmicConservative
One of the most environmentally damaging industries out there is the movie industry. Besides the carbon emitted in hauling millions of dollars of equipment "on location" and the fleets of private jets of the stars, the film processing itself involves highly toxic chemicals and a typical feature length film processes thousands of feet of film. And all for the sole purpose of providing us evil Americans with a couple hours of escapist, usually pointless "entertainment". It would be hard to come up with a more frivolous reason to generate so much carbon and pollution than Hollywood, and yet those folks who get rich (and buy huge environmentally destructive mansions, private planes and whose entourages invariably drive around in fleets of SUVs) are precisely the same folks who lecture us about diaper use. It's a funny, funny world. I wonder what industry "seriously" works in...
Dadman
You mean I can start using more than one ply now to wipe my arse?
seriously?
I have no idea where you get your information (Fox news, my guess). But just so you know, I don't have an air conditioner, we drive a hybrid (just like you), we have an HE washing machine and low flush toilets, we compost in our backyard, and I don't work in the movie industry (I am a doctor). By the way, septic systems are one of the primary causes of groundwater contamination, so you can take your crap and drink it. Also, tree logging and wood pulp production is one of the largest causes of CO2 emissions (aka global warming). Regardless, there is not just a sinlge issue that effects our environment....that is rather single-minded of you. You tell me I am lecturing you, what are you doing in return? It is the older generation who is so unwilling to accept change and often thinks so selfishly. I am guessing you are not too new this planet.
CosmicConservative
Seriously, I wonder if you have any idea of how bigoted you sound. You trot out the standard liberal talking points and sneer at Fox News as if CNN or any of the legacy media outlets are any less biased just because Fox happens to be biased in the other direction. Where do you get your information about logging? "One of the largest causes of CO2 emissions? Really? Bigger than, say, the automobile industry? Bigger than coal power production? Bigger than the livestock industry? I don't think so. Besides, so long as the pulp tree farms regrow trees at a sustainable rate, the net carbon generated is only the carbon generated in running their machinery, since they grow a new tree for every tree they cut down. And again, those tree farms are generally teeming with a very biodiverse population of plants and animals, unlike, for example, a cotton field. And if your bigoted attitude about conservatives in general wasn't intolerant enough, you had to throw in some age bigotry too. I'm pretty sure that when it comes to raising the examples of environmental issues is concerned, I'm the one who brought soil erosion, water consumption and ocean fisheries depletion up, not you. If anyone on this thread has a narrow single-issue view, it's been you, not me. But, going back to that single issue, why don't you tell me exactly what pressing environmental calamity is being caused by burying millions of diapers in landfills? What great threat exists? How is using a cloth diaper saving the planet? By the way, it sounds like you are quite proud of your environmental bona fides. But in the end it sounds to me that you still burn gasoline, still use up precious water resources (do you fertilize and water your lawn?) And in general you live in a way that your environmental impact is probably quite close to my own. In fact the only significant difference we've identified in our actual lifestyles so far is that you chose to use cloth diapers and I chose disposable. Do you really believe that alone gives you the moral superiority to lecture me the way you have? Not to mention the hilarious prejudicial comments you felt compelled to throw in about my presumed age and television viewing preferences. (By the way, I rarely watch any TV news at all since I find virtually all of it to be simplistic and overflowing with ideological bias.) Does it really make you feel better to be so overtly bigoted and insulting?
Drax
Hehe...poke poke... It doesn't matter how much you do, seriously, you ain't doing enough. The difference between you and us is that we understand that there's a trade-off and don't breast-thump or point fingers if others choose a different point in that trade-off thinking that we are better than they because we chose (what we consider to be) a "better" level of greenness than they. I'm better than you, you know. I don't drive to work; I work from home. No amount of your other "sacrifices" (*cough*) will make up for that lapse in judgment. Shame on you.
seriously?
I am no more bigoted than you are. I am pointing more more fingers than you are. YOU brought up your environmental bona fides, as you call them first, implying they were better then my own. And you were the one make preceived ideas how my actions and profession first. And I was only tauting the benefits of cloth diapers compared to disposables becuase that was the original issue YOU brought up in YOUR blog. And simply because one source makes more CO2 emissions than something else, does not mean that it doesn't make significant emissions. And actually tree farms have very little biodiversity given the rate at which they are harvested, but that is neither here nor there to you. There are many many many areas of environmental concern. I am merely addressing diapers and landfills because YOU brought it up. And, of course, I am not a martyr. I never said I was. Noone makes zero impact on the Earth...it is impossible. That doesn't mean that you give up and just damage it left and right. CLoth diapering is not saving the planet, not one single act can. But everything adds up.
Drax
Seriously, his point (jik you missed it) is that he did some serious investigation of the facts known at the time vis a vis the environmental impact of cloth vs. paper diapers and found (after said investigation) that the difference, if any there was, was minimal. As one site puts it: "Are cloth diapers better for the environment? Well, disposable diapers do make up a huge part of the garbage we dump in our nation's landfills every year. On the other hand, washing cloth diapers raises environmental concerns, too. Laundering diapers uses up a lot of energy and water, and the detergents used pollute the nation's waters. Some fans of disposables even argue that diaper delivery trucks use up natural resources of gas and oil and contribute to air pollution. Backers of cloth diapers counter that parents who make midnight runs to grocery stores and pharmacies to pick up another pack of disposables use up much more gas than diaper delivery trucks that map out the most cost-efficient route to serve their communities. The debate over the relative impact of disposable and cloth diapers on the environment is not at all clear cut. The side you come down on in this argument depends on what aspects of the environment you value most. Disposables and cloth diapers each have their own advantages to you and your baby as well as to the environment." It isn't really a yes/no, better/worse question. Cloth diapers have an environmental impact separate and distinct from those of paper diapers -- from manufacture to cleaning to ultimate disposal. Paper diapers have their own environmental concerns, not the least of which is where to put them when you're done with them. (But, this, too, has the potential of a POSITIVE environmental impact as well as an impact on the quality of life as landfills can be have a positive effect on the environment and the quality of life as easily as the converse.) I can certainly see the side of the argument that "cloth diapers are better for the environment." But, I can also see the other side. BOTH have potential positive and negative impact on the environment. We just get a kick out of those who believe that they have the answer to such questions...kinda fun to poke 'em with a logic stick.
Dadman
I believe used disposable diapers should be store in Yucca Mountain, Nevada, right next to the nuclear waste... ;)
CosmicConservative
Drax, thanks for restating my original point. Seriously, as shown in the article Drax quoted, there simply is no obvious and provable "winner" in the choice between cloth and disposable diapers. That is exactly what my original post said. You simply believe there is. If there is an environmentally superior choice it is not by much. My original analysis stands. The difference between you and me is that I don't presume to attack you for your choice while you felt compelled to come here and lecture me because you believe without proof that your choice was superior to mine. I didn't go to YOUR blog to lecture, condescend and insult you. And you can ASSERT that I am as bigoted as you, but only you have hurled prejudicial insults based on nothing more than the fact that I am a conservative. That's the simple and obvious fact of the matter. I hope you don't act this way on other trivial issues just because it makes you feel all superior.
AJ
I just noticed you said that you did your research in the library because the Internet didn't exsist at the time you were doing the study. Typically, with time, we aquire new information that leads us to new studies an this different outcomes that in turn create new "facts". I'm pregnant now and we are trying to decide with cloth is for us. I'd be curious to read the studies you read that lead you to your decision. Can you reference them for us? (another thing typically done in scientific studies) not to be a smart a$$ just want to get the hard evidence for myself. Lastly, I understand that growing and harvesting trees may have less impact on the environment than cotton, I'm curious how many trees have to be harvested to support the purchasing of diapers for 1 child in comparison to the amount of cotton you have to grow/harvest to diaper 1 child. My guess is that there are a LOT more trees getting harvested for that baby than cotton since you reuse the cloth diapers.
CosmicConservative
AJ, that research I did on cloth vs disposable was over 20 years ago now, and I did not create a research paper or publish it in a scientific journal. I don't typically write up, annotate and cross reference every decision I make about what to purchase, and this is a personal blog, not a scientific journal, so I feel no need to provide some sort of scientific rigor on the decision, no more than I feel a need to write up a thesis paper and publish in "Nature" my decisions about my diabetes dietary choices. There are a number of websites out there which have attemped to document the differences between cloth and disposable. Some champion cloth, and some champion disposable. I made my choice after doing my own research 22 years ago and I am quite comfortable with the results. I think my arguments above are quite clear and reasonable. It is important to note that back then the main argument against disposable diapers was the assertion by "environmentalists" that diapers were overflowing our landfills and that we were at a horrible crisis point with landfills taking over the country. In the 22 years since then, I see no evidence that landfills are any more of an environmental catastrophe even though the predictions of the cloth diaper proponents was that our towns and cities would be overflowing with garbage by now due to the massive flow of disposable diapers into landfills. It simply hasn't happened. As with so many of the doom and gloom predictions of the "environmentalists," not only has the predicted calamity completely failed to occur, but in fact forested land area in this country has increased dramatically in the time since they were predicting a diaper landfill acopalyse. Do what you feel comfortable with, just don't fool yourself that your eventual choice is somehow the "right" moral choice that will help save the world. Diapers were never any significant environmental threat to begin with. It's all just more feel-good pseudo morality lecturing from the arrogant and generally uninformed left.
Andrew Brautigam
Maybe cloth diapers 22 years ago weren't great, but modern cloth diapers go a long way towards addressing the issues that caused the results of the original studies to be inconclusive. First, cloth diapers get washed with cold water, with dye free bleach free powder detergent, and get hung up to dry. Here's the big sticking point that most people want to avoid: It is way, way cheaper to use cloth diapers, especially for multiple babies. At 450 dollars of start-up cost, (fuzzibunz one size, 24 total) then 4-10 dollars of monthly water bill increase from the extra 6-8 small loads of laundry a month plus a couple of bags of diaper detergent, the total cost is well under 1000 dollars for one child, compared to 1600+ for disposables. For the second child, and any subsequent children, the total cost is under 300 dollars. For a family with 4 kids, this is a 4 thousand dollar swing. Not chump change. In simple, economic terms, cloth diapering is a no brainer. As with most environmental decisions, the long-term cheapest choice is usually the most environmentally friendly. The best line from the study that I assume you are referring to is that the impact from diapering a baby with any kind of diapers is the rough equivalent of driving a car 1300-2200 miles. Diapers are a small piece of the puzzle, while driving and other lifestyle choices make a much bigger environmental impact.