Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Comments (21)

Drax
Sigh...I'll be getting mine soon... Screw 'em. I'll answer the questions the Constitution allows them to ask.
CosmicConservative
That's what I told him, that's when he threatened me with a fine.
Andy
I'm a little confused. Did you return the form incomplete, or not at all?
mtnlurker
There is a law that says if you don't fill it out you fill face a $5000 fine. You can look it up.
CosmicConservative
As I understand it, there are three levels of fines. $100 if you don't answer the questions. $500 if you deliberately answer incorrectly $5,000 if you don't return the form at all. I returned the form with just the number, gender, age and names of the people living here. According to the Constitution you are only required to return the number of people. According to some sites I've seen an old statute requiring you to return the age and gender has held up in court. But no court has ruled that you have to answer any other questions. We'll see how it turns out.
JSullins
Be careful as well, as I've heard of scams relating to so-called census folk and their obtaining of your info. It could have been a scammer trying to get personal info from you, and throwing in the threat as motivation.
CosmicConservative
JSullins, that could be, but my caller ID did come up with "US Census Bureau" or something like that.
Andy
Thanks for clearing it up Cosmic. Sigh...
CosmicConservative
It is my understanding that in spite of these fines being used to threaten people like me, no fine has ever actually been collected other than for not returning the form at all. There are lawyers itching for a fine to be levied so they can turn it into a court challenge.
MoogieP
E - frickin' - gad. Keep us posted, please.
Janelle
Good for you, telling them to go to hell!
US Census Bureau and GPS Targeting | All About GPS
[...] » Called by the Census Bureau… and threatened CosmicConservative: Rational Conservatism ... [...]
The Queen
I had a Census worker show up at my door and tell me, not ask, tell me that I was going to answer a few questions and that it would take about 10 minutes. In the background could be very clearly heard...my 13 month old son wailing at the top of his lungs because he just pooped. I told him that I didn't have time and he could either come back later or wait 5 minutes while I tended to my child. Then he goes on and on about my breaking the law and not returning the census form. That's when I lost my temper and said - what are you f**king talking about?!?!?! I turned that in a month ago. He called me a liar and then he said we don't have any form from your address. I said that's because we've only been living here since April 24th you arrogant little prick! Well, who was living here on April 1st then? Nobody was. The house was vacant because the previous owner DIED around Christmas. He demanded my name and prior address so he could verify my "story". I said I'll give you that when you're done apologizing for being a nasty little prick and after you've sufficiently kissed my ass. Then I slammed my door shut and went to my baby. I expect his supervisor will be visiting this week. :-)
Andy
Sounds like The Queen was having a rough day. ;) But then again, there aren't many easy ones when you have a toddler...
The Queen
Yeah...I'm usually a very nice and polite person. I don't like it when strangers come to my door and start telling me that I have no choice but to answer his questions and imply that I'm a liar. My family came here from Communist Poland and my parents told us lots of stories of how it was back then...they were born in the mid-1930's and survived WW2 and then Stalin. I felt the tactics used by Census dude were a bit more strong armed than necessary. Plus, my baby had a massive turd in his diaper! LOL
Jane
I had another census woman come to my door today, weeks ago a man came by twice, my husband gave him number of people and gender, said that was all he was given them as required by law. Today this woman comes, bangs on my door, I didn't open it, just told her we already filled it out, she says no you didn't do I need to call the Sheriff. THAT was it, last straw, I went outside, told her if she Ever threatened me like that again I'd have the ACLU on her ass immediately. She then hands me this piece of paper with form and I told her, I am not giving you my race, it is not needed [she can see that I am white] and she begins to argue with me and I told her no, it is NOT necessary NOR is it Constitutional and I know my rights, there are Two people in the home and male female gender and that is that. I told her I would hire a Lawyer, I am NOT giving them anymore than that. My husband after I called him called the ACLU, she broke the law threatening me with sheriff though they acted as if they didn't believe him and of course passed the buck--told us to call the Census people, like Yea, right. This really angers me, being Threatened in my home by a Census Worker, in Colorado, for not wanting or Agreeing to give the Government my race, income, how many times I have sex, my Religion, etc., I am a Leftist, I am a Women's Human Rights Activist, I will no way, agree to take Part in what I know has a history of Genocide/and/or violation of Human Rights in This nation [last time they asked for race they then interned the Japanese] and especially after our government didn't even Balk at IRAN being voted to represent Women's Human Rights for the United Nations which is a slap in the face. I no longer have trust in my nation or my government, my husband is Jewish, there is NO WAY, WE WILL, SIGN UP FOR A YELLOW STAR, I guess I'll be going to court, I only pray to God that we will have the support to stand and fight this, because it Is illegal search and seizure, it Is a violation of Human Rights, it Is a violation of Civil Rights. It lays the groundwork for Tyranny and usurping of all the rights those before us Fought for, both right and left, and it is a disgrace that in 2010 we have a President and an Administration that believes they have the right to not only usurp all our rights, and to do so under the Lie of 'concern', but to do so with threats, intimidation, and who knows what else. IF I thought, for one minute, that the information was being used for legit purposes that might, Might, aid in my cooperation but I know from having worked with the poor, the homeless, with women leaving violence, that the information does Nothing to aid anyone, it is for voting and district lines and if they need more than that, there obviously is a purpose that is Anything but representative or beneficial to the citizens of this nation. When they can come our door, without us breaking Any laws, and Threaten us with arrest, it is Totalitarianism. And we need to stand firm and oppose.
Dadman
Jane: You sound more like a right-wing, anti-government militia member than a Leftist. If you've been voting for left-leaning Democrats my hope is you will cease and desist.
Jane
I haven't voted for any Democrat or Republican in years Dadman, I am independent. As for your hope I'll cease and desist, uh, yea, kind of got that totalitarian bent yourself I see, guess dissent not a good thing to you, so Fascism eh? To me don't matter if you are right or left, fascism is fascism [Weber defined 13 different varieties of], and it stinks. I am leftist on numerous issues and conservative on others, mostly pro-Human rights, including Women [yea I got this thing about women being human beings, I know, like shock huh, I didn't drink the women are appendages kool aid, the porn culture, the cultural relativist culture, the consumerist people don't matter culture, the government is 'god' culture] yea it's called Independent thinking, so of course, you want That to cease and desist. Gee, lol, forget worrying about Census, the gods don't need it, they already seem to have You. Jane
Andy
So, Jane...you didn't vote for any Democrat, or Republican in years? Trust me, I'm not being disrespectful here (I hope)...In other words, your vote (if you did vote for anyone) made no difference whatsoever. I am an "Independent," also. But, I can't count on one hand the number of Independent candidates that have been elected to any meaningful office in my lifetime. And, I'm sure that I am older than you. I have voted for both Republicans, and Democrats. Ya' know...like somebody that actually has a CHANCE to win, and maybe direct policy in a meaningful way. I am going to respectfully submit to you that people who refuse to vote for anyone in the two major parties really doesn't care about accomplishing anything. They throw protest votes that land on fallow ground, and do no good. I respect, and admire your slap at the Census people. But, the best way to avoid that in the future is go out and elect some people with a chance of winning, that actually MIGHT change it.
Dadman
Jane: You sound confused so I'll give you a pass on calling someone you've never met a 'fascist'. You're quickly convincing me you're a 'Leftist' afterall, however. I've found they are very good at name-calling. By the way, I'm an indepedent conservative who's voted for both Dems and Republicans over the years. Lately, I'm rather sick of both political parties, but if you're interested in liberty (and independent thinking as you claim) I suggest you not vote for Democrats in the next national election cycle. They'll have you begging for THEIR permission to adjust your thermostat or buy a cheeseburger if they get their way. The census is only part and parcel of the control they would really like to wield over your life and the lives of all Americans. Dump the Dems in November!
JSullins
Jane sounds confused, indeed. It is a shame that passionate but ultimately ignorant people like her won't take the time to learn the truth.