Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

SCOTUS appointee Elena Kagan

By CosmicConservative
I'll give Obama this much credit, he has picked a candidate for the SCOTUS who appears to be difficult to pigeon-hole. On the one hand, she's a hand-picked Obama administration official with ties to Chicago of her own. On the other hand, she did open up Harvard to increased exposure to conservative viewpoints by mandating the interviewing and hiring of conservatives. She has precious little in the way of writings or judicial experience to judge from. But she appears to favor Presidential authority in borderline cases. I guess my current position on her is that from my perspective right now, Obama could have picked a far worse candidate. I can't say that I am reflexively opposed to her nomination. She doesn't appear to be a Ruth Bader Ginsburg type of radical Leftist anyway. And based on who she is replacing, it's somewhat plausible that she could inch the court a few notches to the right... Hard to say.

Comments (5)

Andy
Cosmic, IMHO, she will not vote any differently than who she is replacing already would. They are all the same. You can know with 95% certainty where the left side of this court comes down on issues. With the exception of the few times they REALLY surprise me, it's pretty well known going in where the Justices are going to land on issues. I see her nomination as a "shove." And, it could well be that we are fortunate. We may have gotten "worse" out of ObozO. My only regret in this whole thing is that she is so young. She is younger than I am...and will likely be around to screw up the nation with her rulings for too many years. Damn those lefties...hung around just long enough for ObozO to replace them!
esox67
I agree with Andy Harvard is a great school, but unless you are choosing an attorney who has worked for a living in say one of the downtown NY firms after graduating, you are pretty getting somebody who has never worked worked outside academia, the die has been cast. She has tasted the tainted fruit of the living breathing document philosophy of the constitution and believes like the wise latino that the courts role is to legislate from the bench. I say she should be borked...we got enough judges who make up law as they go, one less progressive sheep like Franken in senate would be a good move forward for our country.
Old Goat
I don't see her changing the make up as it is currently configured, but I fear the lack of any track record as it seems he was purposeful in choosing someone who has no record. You can't ever be absolutely certain with these choices. Given that some of the liberal members were put in by conservative Presidents, it would be nice to see someone who was picked by a liberal President turn out to be conservative... for a change.
esox67
Do not confuse democrats with the stupid choices past Republicans like Bush senior put on the court, Obama knows exactly how she will vote. The socialists running the show are not afraid to put anyone they want on the court while republicans are still trying to "get along" which gets them nowhere. Maybe they will figure this out someday.
staylor
Perhaps her lack of record indicates that she is a Rovian plant who will move to the right of Scalia once she is one the court? I know, it is unlikely but a guy can dream.