Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

What do you think of this?

By CosmicConservative
A video of a man purchasing a Koran, shooting it full of holes with a military rifle in the woods, and then dropping the mangled result off at a Muslim mosque in Chattanooga, was posted on MySpace.com. The MySpace.com site where it was posted also contained comments encouraging the killing of Muslims, as well as other racist comments about blacks and hispanics. What I would like to know is whether any part of the actions in the video and on the website are acceptable, whether any parts of the actions are criminal, and where you think the poster crossed the line. The F.B.I. is investigating the incident.

Comments (5)

mtnlurker
It doesn't sound like he actually advocated the killing of anyone. Though he does admire people who kill muslims. The shot up Koran could be construed as a threat. I think an investigation is warranted.
CosmicConservative
Would it have been a threat had he simply shot it up and posted the video without dumping it on the doorstep of a Muslim Mosque?
Dadman
Nope. It's free speech...similar to flag burning. Or rendering cartoons of Mohammed...
qwerty182764
Okay .. . (wince), I recant my previous position. I still don't think flag burning is on the level of a mortal threat (since hippies don't intend to actually rebel or anything), but you're right. There is some stuff that's just intimidation.
CosmicConservative
If I understand the law, the shooting of the Koran and posting the video is probably protected free speech. The posting of racist comments encouraging or at least approving of killing Muslims on a website is probably not protected and could be criminal under hate-crime laws, but I don't know Tennessee laws so I'll just say this is a "maybe." The leaving of the bullet-riddled Koran on the steps of a Muslim Mosque is a definite hate crime. I believe the investigation to be warranted.