Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Calvin & Hobbes ruminations

By CosmicConservative
So I have probably mentioned before that I have a number of Calvin & Hobbes comic strip compilations. In fact I may have the complete set of them, including the full hardback three-volume set that is still shrink-wrapped on my bookshelf. Bill Watterson, Calvin's creator, has always been somewhat reclusive, but his thoughts on why he created the strip, how he battled the syndicates for creative control, and how he refused to license products based on Calvin & Hobbes, have been known for about two decades now. In fact all of those Calvin & Hobbes decals you see on cars and trucks are all unlicensed trademark and copyright infringements because Mr. Watterson himself has refused to allow images from his strip to be reproduced in any way other than as comic strips. Many of his fans find his stance on licensing merchandise to be as incomprehensible as his decision to retire the strip when it was at the height of its popularity and was arguably the most popular comic strip in the world. I have always defended Mr. Watterson's right to walk away and refuse to license his characters, and I've even done so here on this blog. But one thing that has been bugging me lately is that I wonder how plugged into the modern world Mr. Watterson actually is. He recently surfaced at some college for a short interview and public commentary, and he repeated much of what his final words on the subject were some 20 years ago, mostly all about the comic strip syndicate, how they want creative control and the declining commitment of newspapers to the medium of comic strips. It made me wonder if Mr. Watterson has even given any thought at all to the world of internet web-comics, a means of producing and distributing an artist's work that avoids pretty much every constraint that Mr. Watterson has so pointedly complained about for 30 years. Webcomics have no format restrictions save that it has to be served up in a browser on a computer monitor. Some of the best web comics are visually compelling in ways that newspapers never could have managed to support. One of my favorite strips, "Girl Genius" is renowned for it's compelling visuals, including both style and format. This strip, from the current story arc, shows just how dynamic and flexible the webcomic format can be. So this makes me wonder if Bill Watterson has bothered to investigate a medium and distribution model that seems perfectly suited to his style, and seems to have answered all of his complaints about drawing comic strips. And if so, why hasn't he returned with either more Calvin & Hobbes or a new strip (I'd love to see "Spaceman Spiff" as a comic strip, for example). In the end I have to wonder if he's just grown complacent and is more than willing to spend the rest of his life living off his ten-year phenomenon. If so that would be a shame.

Comments (8)

Cullen
Just look at what XKCD has accomplished with stick figures. I think the best example for Watterson would probably be Scott Adams and Dilbert. While Adams doesn't have the licensing issues Watterson did, his web presence is a great example. He could make the transition to web-only comic easily, I think.
JSullins
Never could like Girl Genius. Bugged me. I do have some others I follow, though.
CosmicConservative
The reason I used "Girl Genius" as an example is because of the complete disregard for traditional comic strip layout and the gloriously rich and evocative artwork. Dilbert is just a comic strip on the web, his strips would fit perfectly in the modern newspaper strip format (and in fact do appear in newspapers). Girl Genius is much more like what Watterson publicly says he wanted to do but was unable to do because of newspaper format restrictions. Girl Genius panels are of variable size, the story might be captured in one strip with an extravagant and huge background visual, overlaid with smaller vignettes of varying size and shape which advance the story while the eye lingers on the magnificant background. When I first encountered Girl Genius I didn't immediately become a fan. I'm not into "steam punk" in general. But the visual intensity and unique style drew me in and eventually I became interested in the story. There's a reason Girl Genius is one of the, if not the, most popular webcomic on the internet.
JSullins
Well, Girl Genius is certainly well known, but most of the comic-ratings out there put it far down the list ;) Believe it or not, Girl Genius is a little bit old-school imho. Ok, now I'm just being a jerk! This is one that really is rated among the top, often is the top: http://requiem.seraph-inn.com/viewcomic.php?page=1 Although it is "top rated" it is not really my favorite. That distinction probably goes to: http://www.gunnerkrigg.com/index2.php To each his own, of course. Phoenix Requiem caters to a different audience -- perhaps that is why it is more popular. Hint: if you like Twilight, you'll like Phoenix Requiem.
CosmicConservative
Heh, I better wait until I get home to click those links. Based on your hint I'll assume I wouldn't like "requiem". I have several webcomics I read almost daily. The short list I can remember here would be: Girl Genius XKCD Order of the Stick Dilbert Yet Another Fantasy Gamer Comic (YAFGC) Questionable Content I used to read "Sluggy Freelance" until they did the story arc where they apparently killed off Zoe. After that it just got bizarre and I lost interest in it. I should check back and see if it's gotten back on track again. I checked out a strip called "Full Frontal Nerdity" but it's pretty lame usually. I'll check out GunnerKrigg... even though the Wiki entry reveals it's quite obviously heavily influenced by anime and manga.... I should pass it on to the Cosmic Daughter, she likes that sort of thing. But then again, she likes Twilight.... hmm.
Cullen
You should check out Amazing Super Powers, too. Tradition format but those guys are freaking hilarious. I like online comic books too. The Adventures of Dr. McNinja is great if you're into that sort of thing.
Dadman
I've never understood why Watterson consistently refused to market Calvin & Hobbes as art prints at the very least...or even calendars. The media would allow the art to be displayed in its full glory unlike decals, mugs, lunchboxes, etc. Oh well. Genuis can be quirky. BTW, I am working on a web comic concept and currently working through some of the technical issues. I may have some questions for you, Cosmic. Can't wait to get it online...
JSullins
Dr. McNinja, hehe. I used to read that one but lost interest. The first story arc was the best.