I posted this entry earlier today:
Evolution Ruminations
There are two links there, one a more "scientific" analysis of evolution and one a more "religious" analysis. I watched as much as I could stand of both of them. Which wasn't much, frankly.
I have as my tagline on my blog "Rational Conservatism from the Rocky Mountains." I'd like to think that is more than just rhetoric. I make every effort possible to examine things rationally.
When it comes to evolution and creationism, here are my thoughts:
Points in favor of Creationism:
- I am unable to come up with any physical rational evidence to support Creationism, so if somebody has some, send it my way.
Points in favor of Evolution:
- There is tremendous agreement between virtually all fields of science when it comes to most of the "big" questions about the universe. Its age, its composition, its physical laws, etc.
- Evolution explains some of the more troubling aspects of life, such as "why are there ticks?" When resorting to a supernatural explanation has troubling implications for the nature of the Creator Himself.
- Evolution is generally only challenged by a very narrow segment of the world's religious community, basically that which derives directly from ancient judaism. Other great religions, such as Hindism and Buddhism, don't seem to find any evidence to support Creationism, instead they are quite comfortable with the evidence that supports evolution.
- Evolution can be demonstrated, and has been done historically. It is generally acknowledged that dogs are a different species than wolves, but that they derived from domesticating wolves. Genetic studies bear this out. More specifically grains that have been bred by humans for human consumption, such as wheat and corn, can be traced back to original species that still live in the wild today. This "show me one species that evolution produced" challenge from Creationists is one that demonstrates a remarkable lack of understanding of genetics. So the evidence is overwhelming that not only do we have actual evidnence of evolution in action, but that the evidence is through human manipulation itself.
Points against Evolution:
- The timescale of evolution is very long and therefore difficult to demonstrate.
- There is no rational explanation yet found to explain the initial formation of the universe.
- There are significant gaps in the existing fossil record. Biology, paleontology, anthropology and history are all incomplete explanations of the universe, the earth, life on earth and human history.
- Many of the most vocal proponents of evolution are just as bad at science as their counterparts on the Creationism side, leaving the general impression that both are "just theories"
Points against Creationism
- Horrible debilitating diseases like AIDS or the Ebola virus
- Basic astronomical observations (more on this below)
- Lack of support outside of narrow religious community
- Repeated use of bad science, even when thorougly debunked.
- Absolute reliance on religious doctrine as the only way to know "truth"
- It isn't science. God is not falsifiable.
OK, a quick comment on astronomical observations. One of the arguments made in the video links I published was the baldfaced assertion that the Earth is "not millions of years old." Meaning that the universe itself is "not millions of years old."
Well, this presents a problem if you go outside and set up a telescope. Let's take something simple like the Andromeda Galaxy. The Andromeda Galaxy as we see it in the sky is something like 3 million light years away. Which means that the light we see when we look into a telescope originated 3 million years ago.
Um... but waitaminute. That can't be right, because the universe is only, say, 12,000 years old. But the speed of light is an invariable constant of the universe. If the universe is only 12,000 years old, we could only see objects in the sky that were closer than 12,000 light years away. Everything else in the sky, every star greater than 12,000 light years (the majority of the Milky Way's stellar population, since the Milky Way itself is something like 150,000 light years wide), every galaxy in the sky, every globular cluster, every quasar, in fact, pretty much everything you have ever seen in an astronomy textbook, would be invisible to us because the light could not possibly have reached us yet.
When I point this out to Creationists, they fall back on the "Well, God made the light in progress." But there's a problem with this.
Let's say that God created the Andromeda Galaxy 12,000 years ago. And he created light "in progress" that showed the Andromeda Galaxy as it was 3 million years ago. Then we would be seeing light from the andromeda Galaxy that didn't actually come from the andromeda galaxy. But wait, there's more! There are exploding stars in the Andromeda Galaxy every year. We see them all the time. In fact we study Andromeda supernovae for lots of good scientific reasons. But these are supernovae that exploded 3 million years ago. In a galaxy that was created only 12,000 years ago. So if the "light" was created "in progress" what we see today are actually movies of exploding stars that
never actually existed. So all that study we are doing of Andromeda supernovae is all a figment of God's imagination. Those stars never existed, they certainly didn't blow up 3 million years ago.
So the only rational conclusion to reach is that the night sky is a colossal, cosmic lie. And such a lie. The Hubble has revealed that there are literally billions of galaxies. Every new telescope we build sees new ones further away that we never saw before. So presumably there are still even more non-existant galaxies out there that we will see that never existed in the future.
This presents a problem if you believe that God cannot lie. And if you believe that God can lie, then you have to start asking "well, if he lies about the stars, what else does he lie about?" And that leads to some very troubling questions.
So, put me down as one who follows the basic science progress in multiple fields, who is skeptical that we have the details of evolution down, but who feels that evolution is the best explanation we have yet for how we came to be, and how the universe will continue.
One final point. The argument that since science can't explain the creation of the universe, somehow that is a point in favor of Creationism is what is generally known as a "logical fallacy." It is quite simple to ask "where did God come from" to demonstrate this. Creationism does no more to explain the existence of God than evolution does to explain the formation of the Universe. Both are unexplainable "first causes" that neither side has yet managed to explain. So that's a wash.
Comments (4)