Cloth vs. Disposable diapers
By CosmicConservativeBack when the Cosmic Wife and I were going through the birth of the Cosmic Daughter, I had a discussion with our doctor about the benefits of cloth vs. disposable diapers. To my surprise my doctor was adamant that disposable diapers were healthier for the baby. In her mind there was simply no debate on the issue.
Since the prevailing narrative at that time (and to this day) was that cloth diapers were a superior environmental choice, I decided to check into the environmental impact to see if there was any compelling reason to put my daughter's health at risk (the risk primarily being increased diaper rash and minor infections of various sorts, as well as the potential spreading of various diseases through leaky diapers).
So I looked into the major environmental impacts that disposable diapers were supposed to cause. At that time the major opposition to diapers from hard-core "environmentalists" was that diapers were filling up landfills at an alarming rate, and that we would soon run out of landfill space if we didn't stop using disposable diapers. There was also the claim that entire forests were being wiped out by disposable diapers and that the creation of them produced chemical toxins that were poisoning the earth.
Well, it turned out when I examined the actual data around disposable diapers that each of these claims ended up being seriously over-stated by environmentalists and the actual environmental impact of diapers was vastly less than the hype being spewed over the national airwaves. In fact, in a bit of delicious irony, the production and distribution of just the newspapers alone which were spreading this disinformation was several orders of magnitude more than the disposable diapers themselves. In fact, not only were newspapers, phone books and magazines creating thousands of times more landfill waste in bulk and by weight, but disposable diapers actually biodegraded much more rapidly than newspapers and magazines. Also virtually all disposable diapers were produced using the same pulp tree-farm techniques that were used to create paper, and the amount of wood harvested to produce paper in its various forms was tens of thousands of times as much wood as that used to produce disposable diapers.
And, as it turned out, the chemical byproducts of diaper production were similarly comparable in quality, but vastly less in quantity, to that which the paper and ink industry turned out. In other words an average daily newspaper was far more impactful to the environment than the average box of diapers.
And the more I looked into cloth diapers the more I discovered the environmental impact of cloth diapers was vastly underrated by these same "environmentalists." The production of the cloth itself required the planting and harvesting of cotton, a product that is vastly less efficient than the planting and harvesting of wood products. In other words an acre of pine trees produces thousands of times more raw material suitable for creating a diaper than does an acre of cotton. So each cloth diaper had a comparable impact to the environment of thousands of disposable diapers, just in the area of land, the irrigation and fertilization of the croplands. Croplands that routinely lost tons of topsoil through erosion and plowing, compared to the minimal loss of topsoil to tree-harvesting processes.
And then there was the problem of cleaning the cloth diapers. No matter what process you use, cleaning a cloth diaper introduces chemicals to the environment, and to clean them thoroughly requires bleach, which is one of the most environmentally damaging chemicals there is. Of course you can decide not to use bleach to clean your cloth diapers, but doing so introduces additional risk of health issues since bleach is one of the most effective anti-biotic agents known to man.
In the end I decided that the actual environmental impact of cloth vs. disposable was not easily determined, and was potentially even too close to call, but my own feeling was that in the long run, disposable diapers were actually less impact to the environment than cloth. And since we were talking fundamentally about the health of my infant daughter, it was a no-brainer and we went with disposable diapers and never once regretted it.
Well, it so happens that I know a couple who are about to have their first baby. The mother is determined to use cloth diapers. I mentioned to her that the Cosmic family went through that same decision process and decided to go with disposable, and she immediately cut off discussion on the issue declaring that cloth was better for the environment and that was the end of it.
I know when there is no point to trying to change someone's mind. This woman clearly had convinced herself that it was her duty to sacrifice the health and comfort of her baby to achieve a socially desirable goal of presenting herself as morally superior to other mothers. She wasn't interested in analysis, she insisted that she had done her own analysis and that cloth was the answer, end of discussion.
I politely told her that it was a personal decision that each family had to make and that I wished her the best. But privately I can't help but feel sorry for a baby who is undoubtedly, at the very least, going to suffer from chronic diaper rash due to his or her mother's insistence that she conform to the environmental narrative, comfort of her baby be damned. Oh well, my guess is that a few months into the baby's life, the mother will grow tired of the unnecessary hassle, mess and chronic diaper rash of her baby and will gravitate towards disposable diapers. Or at least I hope she will.
Comments (30)