Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Guildicide

By CosmicConservative
So a few days ago I posted here how frustrated I was with my World of Warcraft guild. I made a mention of how the guild was really more of a clique with a central "in crowd" and everyone else more or less operated at the mercy of the guild's inner core. Well I logged onto WoW last night and started seeing a flurry of "XXX has left the guild" messages. In fact I saw at least a dozen in the first ten minutes after logging on. Then one of the guild members private messaged me telling me that a large group of guild members was leaving after the guild founder and his inner circle cronies had insulted the others by telling them, in open guild chat apparently, that they would never be good enough to raid with the inner core members and to stop asking for invitations to the top raids. Then one of the core members who is one of the few guild members I have any sort of relationship with messaged me saying that the ones leaving were leaving because they weren't willing to take the guild tests to become core guild raiders. What a virtual Peyton Place... In the end it looks like about three dozen guild members are leaving. Now many of those are player alternate characters so that may only end up being two dozen actual players, but some of the ones leaving are long time guild members who have apparently just had enough of the arbitrary and abusive behavior of the guild leader and his core "officers." I have been told I am welcome to join the newly formed guild, or to stay in the existing guild. One benefit of not forming strong bonds with guild members appears to be that even a major guild schizm doesn't end up with me obviously on one side or the other. And at the same time I have been seriously considering applying to a completely different guild. I think tonight I will send an application to that other guild and hopefully leave all this drama behind...

Comments (7)

CosmicConservative
It occurs to me that my status as being welcome in either the original or the newly formed guild may not be as much about my social status as it is about my raiding status. Everyone who raids in the guild knows that I used to be in the main raiding group before I took my 8 month haitus. They also know that even though my gear is still lower than the rest of the core group's gear, when I did get invited to the 25 man raid, I was still #4 in the damage charts. With so many people leaving the guild, the remaining raiders probably see me as even more valuable as an alternate than they did before, when I was getting rare invitations already. And those who are leaving probably realize that my damage output is probably higher than anyone else in the group that is leaving, meaning they are more likely to be successful raiders with me than without me. Perhaps the joint invitations to leave or stay aren't nearly as generous as I thought. Hm....
JSullins
Always able to find the gray lining in the silver cloud? :D I'm the same way, of course. Incidentally, where are you applying?
CosmicConservative
Well, was gonna check with Salmar...
Drax
Heh. All guilds have drama. The trick is to get into a guild in which either you're able to keep out of the drama while still enabled to do that which you like to do -- or the drama is of the kind in which you like to engage. The actions of the guild leaders seems to be of the kind typical beta males employ, i.e., the core group didn't have any use for the hangerons but didn't have the guts to outright kick them -- so they gave them an excuse to quit by insulting them with the truth (or their perception of it).
Tom DeGisi
> The trick is to get into a guild in which either you’re able to keep out of the drama while still enabled to do that which you like to do — or the drama is of the kind in which you like to engage. Drax, I think what you said also applies to blogs with a large group of commentors. Yours, Tom
CosmicConservative
Tom, I suppose that might be a reference to Dean's World, a blog I no longer read or participate in since Dean developed a habit of unfairly and arbitrarily deleting my comments on the flimsiest of pretexts. I certainly decided not to continue to participate in that group. And, as I may have noted on a later post, I have joined a new guild, and in that guild I've already done three raids in the highest level content. In fact our raiding group completed all but the final two bosses in Ice Crown Citadel, and we have one more shot at ICC 25 tonight. I think we have the ability to complete Sindragosa, we came very, very close to defeating the ice bone dragon last night on a couple of attempts. That fight boils down to just not making many mistakes, the mechanics are not terribly complex, they just have to be navigated several times without an error. The Lich King though, that looks to be the most difficult raid encounter I've seen in World of Warcraft. Probably not as difficult as some of the EverQuest raids, but pretty dang hard. I doubt we'll defeat both tonight, but just defeating Sindragosa would be a major achievement, especially for someone from a guild who wouldn't even invite him on the attempts.
Tom DeGisi
Not only Dean's World, CC. :) I've seen drama on lots of blogs with a large number of commentors and some with just a few. Your commentors seem very well behaved, though. Yours, Tom