Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Black Holes in the news again

By CosmicConservative
CNN has the story. Now for my snarking on the typical "science reporting" nonsense:
Until recently, black holes have remained hidden beneath invisibility cloaks
Wow. Apparently black holes are sort of like Harry Potter. What a way to lead a science story on black holes. Was this written for a fourth grade science class?
But to other far more massive black holes, swallowing a single star is like Mount Everest absorbing a snowflake.
Geez, talk about creative license.
supermassive black holes hold millions to billions the mass of our Sun, and lurk at the centers of many galaxies.
Wow, not only are they wearing invisibility cloaks, but they are sort of like cosmic versions of Shelob, malevolently seeking to pounce on their prey. In case you didn't get the allusion to malevolent carnivorous intent the first time, it's repeated in my favorite line from the story:
The charged breeze could zap the accretion disc's spin energy. With its prey weakened, a black hole could then slurp up the nearby particles, the thinking goes.
This is called "thinking?" And to finish it off:
Of course, with her findings came another mystery. Ghez and others have spotted very young stars near this super-massive black hole. Theory tells us that a black hole's titanic tug should prevent stars from forming.
Theory tells us no such thing. Theory tells us that in the immediate vicinity of a black hole tidal effects would make it difficult, but not impossible, for stars to form. However, theory also tells us that in a mass rich environment, such as a billion stellar mass black hole's accretion disk, turbulent effects will tend to cause matter to clump and such clumping could well encourage star formation, even in the presence of tidal forces. Once a clump gets massive enough, it's own gravity would overcome the tidal effects of the black hole. This, for example, is how planets are thought to form in the presence of their star's own tidal effects. Sheesh....

Comments (0)

No comments on this post.