More on raiding in MMORPGs
By CosmicConservativeI know that a few of my regular commenters here have played Massively Multiplayer Online Role Playing Games (MMORPGs), but most have not. There are probably others who have played WoW or games like WoW, but never raided themselves and may not really understand the whole raiding dynamic. In fact I am a big fan of "The Guild" a web video series that parodies the antics of members of a raiding guild in a generic MMORPG, but "The Guild" gets far more wrong than they get right, making me wonder if Felicia Day has ever really been seriously involved in raiding before or during the creative process of making "The Guild." It's possible she has but she feels that it is easier to parody the average person's assumptions about raiding to mine the humor there than to accurately parody an actual raiding guild. If so, she's probably right. Much of the stuff that happens in a raiding environment wouldn't make sense to a non-raider and as such wouldn't have much comedy potential.
Years ago, when I set up my first account on EverQuest, I didn't know anything about raiding. I was looking for an online version of Dungeons and Dragons, not some totally new gaming experience. In fact, for a long time I was frustrated with EverQuest because I kept trying to make it into an online version of D&D, when really a MMORPG in combat is more like a networked first-person shooter than any table-top role playing game.
But over time I became accustomed to that reality and committed myself to the level grind in EverQuest. I had a couple of friends I played with frequently and we would group to do instances, which is sort of a baby version of raiding that at least introduces the concepts of role-based combat. But it wasn't until my EQ wizard reached level 60 or so that I discovered raiding and realized that raiding was, in fact, the justification for the existence of the genre. Everything else about MMORPGs is basically some sort of grind, or some sort of training for raiding. Raiding is what it's all about.
And why is that? Well, I suppose different people have different motivations for raiding, and there are no doubt lots of MMORPGamers who enjoy the game just fine without raiding. But the ultimate goal of the game itself, as created by the game designers, is to defeat the game's top bosses. And the top bosses are all in the raids.
OK, OK, I can see an argument for PvP being just as fulfilling and just as much fun, and I've done lots of PvP myself in WoW, but PvP is, by its nature, a series of short, limited engagements with strategy and tactics that are defined and executed in fractions of a second.
Raiding is much more strategic. It requires real planning and study to do successfully. Besides mastering your character's game abilities, you have to know when and why to use them over battles that frequently last ten minutes or more, in sessions that can last for two hours or more (most start-to-finish raids in IceCrown Citadel are set for three hour runs, and as often as not the raiders have to come back later in the week to complete the final bosses that they didn't get to in the three hours set aside).
Raiding in a MMORPG is about as pure a meritocracy as I've ever encountered. It's a brutal example of survival of the fittest where your performance is quite literally rated on charts for the whole world to see, and if you don't reach certain thresholds, you simply aren't allowed to do certain things. That's because one under-equipped, under-skilled, or just plain ignorant player can wreck the plans of 24 other people simply by not having prepared properly for the raid.
Raid leaders, in particular, scrutinize the equipment and performance of raiders. It is not uncommon at all for a raid leader to, without a word, kick someone who is not performing adequately out of the raid. Every serious raider has a series of meters and charts that they use to measure their performance. For Rhlyssa that is primarily how much damage she is doing. I use a damage meter that resets for every fight we get into. To save screen space I have it sized to ony show the top five damage producers in the raid. If Rhlyssa's name is not in that top five, I get nervous. Typically I want to be in the top three, and frankly I feel my proper place is at #1. Healers monitor their healing effectiveness both by how much healing they've done and by how few raid members are dying. Tanks monitor their ability to control the boss so that the boss focuses its attack on the tank. Everything is public to raiders who have the proper tools. When someone is doing an unacceptable amount of damage, healing or aggro management, if they are lucky, they will be told to step it up. Usually they are simply dumped from the raid and the raid leaders put them on their "ignore" list.
And as important as it is for a role to perform adequately in that role, there are many other things that raid members appreciate in their raiding party. Such as not dying during an encounter. It also includes having appropriate equipment, potions, flasks, elixers, scrolls and food to buff up the party, as well as being able to utilize the highest level of skills to improve the raid's chances of success.
Perhaps I like it because it's the ultimate geek fantasy. Everything is quantifiable, verifiable and demonstrable. Since it is everyone's best interest for everyone to perform to their best abilities, tips, hints and tricks are freely shared, so just by raiding you learn how to better perform in your role.
Some of the fights you have to perform are so complex and so difficult that it is truly an accomplishment to pull them off. Plus you have to perform cooperatively to succeed. Every class has a primary role, but also has a series of abilities that make other classes jobs easier. So the best raids (and most successful) happen when every player is focused on the team, not on themselves, and is doing everything possible to perform their role while also supporting the other roles as much as they can.
And since every fight produces publicly available logs of every swing of a dagger, every healing spell, every buff that expires, etc... there is nowhere to hide. If you screw up, everyone knows it was you. If you want to keep playing, the only way to do it is to get better and better.
Among the quantifiable elements in the game are tools which score a character's gear. One is called "GearScore" (geeks are so original) and it's the primary means of rating a character's gear. Right now the general agreed upon value for a "raid-worthy" character is to have a gear score of at least 5,000. At this moment Rhlyssa's gear score is 5.5K. The average value I've seen in ICC raids is about 5.7-5.8K, so Rhlyssa is still a bit under-geared. But in combat she has been holding her own in DPS (Damage Per Second) against other raiders with gear scores of 5.8 - 6.2K. What that tells me is that when she finally gets her complete set of tier 10 gear, she'll be back at the top of the charts.
And for some reason, that's important to me. I probably won't rest until I can go into ICC 25 on hard mode, clear out the instance, and be at or on par with the top damage producer in the raid.
And by then I expect the next release will be out... :)
Comments (11)