Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Why I oppose any ban on flag burning

By CosmicConservative
The vote was close last night in D.C. Believe me, as a son of an Air Force veteran and brother to both another Air Force veteran and a Navy veteran, and as a committed conservative, I find burning the American flag deeply offensive. But I do not support any legislation to ban flag burning because it's just a waste of time and political grandstanding anyway. The SCOTUS will overturn any statute banning flag burning anyway. The only way to get flag burning criminalized in the U.S.A. is through a Constitutional Amendment. And I oppose that for the following reasons: 1. There are far more important things to spend our political capital on than banning flag burning. 2. I don't believe that "offensive" and "criminal" are the same thing. This is exactly what conservatives give liberals grief about, so I consider it hypocritical to rail against "political correctness" laws and then try to create what is essentially an exercise in political correctness myself. 3. I don't really mind being able to identify the moonbats in our society and watching someone burn a U.S. flag is a pretty good way to identify them. I consider it sort of an early warning system for locating the looniest of the fever swamp denizens. 4. It is unquestionably painful, frustrating and maddening to watch, but I can handle it. 5. On rare occasions I can accept that such a striking political statement might actually be justified. For example, if the U.S. were to accept that the International Criminal Court had jurisdiction over U.S. citizens, then you could argue that the U.S. as a sovereign state had ceased to exist, and burning a flag to make that point seems justified to me. Just my thoughts.

Comments (14)

Drax
I'm a bit split on this one. There are some acts which are so deeply offensive that they simply should not be allowed. Thus far, the Constitution protects those who choose to burn the American Flag from criminal prosecution. A Constitutional Amendment MIGHT change this (we NEVER know how a court will INTERPRET anything...so "might.") The burning of the flag is intended to offend, and it is intended to offend those who have deeply held patriotic feelings. It is "speech" only because the Supremes SAY it is (and, this is, at least, "arguable.") The content of the "speech" certainly could be conveyed through ACTUAL speech or through OTHER actions which convey the same idea. (Crushing a model of the Statue of Liberty, a shattered Liberty Bell, felling of a model of Lincoln, or whatever.) Perhaps even more effectively, since these icons of America generally stand for specific ideas, while the flag stands for the totality of America. So. I wouldn't object to a Constitutional Amendment on this issue. If a sufficient number of Americans found the burning of the flag to be so offensive that they would vote for this Amendment, then so be it. And, I have no problem with this as an expenditure of political capital, as it is one which clearly identifies where the heart of the politician lies, who they cater to, how firm they are in their beliefs on this subject. It could be a great cry to rally around.
CosmicConservative
Good points, and I am not heavily invested in the question one way or the other, but on balance I remain opposed to criminalizing burning the flag. I just think it's a side issue and if the flag is deserving of respect, it will get the respect it is due from the people whose opinion actually matters.
Aaron
I don't like this flag burning amendment one bit. I'm an absolutist on free speech. Even though I think the people who burn our flag and spit on the greatest thing to happen to mankind (America) are worms, and shouldn't be living here, I do not want laws made for symbolic acts. There are some acts which are so deeply offensive that they simply should not be allowed. Not in my opinion there aren't! The only acts which should ever be restrained by physical violence (the government - a law manifests as police officers arresting and jailing people at gunpoint in reality) are acts which cause physical harm. That's why I'm absolutely for a free internet. That's why I'm absolutely for freedom of speech, and I believe that includes any symbol, no matter how offensive it is. When we start in on the road where a symol, where an idea or an expression of one, can be outlawed on the basis that it offends people, we've trashed the first amendment. People speak of slippery slopes, but in principle, in the case of the first amendment, there is no slope! It's cliff. On or off, free or not free. Either people can jail you because you offend them, or they cannot. When our founding fathers drafted the first amendment, they did it to prevent sectarian warfare. They did it to prevent the outlawing of ideas and thoughts because they were "offensive" or "heretical" or against mainstream opinions. Sure, burning the American flag is heretical and sick. Show me the nation that ever succumbed for tolerating heresy.
Aaron
PS, had it passed, I'm sure that the ACLU would be prosecuting boyscouts left and right for learning how to properly dispose of the flag.
CosmicConservative
Aaron, the only thing I would dispute is the contention that freedom is "on or off". It is my belief that freedom is by necessity a continuum where on the one side you have Socialism, where the individual is completely subserviant to the collective, and on the other side you have anarchy, where the individual is completely unfettered. In between those two extremes you have "liberty" which is when as many freedoms as possible are protected by the government with an understanding that some acts cannot be allowed no matter how much an individual wants to do them because they are too harmful to society as a whole. And this includes expression, as the SCOTUS famously ruled that free speech does not protect the right to yell "fire" in a crowded theater. Similarly you cannot wantonly slander or libel a person's reputation under the guise of "free speech" even though such attacks are non-violent ones. You also cannot reveal classified information that would damage the security of the nation. I could go on. Within the continuum of acceptable speech, I would put flag burning on the "offensive but acceptable" side for the reasons I've already stated. But I would not defend burning the flag under some sort of absolutism in freedom of speech. I don't believe such a thing does or can exist.
Aaron
Right, but in those cases, we're talking about putting people in physical danger (through treason or yelling fire). As to slander, you'd never know it was outlawed in todays ... well, nevermind. But here we're talking about the right to offend people. I don't think there's any continuum there. If people can jail you for offending them (and the government is composed of people of no loftier caste than the average American, nominally at least), in what sense can speech be said to be protected? What absolute basis would you pick to define what acts are too offensive to allow? (And things aren't objectively offensive. They offend someone. Who gets to have what offends him legislated away?)
Drax
Aaron: To say you're an "absolutist" on free speech is going a bit far, isn't it? Especially when you're talking not about actual speech, but constructive speech, i.e., NOT "talking" but "doing." I said: "There are some acts which are so deeply offensive that they simply should not be allowed." You replied: "Not in my opinion there aren’t! The only acts which should ever be restrained by physical violence (the government - a law manifests as police officers arresting and jailing people at gunpoint in reality) are acts which cause physical harm." Now. Without being too offensive here, your position would allow for people to stand on the street corner exposing themselves to little children. Mine would not. Now, if you agree that THIS act is one which is "so deeply offensive" that it should be prohibited (and I can think of a whole TON of others which cause no physical harm...) then you have ACCEPTED my premise, just not whether or not THIS act is one which should be prohibited. In other words, if you agree that people shouldn't be able to defecate in public, masterbate in public, copulate in public, etc.., then, the question isn't WHETHER some acts should be prohibited, but WHICH ones should. If, however, you don't accept that there is even a single act which should be prohibited in public unless it causes physical harm, then, well, your level of tolerence far exceeds that of anyone I can imagine. Most rational people will agree that some acts, regardless of WHY they are performed in front of others (and, if they aren't performed in front of others, they aren't "speech") and regardless of whether they even have the POTENTIAL to cause physical hard, are simply unacceptable. The tough question, generally, is which ones should be prohibited and which ones should be accepted.
Aaron
I'm almost willing to conceed your point. I'll have to think about it some more. The tough question, generally, is which ones should be prohibited and which ones should be accepted. The problem is that your political/ideological/religious opponents will never find it anywhere near as tough a question as you do.
Aaron
Perhaps a better question to ask is this: Is there any objective standard that you use to parse acceptable from criminal speech that can be referred to? Something that can be held up as more than the whim of those who hold power?
Drax
Therein lies the rub, and why, in obscenity cases the Supremes use "community standards" to determine what is and what is not obscene. When we're talking about just "words," it gets rather difficult to determine what should and should not be allowed. Treasonous speech, of course, is forbidden (this begs the question of what actually is treasonous, heh). Speech intended to start a riot...."FIRE!" in a crowded theater or some such. What about the "nazi" advocates who seem to urge their followers to actually harm others....? Constructive speech is even more difficult, as there are no words to examine. So...we're kind of forced into a "majority rule" format, balanced by the "protection of minority rights" rule, along with "free exchange of ideas" rule....heh. It's an extraordinary balancing act without any clear lines. And, what lines there are seem to be constantly shifting (Carlin's 7 dirty words skit, for example....). The most important thing is that we continue to discuss what we can discuss, how we can discuss it, where we can discuss it. The more involved in these discussions, the easier it is to determine just where those lines are currently drawn.
CosmicConservative
Taking the "majority rules" approach is getting perilously close to Jefferson's "tyranny of the masses" and is one of the most common excuses the Left uses to justify their political correctness jihads. Leaving what is offensive up to the majority is problematical at best, and potentially prejudicial at worst. But the alternative is what we have now, an elitist approach to what is "acceptable" determined essentially by nine people in black robes who answer to nobody for their decisions. Or perhaps it is more accurate to say it is determined by five or more people in black robes. Free speech controls may not be tthe "cliff" Aaron described, but there is definitely a slope and it is slippery enough. When flag burning is "outlawed" what happens when I make a flag with six pointed stars and fifteen white and red stripes? Is that "flag burning"? Or what if I decide to burn an replica of the Declaration of Independence? Or an effigy of the President? I haven't even given it more than a few minutes thought, but I can think of a dozen ways to get around a "flag burning ban" amendment and still offend you as much as I would like because although I may not be burning an actual flag, you would know what I meant just as if I had. It's just too much work, too easily avoided. It invites expanding the definition of flag to capture more of the offensive acts until you end up with the Supreme Court deciding "I can't define 'flag' but I know one when I see one."
Drax
Heh, I understand...which is why I said: "we’re kind of forced into a “majority rule” format, balanced by the “protection of minority rights” rule, along with “free exchange of ideas” rule." We're all pretty well agreed that SOME things just shouldn't be said/done, and that some things shouldn't be said/done in certain circumstances. But, after that, we're pretty adrift, since speech, by definition, is subject to interpretation. Art for one is obscenity for another, for example. However, there IS a "point" where enough people, an overwhelming majority of people, decide for themselves the nature of the speech in question -- and labels it accordingly, by their reaction to it. Today, with the internet, changing mores on television and elsewhere, at an incredibly accelerated pace, the definition keeps changing, almost on a daily basis. At this pace, we will soon come to a place when burning the flag will cause no more of a raised eyebrow than burning any other piece of colored cloth. (I still remember a time when wearing a flag on a piece of clothing did much more than "raise an eyebrow," lol.)
CosmicConservative
Who was it who said that burning the flag was the political equivalent of a grunt? Social mores and standards are slippery slopes themselves. You remember a time when a flag worn as a do-rag was an insult, and yet now it is much more frequently intended as a patriotic statement to do the same thing. And who can argue against flag bikinis? But I digress... I still say that there is no way to enforce such a ban, and attempts to do so will do more harm than good. Let them burn the flag, it says more about the burner than the burnee. The number of political expressions that offend me grow every day, but I haven't yet come to the point that I want to silence the ones that offend me. I am sure some of my own political statements offend others. And I do find something admirable in a society that tolerates such things with a wry shaking of the head, instead of repressing such things with the swinging of a truncheon.
Drax
As I said, I'm a bit split on this one. I'm a HUGE proponent of free speech, and, frankly, I'm with you that those burning the flag are telling more of themselves than are those who are offended by the act. However, if enough people are sufficiently inscensed about it that they sign off on a Constitutional Amendment to stop it, then, I have no problem with that either. It just sticks in my craw that, for the most part, many of those who so vehemently advocate for "free speech" on THIS issue, are frequently the same ones who shout you down if you're white attempting to discuss black culture...or wish to talk about God in schools (or heaven forfend....have the 10 Commandments on a public courthouse)...or any issue with which they disagree. These (mostly liberal) "free speechers" believe only in free speech which promotes THEIR agenda. Most conservatives who advocate "free speech," swallowing their disgust with those who burn the flag, do so because they want ALL speech to be free (to the extent possible in a somewhat civilized nation of laws).